Creepypasta Love Stories: Ben x Jeff x Reader

Just a Normal Boring Day

~(Y/n)'s POV~

Ahhhh......today was so amazing. Absolutely nothing happened. Just the same old boring shit. Yeah yeah, people call you boring or whatever. You're just too used to the same old stuff you're afraid if anything too much happens you won't be able to handle it.

Anyways, you pulled out your phone and home screen which was a picture of Ben Drowned and Jeff the Killer. Yes, they were killers but you loved them nonetheless. You entered the password and opened Instagram. You scrolled down and saw that there was a Ben Drowned parkour contest in minecraft. If you win you could gain a thousand dollars. You were an absolute gamer but you weren't really sure if you could finish this parkour competing against maybe over five hundred other players. But you were also really broke so any money would be fine.

You decided to enter the contest and then went down for some dinner.

You took out some leftovers from the fridge and ate it. You were still pretty hungry but you were gonna have to deal with it. You just got fired a few days ago and you're still looking for a job. Honestly, at this rate, you might as well just go full criminal mode and see how long you last.

It was pretty dark out so you went back up to take a shower and sleep. You walked into the bathroom, heard a loud thud on the roof, ignored it, took off your old clothes and hopped into the shower. Just as you finished putting on your conditioner and body wash, all the lights turned off and the water soon became freezing. Shit. you forgot to pay the electricity bills. You finished up your shower in the freezing cold water and dried yourself. You used your phone's flashlight and brushed your teeth. You put on your pajamas and went to bed.

~Jeff's POV~

Today was so boring. I got some kills, lost to Ben in Mario Kart, again, he's probably somewhere bragging to the ladies. Not that I care. The only thing I care about in this world is my beloved little pig Petunia, and the woman I love. I've been stalking her for quite a while now and I know that she obviously likes me. Well........me and Ben. She likes both of us. I think. I mean I have no idea why she likes that stupid idiot but ok. I respect her feelings but if I have to share with Ben.....I might as well kill him. I know that she won't like that but I mean it's either me or nothing. I mean it's not like Ben will actually like her too right? I mean he is with ladies 24/7 so yeah. Why do I even care so much about Ben? He's the least of my problems. Anyways, I might as well just go stalk her today. Yeah I'ma do that.

I went out my window and ran through the woods. I know the way to her house by heart. I saw that her bedroom light was on so I went to the tree next to it. I climbed up and saw that she was going into the bathroom. I climbed higher on the tree then jumped onto the roof making a loud thud. I hope she didn't hear that(she did). I climbed down onto the tree outside her bathroom window(why the hell does she have a window in her bathroom?) and saw her start stripping. I felt myself start to get hard. I saw her hop into the shower and start washing herself. I took out my dick and started to jerk off. I tried my best not to moan. I thought of myself pounding hard into her ass and her moans. I finally came and I put my dick back into my pants. I was twitching and shivering so much I thought I was gonna fall off the tree. I got a grip and continued to watch her take a shower.

She was in the middle of a shower when suddenly the lights went off. I couldn't really see anything after that. She turned on her flashlight at some point and brushed her teeth. Then she walked out of the bathroom. I watched her put on some pajamas, turn off her flashlight and go to sleep.

I hopped down from the tree and made my way back to the mansion but before I could go in I heard a voice behind me say "Where were you?". I turned around and saw the one and only Ben 10 standing in front of me.

~Ben's POV~

The day was not that bad. I played some video games, beat salty Jeff in Mario Kart, then played some more. I bet Jeff's probably somewhere sulking cause this is like probably the 500th time he's lost to me. Anyways, I'm honestly kinda bored so I'ma go stalk my number 1 fan~.

I left my room and went down the stairs to the entrance of the mansion. I saw someone in the distance running away with real speed. It looked like Jeff. Whatever. Anyways, I ran and let my legs do the rest and in no time, I got to Y/n's house.

I climbed up the tree next to her bedroom window and couldn't find her anywhere. She must be in the bathroom. I waited for a little bit then suddenly, the lights turned off. Damn I wish I could help her but.... I'll endanger everyone. Maybe I can turn her into a creepypasta. But if I turn her into a criminal and everything will she fall for other people? Will she start hating me?

I shook my head. I gotta focus on the parkour event this Sunday. Only a week to go. Don't go too ahead of yourself, Ben. Get it together!

I saw her walk out of the bathroom and get to bed. I watched her for a few more moments to make sure she was safe then in the corner of my eye I saw a person run away from her house. I jumped from the tree and followed her. The person had kind of long hair and a white hoodie. Pretty sure she was wearing black pants but it was dark and-WAIT A MINUTE. That damned bitch.

Jeff reached the mansion and I stopped a little behind him. Stalking my girl? There is no way you are getting out of this.

"Where were you?" I asked as he reached for the door knob. Jeff turned around and his face twisted with disgust.

"None of your business." he growled quietly. "What about you? Are you stalking me?"

"As if." I replied and rolled my eyes. "I was just stalking my beautiful Y/n. She's so sexy and pretty I just couldn't help myself ya know?"

I smirked as I watched his face fume up. He gritted his teeth and for a second, I thought he was gonna explode.

For a dude so pale, he really changed color.

"YOU MOTHERFUCKER!!!" Jeff screamed and lunged for my neck. It was late and I was tired as fuck so I did not dodge quick enough and he was able to get a grip on me. "YOU SON OF A BITCH!!! Y/N'S MINE!!!"

He punched my face and laughed.

"Look at you! So weak and pathetic. All you do is play video games! Do you really think she'll actually want to date a wimp like you?!?" Jeff picked me up by the throat and yeeted(threw) me into a tree. I coughed up a little blood and wobbly stood up. Jeff charged at me full force with a knife. Honestly, I am just too fucking tired to do anything so I summoned my Zelda shield and blocked all his attacks.

For a second, in the corner of my eye, I thought I saw her. I stopped and gazed at the forest of trees surrounding us. She was smiling and waving at me. She finally noticed me-!

I snapped back to reality as I felt a burning and stinging sensation over my eye. I felt blood trickle down my face, my neck and into my shirt. I looked at Jeff, still trying to process what had just happened. Then, it hit me.

"What in the world are you guys doing?!? It's like 2:00am and you guys are fighting and shouting?!? Where the fuck have you been?!?" a voice shouted and immediately Jeff and I were grabbed by tentacles.

Fuck. We're screwed.