Creepypasta Love Stories: Ben x Jeff x Reader

The Basement

Hello guys, so I just wanted to say, I'm sorry cause I took a bit too long for this chapter and kept you guys waiting but here it is! (I'll probably be posting once every 2 weeks from now on. Sorry)

On with the story~

~(Y/n's) POV~

You woke up wet from your dreams. You sat there, embarrassed. Partly because you thought you were a bit too old to be wetting your pants but also because you couldn't remember what you dreamed about. You were bummed out that you couldn't remember anything but you were ok with it.

You went online to look for job applications cause you really needed to pay your electricity bill. You could not stand another day doing a cold shower.

You couldn't really find anything so you just drove around and saw that Starbucks was hiring so you applied(ok I do not know how jobs work so pls do not yell at me for getting this wrong). Guess you're gonna have to wait a few days to actually test your skillz. It was two days until the parkour so maybe a little ramen until then.

You went to your room and opened your laptop. You opened Minecraft and loaded this little parkour map your friend, F/N, made for you. She/He/They/Ziy made it for you a few weeks or maybe like a month ago and you were too busy trying to let yourself live so you didn't really have the time to play it. (Gender) said it was pretty easy so you felt super confident. You logged in and started the parkour.

~Jeff's POV~

I woke up with Ben's ass in my face.

"What the fuck?!?" I screamed. Ben giggled.

"Wakey, wakey~" he cooed. My head became a tomato. He hopped off the bed and walked towards the bathroom.

I got up and threw a pillow at him.

"Oi, what's your problem?" Ben snapped and looked at me. I shrugged. He picked the pillow back up and walked into the bathroom. I started following him but he suddenly turned around and sniped my head with the pillow. I fell back and my head hit the ground. Next thing I knew, I blacked out.

~Ben's POV~

I woke up wrapped in Jeff's arms. I slipped under his grasp and hopped onto the floor. I went into the bathroom and saw that I was butt naked. I had a huge headache and I couldn't really remember why. I jogged through my memory, then something on my body caught my eye. I had hickeys all over my body and bite marks(that's sus😏). Then, I remembered.

~This flashback has been brought to you by Offender's stripping club~

Slender looked at us with his nonexistent eyes. The atmosphere was tense and my head was pounding so much. All I could think about was losing Y/n. I didn't even care about the pain in my eye or the fact that Slender was obviously horny I just didn't want to think about anything other than Y/n. She made me happy and that is a feeling I have not felt for a long time.

"So." Slender started. "You know why you're here."

"It's not my fault! Ben was stalking my Y/-"

"It doesn't matter." Slender's voice cut through the air and I felt shivers down my spine. "You disurbed my sleep! And everybody else's sleep but still! Do you KNOW how hard it is for me to sleep?!?"

I burst out laughing.

"SLEEP?!?" I cried. "You are obviously so fucking horny don't even talk about sleep right now!"

Slender's face was steaming so much I thought he was gonna explode.

"A-Ahem, we don't talk about that." Slender said blushing hard. "You guys are dismissed, escort yourselves to the basement please. You'll be staying there for a week. Bring whatever you want but no weapons."

I gulped. I looked at Jeff and our eyes met. We had the same, terrified expression. We got up and left Slender's room. I went to my room and took my most important gaming things for the parkour that's happening in two days. I sure as hell hope Y/n will be there. She probably will be.

I headed down to the basement and unpacked my things. I got there first so I occupied the only desk. The basement was really big with a pretty good tv, a ripped up couch, a king sized bed, a christmas tree, a grand $200 couch, a fridge, a stove with some pots and pans and a few drawers and closets. The walls were freshly painted with a nice burgundy color. There is a little section in the basement for.......sussy stuff. There are shackles, a few whips, dildos of different shapes and sizes, lube, gag balls and you get the point. I don't even know why Slender has that there. I think this was Offender's doing but I doubt I'm gonna use it much. I mean I won't use it at all! This is Jeff we're talking about. There is also a whole half of the wall for a majestic bar. Now this, is something I'll definitely be using.

~After a number (that I will not name) of drinks~

My vision wasn't that blurry but I feel like there was something wrong with my head. I looked at Jeff. Damn, he's so hot and sexy~ How come I've never noticed this before?

I was so fucking horny and it looked like he could use some help rubbing it out too so I walked over to him and sat on his lap. I could feel his dick pressed against my ass.

"B-Ben?*Hic*"

"Yes Jeffy~?"

"Can you *Hic* h-help me out a bit here? *Hic* As bros do?"

"Thought you'd never ask~"

~Jeff's POV~

I woke up with Ben kissing my lips. It was more of a him gobbling my face up thing but still, gross!

I felt his ass on my dick. It was pretty nice but this is Ben we are talking about. I felt myself get hard as I thought about this situation but instead with Y/n. Damn Y/n.... you're pretty good at kissing. This sweet taste in my mouth. Yum~

I lay there fantasizing but then I realized that this is actually Ben doing everything and I was thinking of perverse thoughts! Wtf is wrong with me.

I lifted my arm and grabbed what I thought was his back but turns out, I grabbed his ass.

He yelped and jumped off me.

"What the hell was that for?!?" Ben cried.

"Ahem, says the one devouring my fucking face!" I shouted.

"Look, I was trying to do CPR but then I got distracted while doing the mouth part!" Ben defended.

"Gross." I spat.

I walked away and went to the bathroom. It was pretty small and wasn't much with a full sized bathtub and a glass shower. The sink was in between the two and the toilet was near the door squished between the wall and the shower.

I slammed the door behind me and looked in the mirror. Why the fuck am I naked?

I turned on the water and hopped into the bathtub.

Mmm~ This is what I needed. I pictured Y/n sliding into the tub with me and put her head on my chest.

"Wow~ you bad boy. Look how hard you've gotten after just thinking 'bout me." she cooed. "You know what I think?"

"Mhm~?" I hummed.

"I think-" she grabbed my dick. "You need to be punished~"