Friendzone

What if... Pt. 2

A/N: Please leave comments. I worked on this all night. I'll do my best to update soon. Share with friends. I really hope you enjoy reading this. Thank you for the support

Matthew's POV:
So many thoughts are crossing my mind at the moment. I can literally hear my heartbeat. I knew it was too good to be true. Why am I such an idiot thinking such a great girl would fall for me? I feel something warm on my face. Is that normal? Matthew get yourself together and pretend like you didn't see that. Remember you should never let the other person know you're hurt. Be strong. After what seems like hours of telling myself what to do I smile and pretend I'm fine
"Hello I'm Matthew"
"Hi there I'm Kate" the girl in front of me smiles and shakes my hand
"Nice to meet you, Kate. I'm looking for Catherine. Is she here?"
She pauses and frowns but quickly recovers by smiling "I'll get her for you. Oh my where are my manners please come in"
"Thank you" I say as I walk inside the house avoiding letting Catherine know I saw her "May I sit there?" I point to the couch
"Of course you can. Do you want anything to drink?"
"Water please" she walks upstairs and disappears
This house looks better inside than outside. It'd be fair to say it fits her personality. Since I don't know how long I'll have to wait for Kate to come back I'll just check what's on Twitter
Catherine's P.O.V:
"Please Miguel you shouldn't be here. You succeeded at ruining us. I already moved on so just leave and never come back"
This is a total nightmare. I was already over him and over crying because of how much pain he caused. I need a miracle to make him leave and never appear in my life again. I should really stop checking my phone but I can't stop admitting to myself that I miss Matthew. Why hasn't he talked to me? What if I did something wrong? No no no I wouldn't be able to handle hurting him. He's so amazing and deserves the best. Miguel's voice brings me back to reality. Damn why does he always have to ruin everything?
"Catherine I've changed. I was a jerk before but not anymore. I..."
I hear a knock on the door I'm sure Kate can deal with that. I'm caught off guard when he wraps his arms around me and kisses me. As I try to pull away and not fall in his trap I hear a male voice but can't recognize it. Is it just me or did I hear that the male's name is Matthew? No it can't be. After all he's far from here. Catherine focus. How the hell do I get this jerk off of me? Lucky for me Kate walks in
"Asshole let her go and get the hell out of here!"
Thankfully Miguel does as Kate says. I hug her "Thank you Kate for getting him to leave"
"He never deserved my best friend" she says as she hugs back "By the way there's someone in the living room" she smirks "The cutie says his name is Matthew and asked for you specifically. Why didn't you tell me you knew someone so handsome? I was supposed to get him water but you can do that instead" she winks
I absolutely love how honest she is except when she wants to give me a lecture about a guy. But wait that means it wasn't my mind making it up. He's really here. I'm freaking out! Breathe.... Breathe.... Breathe!!!! Before I walk to the living room I hear voices
"Who the hell are you!?" Miguel says
"I don't want any trouble" Matthew says calmly "Please"
"You're looking for trouble being here. It's my girl's house so you need to leave"
"Kate's?"
"No you idiot. I'm Catherine's boyfriend. I'm guessing she didn't tell you" Miguel laughs. That jerk! This won't end well I need to stop this. On my way to the living room I stop by the kitchen to get a glass of water. I make my way to the living room and face Miguel to throw the water on his face
"Get out! And to make everything clear in that fucked up mind of yours I AM NO LONGER YOUR GIRLFRIEND. You've caused enough damage. Do something better with your life and stop ruining others"
My whole body is shaking from how mad I am but I don't care. I'm just not going to let this jerk ruin someone else's life
"It's her house but I don't mind teaching you a lesson so you do what she said" I really hope Matthew doesn't mean that because I honestly don't want him to be in trouble. After a few minutes of silence and angry stares Miguel leaves
"I need a glass of water immediately" I say
"May I have one too, please?" Matthew says. I totally forgot for a moment that he's really here. I walk to the kitchen smiling
"Cutie and is a bad ass willing to protect you from Miguel. As a bonus he made you smile. He's definitely a keeper" leave the love lectures to Kate "You're totally blushing!"
"Kate keep it down"
"I'm sure you won't say that when he's keeping it down" she smirks
"Gross"
"Typical virgin word. But have you seen that body he has. Damn that white button up shirt clearly doesn't hide those abs. He wore a tie for you. Kinky" I need more friends "As much as I enjoy messing with my virgin best friend I have a date. Now you two can be alone" we hug and she leaves
After debating on what I should say I nervously walk to the living room with two glasses of water then sit next to Matthew
"Here's your water" I really need to get Kate's words out of my mind
Matthew's POV:
"Here's your water"
She's so gorgeous in person. I take a sip of my water. Then place the cup of water on the small table. Then get lost in her baby blue eyes
"Matthew..."
"Oh I'm sorry did you say something?"
"I asked what made you come visit and how long will you be staying or do you have family that lives around here?" Her voice is so soft. I'd love to hear her voice daily
"Actually I really don't know anyone around here. It was an impulse decision I made while thinking of you" (But you definitely didn't expect to see her kissing a guy that wasn't you) the voice in my head reminds me
"Awe Matthew that's so sweet. I'm so happy you're here" she hugs me not realizing she's spilling water on my clothes
"I'm so sorry I didn't mean to" she quickly grabs napkins attempting to fix the mess on my clothes "please let me get those dry for you. I'll get you a towel so you can take your clothes on. It'll only be until they're dry" she walks upstairs. I undo my tie and the buttons on my shirt. She walks back to the living room. I smile when I notice how red her cheeks get when she sees I'm shirtless. I grab the towel wrap it around my waist take my pants and boxers off then give her my clothes. When she's walking away I can't help but stare at her ass. Perfect for bending her over and... I need to calm down she deserves full respect
"Again I'm really sorry I spilled water on your clothes"
I pull her close and hug her suddenly feeling her heart beating really fast "It's okay it was an accident"
After so many hours of talking to the beautiful girl in front of me and laughing I check the time. 9pm. Wow time flies by
"Since you mentioned not knowing anyone around here you can stay here as long as you'd like"
(That wouldn't be a good idea) says the voice in my mind
"I'll love to if it's okay with you. I brought some clothes I'll get them from my car"
"Oh so you had extra clothes and waited until I saw you half naked to tell me" she playfully pushes my shoulder and we both burst into laughter
"I'm innocent"
"Sure you are. You're Matthew the not innocent guy"
"If you say so" I smile and get my stuff from the car
Time flies by again I wake up in a room sweating. She's not around was I dreaming but wait this isn't my room. I take my shirt and pj pants off staying in boxers. I walk out of the room looking for the kitchen and notice a door is open. The light is on. I need to know if it was real. I quietly walk in the room and see Catherine. She's so adorable while she sleeps. I grab her blanket and cover her then kiss her forehead and turns her light off
"Matthew" she says quietly. Damn even the way she says my name is adorable
"Yes? Do you need anything?"
"Stay please"
"Are you okay?
"I'm freezing. Please stay"
I turn the light on. I swear her clothes was on just a second ago "whoa" I can't help but stare at how perfect her body is even if she still has her bra and panties on they fit her perfectly. She quickly stares at my boxers and giggles. Seriously this is embarrassing
"I'm sorry" I place my hand over my boxers
"It's okay" she's still giggling which makes me smile "Wanna cuddle? Your friend can join?" I'll totally get payback for that. I quickly turn the light off and lay in bed to cuddle with her. She presses her ass against me. Does she know what she's causing and how difficult it is to control this? She turns places one leg between mine, lays her head on my chest, and her hand close to the waistband of my boxers. She's a complete tease for sure