A Time Before We Knew ~ Fuyuhiko x reader prequel+AUs+Unused Ideas

If Y/n had killed someone

Well this starts depressing ig-)

Fuyuhiko POV

There they were. Covered in Hiyoko's blood. Hiyoko had provoked Y/n till they lashed out. They beat Hiyoko repeatedly until Hiyoko stopped breathing. Hiyoko... was dead. And me and Y/n were the only ones who knew.

"You won't tell, right Fuyuhiko?" They ask.

"Y/n... I-I don't know- What- what should I do?" I don't know anymore- They- They killed- I mean- I know that I have before- but... But I didn't want this...

"Just don't tell... Don't tell and we'll get out of here together," They whisper into my ear.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"Wait- So Y/n killed Hiyoko? Not Nekomaru like we thought before?" Hajime asks.

"N-No way! Why would I kill Hiyoko?!" Y/n yelled.

"Hiyoko had been teasing Y/n since the beginning of the game..." Akane says.

"B-But that's no reason to kill!" I exclaim.

"Well then- there's the motive," Hajime says.

"W-Wha?!" Y/n exclaims.

"The motive that you can take one person with you if you don't get figured out," Hajime says.

"Hajime! I can't believe you! My own cousin! Suspecting me of murder!" Y/n exclaims. I can tell they're nervous.

"I don't want to suspect you Y/n, believe me, but the way the evidence adds up, this is your pendant, why would it be there? You aren't wearing it now after all," Hajime says.

"That's..." Y/n starts.

"You fucking idiot! Do you really think Y/n would kill someone?!" I yell without thinking.

"I agree with Fuyuhiko!" Peko exclaims.

"L/n-san wouldn't kill anyone!" Peko yells.

"Yeah! Hajime... I can't believe you..." Y/n says.

"I'LL CUT THROUGH YOUR WORDS!" Hajime shouts. That- That was so lame- Did that really just happen?

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"They're guilty... I told you... Fuyuhiko and Peko..." Hajime says.

"I'm sorry Y/n..." Hajime says a tear rolling down his face.

"You're... You're right Hajime. I guess... Maybe being smart is your talent? The Ultimate investigator? Who knows, I won't tell them your secret, don't worry," Y/n says. What secret?

"Welp, Monokuma start the vote!" Y/n exclaims.

"I guess even you don't remember Hajime, heh, I'll take to my grave, I'll keep your integrity as 'An Ultimate Student'," They say.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"An almost Unanimous vote for Y/n L/n!" Monokuma exclaims.

"Peko Pekoyama voted for herself! How strange!" Monokuma exclaims again.

"Pekoyama-San...?" Y/n asks. Peko rushes up and hugs them.

Y/n POV

"I'm Sorry L/n-San... You should've told me to kill Hiyoko... I would have done it... Because I love you," Peko cries. I hug her tight.

"It'll be okay Pekoyama-san," I whisper before letting go.

"Don't blame yourself Hajime, you too Fuyuhiko-kun, and you Pekoyama-San I love you all," I smile with closed eyes.

"Hurry up and execute me Monokuma! I'll survive! I'll show you!" I yell. I see Fuyuhiko cry.

"Don't go... Y/n!" He yells after me. I turn around to look at him, and smile.

I'm lifted up by a noose around my wrist.

I'm in a pitch black room now. A figure walks towards me.

"Nanny?" I ask. It's really her. I start running to her, but she's drifting further away. I scream for her as I run towards her. I run past razor saws. I start jumping from one saw to another, dodging each saw as I go. I slowly get cut because of the speed of the saws. I finally make it to my Nanny, but... She's dead. Just like that day. Then-

Fuyuhiko POV

A figure of her father bashes her skull in with a driver golf club.