Supernatural short stories

GWH confrontation

The motorcycle roared to a stop.

Benny took his helmet off and double-checked google maps. Yup, this was the place. He parked the bike and set his helmet on the handlebars.

He approached the house and took a deep breath before knocking on the front door.

The door opened as much as the door chain allowed.

"Uh hello?" A man with completely messed up hair peered through the crack.

"Are you Cas Novak?" Benny asked.

"Yes, and you are?"

"My name's Benny. I'm a friend of Dean's."

"What?" Cas laughed, "you're joking?"

"No I'm not."

"He's never mentioned you before, what are you doing here?"

"Well, we're old friends. Haven't spoken in a while. We just met up again this morning."

"Oh," Cas spat. Then he slammed the door.

"Hey!" Benny yelled. The door stayed closed.

"Open this door!" Benny was ready to kick it down if necessary. He didn't have to because a few seconds later he heard the lock clicking.

Cas yanked the door open all the way with a glare. He laced venom into his words, "what the hell do you want?"

"A fucking explanation. An' I ain't leaving until I get one."

"Explanation? Explanation! From me?" Cas laughed dryly, "I should be the one demanding an explanation from Dean!"

"What? No! It's-" Benny took a deep breath, "alright now, why do- why do you want an explanation from Dean? What did he do?"

"Don't you know? Weren't you the one he was fucking this morning?"

Benny takes a step back, "what?!"

Cas could see the confusion on Benny's face. His confidence subsided, but he was still angry. He couldn't be wrong.

"This morning I, well it's not like I was stalking, I go for runs every morning, but I ran past Dean's house and I heard him moaning with some guy and-"

"What?!"

"Yeah I-"

"The fuck you talking about? I was at his house this morning and we were just talking! My wife just died and Dean was cheering me up. I don't know whose fucking moaning you heard but it ain't Dean's."

"No I- I heard it. Clear as day. Dean was-" was he moaning? The more Cas thought the more he struggled to remember what happened this morning, "I-"

"Yeah and now-"

"Really? Dean was just talking?" He couldn't have been. That would mean Cas said all those... no he wasn't wrong. This man was lying.

"Yeah, what'd you think happened? He slept with someone? What the- I thought you two were together?"

"I did too, until Dean cheated on me."

"Brother I'm telling you Dean ain't slept with no one."

"Stop lying."

"I ain't."

"I- no! You're lying, you have to be. If not I-" Cas gulped.

"What? What happened between you two? Dean has barely spoken since we dragged him back from club hell."

"What? I- no bu- what did Dean do?"

"You first. Tell me everything."

"Ok uh come inside."