𝐂𝐡𝐚𝐬𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰 {AURALESCENTXREADER}

Chapter 21: Do you Really Not Trust Me?

NSFW 🔞

"Y/n!" she jumps at Jakes voice and realizes she has tears in her eyes. Matthew and Ashley seem to hear it too and turn around.

His heart drops when he sees her angered face, but what hurts him the most is the way she wipes a single tear that slides down her cheek and turns around.

"Fuck." he whispers standing up and chasing after her. "Wait it's not what it look likes-" he reaches for her arm but she turns around to slap him hard.

"DO YOU KNOW HOW FUCKING STUPID I FEEL!?" Everyone in the parking lot stares at them while Ashley tries explaining. "W-Wait! He's right! I'm-"

She gets slapped to, so hard it makes her tumble to the ground. "AND YOU! YOU FUCKING BITCH! AFTER EVERYTHING I DID FOR YOU."

"I'm sorry but you can't be mad, not when your the one who's been going behind my back." Matthew snaps.

Jake sighs, "Imma get some fries, brb." then struts away.

"Me!? I've been working my ass off for you!" she scoffs as more tears begin to fall down her face. "THEN WHY THE FUCK ARE YOU WITH JAKE?"

"I WAS TRYING TO SURPRISE YOU YOU FUCKING IDIOT." She tries screaming but her voice cracks a sob breaks free.

Matthews look softens into a confused look, "Surprise me?"

"YES! WHILE YOU WERE BUSY FUCKING THIS BITCH I WAS PLANNING YOUR BIRTHDAY-" She suddenly gets tackled down by Ashley who holds her down.

"CAN YOU AT LEAST LISTEN TO US!?"

Y/n pants heavily as Ashley sighs, "I don't like Matthew.. I like girls. If anything, I liked you!"

There's a brief pause before she shoves Ashley off of her. "You really expect me to believe that?" she stands up and glances at Matthew one last time, "Do you really not trust me?" he asks, his own voice cracking.

"No.. but apparently you don't either." Y/n calls it off with Jake and gets in her car, not bothering to look back.

She locks herself in the bathroom once she gets home, she wants to cry.

Maybe it's the fact that she loves him, but she wants to forgive him. Why does it hurt so much?

The door to the apartment opens and slams, she hears the fridge then a clink!

"I know you're in there." Matthew calls out from the kitchen chugging down on the beer. Y/n leans against the door and asks "Why're you drinking?"

Ashley had a fake ID too, she had bought those beers for fun but Matthew didn't drink much, he was a lightweight.

"Ashley's at her girlfriends house, I dropped her off." he says ignoring her previous question and opening another beer.

She unlocks the door and walks to the kitchen, he's leaning against the counter and keeps his eyes on the ground.

"You promise you're not lying?" her voice is shaking and she wants to run into his arms.

he chuckles, the beer is already gone and he seems pissed. "I promise." When he stares at her straight in the eyes she flinches.

Sure, Matthew looked hot as hell when he was mad but this version was terrifying. The tension, the way he's staring at her as if he wants to devour her.