fear street imagines

𝐈 𝐒𝐓𝐈𝐋𝐋 𝐋𝐎𝐕𝐄 𝐘𝐎𝐔! - 𝐃𝐄𝐄𝐍𝐀 𝐉.

DEENAXFEMALE!READER
IB: -L0CALSLUT (different ending and storyline though)
TW: Death & Mentions of blood
YOUR POV:
Deena said she was over Sam, but i failed to believe it. Ever since we got Sam out of the hospital, Deena's attention went too her. She'd barely look at me anymore.

We were currently at the school, getting ready for the killers to get us..by us- i mean SAM. I walked up to Deena with my new clothes but before i could say anything, she walked off with Sam. I glared at the two and stormed into the boys bathroom with Simon. Hot tears ran down my cheeks.

"Hey- are you alright?" I heard him ask. I wiped my tears away and shook my head. "Deena still loves Sam...i know it" I mumbled and Simon pulled me into a hug. "Im sure she doesn't..why dont you go and talk with her?" He said and i sniffed and nodded. "Alright, thanks si" he smiled kindly. "Anytime Y/n" he replied. I went into the stall, got changed then headed to where Sam and Deena should be. But when I walked into the room..what i saw shocked me- but didn't really surprise me.

Deena and Sam...making out.
In just their bra.
'How amazing'

I let out a small gasp and they immediately turned around. Deena's eyes widened and she lightly pushed Sam off her. "Y/n! Babe, its not what it looks like!" She yelled, she ran over and took my hands in hers but i immediately pushed them away which hurt her- I could tell it did. "You said you were over her..." I mumbled, my voice unsteady. She looked at me, eyes filled with guilt.

Sam watched us before awkwardly picking up her clothes and walking out. "You know what...be with Sam. You're obsessed with her, and i know it. You might as well fuck her, or is that what i just interrupted?!" I yelled, i wiped my tears angrily. "Babe..." Deena said, putting her hand out to cup my cheek but i immediately pushed it away. Deena looked down and started crying.

I honestly didn't feel bad. I didn't care if she cried. First, she lied. Second, she ignored me. And third, she cheated on me. "Deena..we're over" i stated before storming out, leaving the curly haired girl speechless and shocked. She ran after me, calling my name but we finally reached the group. Sam must've told them what happened because they all gave Deena a disappointed look.

Simon held his arms out to me and i walked into them, holding onto him tight. "Lets forget about all this for now, theres killers after me. And i dont want them to kill us" Sam stated after a few moments of silence. I would argue with her, but she's right. I stepped out of Simon's hold and linked arms with him, a thing we usually did when one of us was upset. "Lets kill these bitches" i said.

Though i was prepared to fight. I was still very heartbroken over my break up with Deena. I was glad i did it though...otherwise i'd be stuck in a relationship full of lies...and nobody wanted that.

—

3RD PERSON POV:
The teenagers were now all in a shop, Simon was telling them about drugs they can give to Sam, so they could kill her and hopefully bring her back. But Deena wasn't really paying attention, her attention was on Y/n. A heartbroken Y/n. She was lost, she liked Sam but..loved Y/n. But now it was over for them. For good.

Later that night, the kids were attracting the killers. Deena was stuffing Sam's face with drugs. Y/n was dealing with the skull mask. Simon was dealing with Ruby Lane and Josh and Kate were dealing with the camp nightwing killer. As Y/n was fighting with the skull mask, he shoved her down onto a bread slicer.

"NO- NO STOP" the girl screamed, her head getting closer to the sharp cutters. The skull mask killer held her down onto the machine, her pushing and shoving didn't effect him. "LET GO- KATE, SIMON, JOSH- DEENA!!!" She yelled, her throat sore from it all. The teens heard her screams and suddenly...it all went quiet. This worried everyone.

Josh, Kate and Simon ran towards where Y/n was once heard...and saw her dead on the bread slicer. Blood down her shirt and splattered on the freshly baked bread underneath her. Their hearts broke, and they didn't know how Deena would react to this. "Y/n.." Simon whispered, his voice cracked. Kate hid her head in Josh's shoulder and began crying. While the boy stood there, staring at his sister's ex in shock. He really liked Y/n (not like that) and he thought she was an amazing girl...

-TIME SKIP-

Deena had finally got Sam to wake up. Everyone lived but she soon looked at them and realised the one most important person..was gone. "Where is she?" They all immediately went quiet, they knew who 'SHE' was. When nobody answered, Deena got up and looked around the store..until she saw her ex-girlfriend..dead and her head sliced up.

"Y-Y/n..." she sobbed, slowly walking towards her. "NO, Y/N- NO PLEASE!!" She screamed, she rushed towards her body but didn't glance at her face, knowing it would break her more. "I-i still love you Y/n, you have absolutely n-no idea how much i re-regret doing that to you!" She cried. Josh, Simon, Kate and even Sam stood and watched in pure sadness.

They lost the brightest girl in the group...
But Deena lost the girl she truly loved...
"I still love you..." she whispered, gripping at Y/n's hand, kissing it and then finally letting go....

A/n: God- ngl that was quite emotional..geez. Sorry i killed you guys btw😀