𝓗𝓲𝓼 𝓑𝓻𝓸𝓽𝓱𝓮𝓻 (Levy McGarden x Male!Reader)

𝕋𝕙𝕚𝕣𝕥𝕖𝕖𝕟

Y/n sweated profusely. He didn't know how he got himself in this situation.

Levy had him sandwiched between herself and the wall. It was an awkward situation indeed, because there was one thing stopping Y/n from leaving.

"Y/n, why?" Levy asked.

"Levy...I don't...I'm sorry! I couldn't bear hurting you or Gajeel..." Y/n said.

"You've already hurt me Y/n..." Levy said.

"I-...I'm sorry Levy...I don't know what more you want from me..." Y/n said, looking off to the side.

"I want you...Mirajane doesn't deserve you. Don't get me wrong, I love her, she's a wonderful friend but...you're mine...please Y/n..." Levy said.

"Levy I-I can't do tha-." Y/n said but was cut off by Levy smashing her lips onto his own.

Y/n's eyes widened as his mind went numb, sparks went off and he could feel his heartbeat faster the longer he and Levy kissed. His hands found their way around her waist and he picked her up and pinned her to the wall. Levy wrapped her legs around Y/n's waist as they kissed one another passionately.

They separated, panting heavily as their eyes were lidded.

"This is wrong..." Y/n mumbled.

"This is right..." Levy whispered, she pulled Y/n's face towards hers, engaging in a heated makeout.

Y/n pulled away once again, he shook his head.

"Levy! Th-This is wrong!" He repeated.

Levy grabbed Y/n's face and looked him deep in his eyes.

"Then why haven't you left? You could have put me down and walked away by now...but you're still here." Levy said.

She let out a desperate sigh as she pleaded to Y/n with her eyes.

"You can't tell me that after we kissed...you didn't want more?" Levy questioned.

Y/n shamefully looked away, the look in his eyes told Levy all she needed to know.

"I-...I know I'm being selfish...and I'm not considering your feelings entirely...but...Y/n...you're are the most amazing man I've ever met. You've been treating me like...like a queen...and once you get treated well you can't go back to bullshit...I-I just don't want to go back to Gajeel...you have to understand..." Levy pleaded.

Y/n bit his lip. He wanted to so desperately be with Levy, his body yearned for hers, every inch of her. He wanted to see her happy, he wanted to make her smile, he wanted to do whatever it is that she wanted of him.

But Gajeel, his brother, Y/n had to think of his brother. His brother would've been devastated and betrayed if he knew of Y/n's feelings...not to mention he promised his brother he wouldn't take Levy away from him.

Y/n set Levy down and looked at her.

"Levy...I love you, I really do...but we can't be together. I'm sorry, that's just the way it is." Y/n said, he prepared to walk out of the bathroom, but Levy stopped him, grabbing his wrist.

"We...could keep this a secret. I-...I won't break up with Gajeel, I won't hurt him, and he won't find out about it...just, please...I need you..." Levy pleaded.

Y/n looked at the short bluenette woman, her pleading eyes a major weakness to him, and so was the throbbing of his heart.

Though...what she offered didn't sound too bad.

'Gajeel wouldn't get hurt...and I could still be with Levy...' Y/n thought.

"F-...fine. I...I accept..." Levy smiled at the reply she got and hugged Y/n tightly.

"Thank you! Thank you so much! I love you!!" She squealed.

Y/n smiled gently at her. Her happiness was all he desired...after all...she deserved to be happy.

The pair exited the bathroom at the same time and returned to their respective partners.

Levy bit her lip in anticipation. The thought of going home to see Y/n distracted her for the rest of the night, catching Gajeel's attention.

"Shrimp? You okay baby?" He asked.

Levy snapped her head in Gajeel's direction, prying her eyes away from where Mirajane and Y/n were.

"Hm? Oh...I-I'm sorry sweetheart...but I'm a bit tired..." Levy said.

"Oh okay, let's get going then." Gajeel shrugged.

The two got home eventually, and as they walked up to the house, they saw Y/n and Mirajane talking.

Gajeel smiled and stopped from a distance, trying to shush Levy who really could care less about Mirajane and Y/n conversing, but watched the two nonetheless.

Gajeel leaned in to hear what they were saying.

"I had a great time Y/n. I'm glad you decided to come on such short notice." Mirajane smiled.

"Of course. Spending time with you is quite the treat." Y/n chuckled in response.

"I hope to see you again. May I...have a kiss?" Mirajane asked.

"Agh, you asked before I could!" Y/n groaned playfully.

He grabbed Mirajane by her waist and leaned down to press his lips on hers. Mirajane wrapped her arms around Y/n's neck, squealing softly as Y/n passionately moved his lips against hers.

Levy's eye twitched as the scene played out in front of her. She was so gonna claim what was hers that night.

They pulled away, a bright blush on Mira's face.

"Th-thank you...goodnight!" Mira said.

A car had pulled up and Mirajane got in, she waved at Y/n, who waved back with a smile on his face.

The car drove off, and Gajeel and Levy walked up to Y/n.

"So, you had invited her in?" Gajeel asked, with a smug look on his face.

"She forgot her key to her dorm so she needed a place to crash and wait for her sister to come and get her." Y/n explained as the three went into the house.

"Mhmm you sure you two didn't do anything in here?" Gajeel jested.

"We only watched a movie halfway, talked a bit, and played Uno." Y/n chuckled, cleaning up the Uno cards from the floor.

Levy unnoticeably scowled at the mere thought of Y/n and Mira cuddled up together, watching a movie and smiling...kissing...laughing...

It disgusted her...

"Did you two enjoy yourselves? It's rare to see you two out and about together." Y/n said.

"We had a blast! Right, Shrimp?" Gajeel asked.

Levy's face quickly switched to a small, fake smile.

"Mhm!" She answered.

"That's great. Where did you two go?" Y/n asked.

"To the bowling alley you and Mira went to. I'm surprised you didn't see or hear us." Gajeel said.

"Well, I guess I was too occupied." Y/n shrugged.

"Well...I'm gonna get to bed early, see you two in the morning." Y/n said, quickly changing the subject.

He waltzed upstairs swiftly as Gajeel and Levy both bid him goodnight.

Y/n slammed himself on the guest bed, and stared up at the ceiling. Thoughts of the nights events replayed through his head, and he cursed himself for feeling the way he did.

"Why can't she just be single? Why my brother of all people...?" He thought, shoving the palms of his hands in his face.

Hours had passed, and looking at the time, it was damn near 2 in the morning. He turned over in the bed, and his ear twitched as he heard footsteps approaching the guest room.

He looked towards the door, and it opened...

Revealing Levy....

Who was wearing her pink, fluffy, and sexy robe...