numb || winchester!sister series

Chapter 3

Sam's eyes widen, 'Wait. How d-'

'When I left for college, dad gave it to me. He said that it'll keep it hidden if I kept it. That's why I know that that's not dad.'

'We're going to have to tell Dean, right now.'

I nodded, figuring out a way to lure him out without "dad" being suspicious. Texting Dean that the car has a scratch on it, he rushed outside to the car.

'Dean!' I whispered to my oldest brother, motioning him to come. He came up the roof as he tried to figure out who messed up his car.

'Did you see who did it?' Dean asked, furious.

'I only said that so you can come up here. I need to tell you something Dean.' As I look over at him, I told him about Dad possibly being possessed.

He huffed, not believing what I said. 'You know what Y/N, if you didn't want to come and save dad you could've said so.'

'Dean, I have proof.' I said as I tried to stop him from leaving.

'Sure, your made up stories are great proof. Like I'm going to believe that.' He shrugged my hand off, stomping away back to the room.

I looked down, disappointed at myself. Dean used to have my back all the time. What did I do to make Dean hate me so much?

Sam put his hand on my shoulder. 'I'm sorry, Y/N...'

'We're just going to have to do this without him.'

He nodded, 'So what's the plan?'

As I explained Sam the plan, we went back inside. Dean looked over at me and gave a stern look which made my heart drop. The relationship with Dean became worse at this point and I wish I can do something to make it right.

'Hey kiddo, you're doing alright?' dad said as he gave me a warm smile. It hurt my heart to see dad's body right in front of me, knowing that it really wasn't him.

I nodded, 'Yeah dad. Matter of fact, Sam and I wanted to celebrate this family reunion with some beer. You up for it?'

He chuckled, 'Alright alright, one beer before we hit the hay.'

'Dean c'mon let's have a drink.' I smiled at my oldest brother. I know he wouldn't say no to beer.

Sam brought four beers from the fridge, 'Cheers to the Winchesters.'

As we cheered with the bottle on our hands, we started drinking. I walked over to dad and gave him a hug. 'I'm sorry.' I spoke softly as I slowly tie a rope around him.

'What's going on?' dad slightly laughed, not struggling to get out.

'We know you're not dad.' Sam confessed.

Dean huffed, 'Y/N, what the hell? I told you stop with his nonsense.'

'You know it's me, Y/N. Listen to your brother.'

'No.'

'Cut the bullshit. Untie the knot. Sam, don't encourage her.' argued Dean.

Dad started laughing devilishly, 'Dean, you really are the dumbest one here aren't you?'

He turned to dad, confused. 'What are you talking about.'

'These two aren't even hunters anymore and they've figured it out. And you didn't?' He then revealed his yellow eyes.

'I'm sorry, Dean. I just knew it wasn't dad and I had to do something.' I apologized to Dean as I pulled out the Colt. Dean's eyes widen, surprised that I have it.

'Wow, the little sister with the special Colt? I'm assuming your daddy handed that to you?' Azazel, the yellow eyed demon chuckled.

As I aim the gun at the demon, I howled. 'And what if he did?'

'Just means that he loves you deeply doesn't it? He could've handed it to Dean, his only son that's a true hunter but gave it to you instead? What a shame for you huh, Dean?'

'Dean, don't listen to him.' I shouted.

'Sammy and Y/N left for college and enjoyed life while you were stuck being daddy's little puppet.'

Dean kept a straight face as he heard his dad confess to him. Sam then reassured him, 'Dean, it's not dad speaking. Don't listen.'

'I swear if you keep talking, I'm going to shoot you.'

'You better not Y/N, you'll kill dad.' hollered Dean.

Azazel chuckled, 'Just do it, Y/N. You'll get to kill me, the demon that ended your mother's life. Plus your dad won't shut up about you shooting me. He also says hi to you all. What a charming father.'

All my life we were looking for the monster that killed mom and now he's right here in front of me. Revenge is something I'm deeply craving, especially after he killed Alex but I couldn't do it. I didn't want to end dad's life as well.

'C'mon, just shoot!' Azazel chuckled, 'You know, Alex was talking about you when I visited your cute dorm.'

'Don't talk about him.'

'He said to keep my hands away from you. That he loved you and he'd want to sacrifice his life for you.'

'Stop. Shut up!' Tears shed down my eyes, unable to control my emotion.

'Killing him was such a —' Sam interrupted him by taking the Colt from my hand and shooting his leg, causing dad to collapse on the ground.

Azazel groaned in pain, then his yellow eyes turned back to dad's. Sam, Dean and I quickly kneeled next to dad. As dad tried to catch his breath, Dean untied the rope around his body.

'Kill me and kill this demon. Please.' Dad spoke under his breath.

'Let us help you dad, please.' I sobbed, crying about the whole situation. I wasn't ready to lose my father.

He gave a soft smile, 'Sweet pea, I love you so much. But we have to.'

Dad then turned to Dean. 'You know what you have to do.'

'No sir, this isn't the only choice. We can help, I promise.'

'Please, dad.' Sam whispered.

He chuckled as he shook his head. Then dad quickly took the Colt from Sam, drawing the gun to his own head and pulled the trigger.