Aries: zero
Taurus: Jeff (probably drank half before giving it to you lmao)
Gemini: laughing jack
Cancer: bloody painter
Leo: Masky
Virgo: Judge Angel
Libra: Nina the killer
Scorpio: Clockwork
Sagittarius: Jane the killer
Capricorn: Hoodie
Aquarius: Ben drowned
Pisces: Candy Pop