fear street imagines

𝐒𝐓𝐑𝐀𝐍𝐆𝐄𝐑𝐒 𝐀𝐆𝐀𝐈𝐍 - 𝐒𝐇𝐄𝐈𝐋𝐀

SHEILAXREADER

FROM STRANGERS...

Sheila bumped into a girl/boy/person one day in SunnyVale, at first she was annoyed. "Watch where you're going" she sassed but the stranger rolled her/his/their eyes and replied "Why don't you?" This caused Sheila to smirk, she liked this girl/boy/person's attitude. "Wanna hang out some time?" She asked causing the stranger she bumped into to smile and nod "The names Y/n" she/he/they introduced and Sheila smiled nicely "Im Sheila!"

TO FRIENDS...

Ever since that day, the two were inseparable. They did everything together and also signed up to go to camp nightwing together the next summer! Sheila never thought she could get someone to like her THIS much, since she was known as kind of a bitch. But Y/n was a sweet girl/boy/person...well most of the time. Unfortunately, Sheila got Y/n into bullying people but she/he/they didn't even notice it. Y/n just followed Sheila, they were best friends after all.

FRIENDS INTO LOVERS...

Over the months of knowing each other, Y/n and Sheila both found out that they were head over heals in love with one another. Y/n ended up asking Sheila out and they started dating. Everyone in SunnyVale knew of their relationship and couldn't help but be happy for the two. There was only one boy that wasn't...Will Goode. Will Goode liked Sheila and was furious to see that an innocent girl/boy/person took her away from him. But none of them noticed the boys hatred towards Y/n, they were too in love with each other to notice.

AND STRANGERS AGAIN...

Sheila and Y/n finally made it to camp nightwing, and although it was sad to admit, Y/n noticed her/his/their girlfriend's lack of effort in their relationship. Sheila hardly kissed, hugged, looked or even cuddled the girl/boy/person anymore...because her attention was on Will Goode. He had gotten hotter and it wasn't hard for Sheila to notice. Y/n became friends with a girl named Ziggy and soon enough, Sheila broke it off with Y/n and started bullying both of them.

•••

Sheila and Will didn't work out, but Y/n and Ziggy did. Ziggy fell in love with Y/n and asked her/him/them out, sharing a beautiful kiss in Ziggy's cabin. And walking passed the window was Sheila- the terrible ex girlfriend who completely abandoned the girl/boy/person she truly loved. Seeing Ziggy kissing who she once kissed absolutely teared her apart. But she was the only one to blame...

After that summer, Y/n moved out of SunnyVale and went to ShadySide with Ziggy...leaving Sheila alone and heartbroken, completely regretted what she had done to Y/n. All she wanted was her/him/them. But we don't all get what we want...