i fell for you when i wasn't supposed to

Chapter One

 Hope always loved her trips home to New Orleans. Every chance she got to spend a few days at home she would jump at the opportunity, and Christmas break was her favorite because she got to see all her family members who came down for the holiday. No school work, no early hours or boring days of sitting in a classroom and studying, instead she got to bond with her family and enjoy the adventures of New Orleans. Her inner circle of friends even came down for a few days to hang out. They all got really drunk. Nevertheless, the break had to end and she was on her way back to school. Despite everything being perfect, there was one thing she just could get off her mind.

Or rather, a person.

Girls and guys both would do anything to gain the attention of the most popular girl at school, she had everyone drooling over her. Hope would date every now and then, had a one-time thing once or twice, but she mostly just liked the attention on her. Being an only child, she wasn't used to sharing. Especially sharing the attention that she gave Hope.

After saying goodbye to her family and unpacking her suitcase, she went downstairs looking for her friends. After multiple conversations and useless flirting from other students, Hope finally made her way to the lunch hall and grabbed breakfast before making her way to her friend's table. They always sit at the same spot, the corner near the window where light comes from behind but doesn't blind any of them. All that just to avoid light in the early mornings for breakfast. Nevertheless, she plops her food on the table before dropping in her seat and resting her head on Maya's shoulder.

"Well hello to you too?" Maya greets her and all other conversations at the table ends.

"Hey."

"What's wrong Hope, not happy to be back?" Raf asks.

"Not exactly, I've been here for about an hour and I already miss my parents and New Orleans," she pouts before picking up a slice of toast and eating it.

"Yeah, that and she hasn't met up with her girl-toy yet," Maya explains, causing Hope to roll her eyes.

"How come you always bring up my sex life?" she asks Maya while laughing.

"Because you're happier when you get laid, and from what you've told me she's pretty damn good at making you finish," Maya responds before picking up her water.

"Jesus Maya-"

"Ewwww-"

"Not at the table-" Jed, Raf and Landon complain.

Maya simply looks at Hope and laughs while we hear the boys complain and push away their breakfast. She unknowingly drowns them out when a particular girl comes into her view. She walked through the entrance of the cafeteria with confidence, although she doesn't seem to brag like Hope would when stealing the attention of a few students. A smirk grows on Hope's face as she thinks of dragging her down to the studio and having some fun.

But let's get one thing straight, there are absolutely NO feelings involved when it comes to what Hope has with her girl. However, that doesn't stop Hope from missing her. She finds herself in need of her touch just to release and relax, it's almost addicting at this point.

"Oh guys, look-look" Maya tilts her head towards Josie Saltzman, Lizzie Saltzman and a girl that Hope doesn't recognize. "That's Penelope Park, she's the new girl."

The closer Hope looks, the more she realizes how comfortable Penelope is around Josie. Anger begins to build up in Hope. She manages to remind herself that she is in public and her... moments with Josette are a secret, so she bits her lips to seem normal.

"Do they know each other? They seem friendly," Hope asks and eats her food, pretending not to be interested in the conversation.

"Damn Hope, have you been out of the game that long? The new girl is clearly making moves on Josie, don't tell me you're falling for your mystery girl," Jed jokes.

"Oh please, flirting is so natural it's just normal for me. Having a consistent girl to fuck around with is ten times easier when I'm horny. It's nice to get straight to the point, and please forgive me for not paying attention to the Saltzman twins," once again Hope tries to sound uninterested.

"No, they don't know each other, but I think I saw the twins giving the girl a tour earlier. She kinda seems like a player, might even give Hope a run for her money. She sure seems to be picking up on Josie Saltzman real fast," Maya explains.

It takes everything in Hope not to clench her fist or look angry, nobody takes Josie from her. She belongs to Hope, she's Hope's toy. Instead she rolls her eyes and bites her lip.

"Please... as pretty as Penelope looks, Hope has this school wrapped around her finger," Landon cuts in.

Hope tries to keep herself inserted in the conversation, however, she finds herself getting possessive. SHE gets to kiss Josie. SHE gets to touch her and make her moan. SHE gets to fuck Josie Saltzman. Not this new girl. The more she thinks, the angrier she seems to find herself. Hope needs to mark what's hers, to show Penelope that Josie is off limits.

Hope has given the girl hickies before, Josie had never stopped her, even when she would ask if it's okay. However, it's rare that she would give Josie a hickie where it could be more easily seen, like on her neck or lower thighs. Hope broke that rule one time, and now she fantasizes about breaking it again.

After sex they would get dressed and leave and go back to hating each other, almost like nothing ever happened. She knew that the 'friends with benefits' thing began when someone almost caught them in one of the classrooms. Hope hid while Josie distracted the student because she was the one who was dressed. The student was basketball star Alyssa Chang, loved among many, right under Lizzie Saltzman and Hope herself. She remembered hearing Josie talk to Lizzie about possibly liking Alyssa when they first began hooking up, which is why Hope was surprised when Josie said that she was "sorta already taken".

That was the first time Hope felt possessive over what she had with Josie. Josie was the best she ever had and never really made her wait. Josie never wanted a date, or gifts, never needed Hope to be a friend to her. The only reason Josie even had Hope's number is to text when she would need sex- to which Hope gladly obeyed. This was the start of their unspoken relationship, they would communicate if they needed a break. However they never found themselves in that situation, and until it was time to end it, both girls would make the most of their time together.

Hope shoved her breakfast in her mouth and swallowed before telling her friends that she has a project to work on and that she'll be back later. That was always Hope's excuse when going to have sex with her girl, they knew what it meant by then. They sheepishly wished her good luck and reminded her to meet up tonight at 7 before the bonfire party for pre-gaming.

Hope threw away her trash and walked past Josie's table while walking to the exit. Josie and Hope made eye contact before anyone else could notice. They kept the stare for a few seconds before Hope was out the door, and that was all Josie needed before excusing herself to her room for 'a nap'.

Now comes the fun. 

Just a reminder that I don't own Legacies or any of the characters. Everyone tells their stories to entertain and I'm trying to get some kind of Hosie action. Sorry if it sucks, I'll be working on it. Any feedback let me know? Enjoy!