Liar

22 - For Whom The Bell Tolls

The girls were all sitting on Spencer's bed, continuing through the videos. This one was a video of Alison, Katherine, Eric, and Noel all dancing, and Katherine and Eric occasionally kissing. They went to the next one and Katherine instantly knew what the video was going to be. 

Katherine was setting up the camera in the video. It was the same room as the one from her first kiss. "Like this." They heard her voice say, getting onto someone's lap. She knew that this video showed Jason's face so she quickly skipped it. "You don't wanna see that." She said, and they all nodded. The next video was once again in that room. She was on top of the older boy, all they could see was his blonde hair. She, once again, skipped the video. She wondered why there were so many of her. 

"Is that Jenna?" Hanna asked as the next video started. 

"You're late." Jenna said in the video. 

"Who's she talking to?" Aria asked. 

"Toby." Spencer said, as the video showed him. 

"It's not right." Toby said in the video. 

"There's nothing wrong about us, Toby. We're not really related." Jenna said, wrapping her arms around his neck. "It'd be so easy for me to convince your daddy and my mommy that you've been forcing yourself on me. You have no idea who you're dealing with." She said, as she took his shirt off of him. 

"Turn it off." Spencer said. 

"Do you realize what these videos are?" Aria asked, as Emily shut the computer. "They're of us, Ali, Jenna. We're young girls in our bedrooms, changing clothes. We're naked!"

"Exposed." Spencer said. 

"Do you think someone was watching us and getting off on it?" Hanna asked. 

"Well, we all know who had a thing for younger girls." Spencer said. 

"I'm sorry but you can't defend him anymore, Kat." Hanna said. 

"You're right. I can't." Katherine said, thinking of when her and Jason had caught Ian recording them while they made out. If the girls had just watched that video for a few more seconds than they would've known that for sure. Ian Thomas recorded these videos. But they also would've known about Jason. But Katherine knew that they would find some way to prove it's Ian.

"I feel sick." Emily said. 

"In some of these, we were just kids." Hanna said. 

"Ian's been watching us for years." Aria said. 

"And he killed Alison to make sure that nobody found out." Spencer said. 

"I'm gonna throw up." Katherine said, rushing into the bathroom. 

"I wish that Ali would've told us about these videos." Emily said, when Katherine came back. 

"I knew about some of them." Katherine said. 

"What?" The other four girls said, looking at her. 

"With that guy. We caught Ian recording us once, he said that was the only time he had done something like that. And the video I made with that guy, I don't know how that got there." Katherine said. 

"Ian's a creep, Kat." Spencer said. 

"I just tried to think that I imagined him recording us." Katherine said. 

"You guys, it is not too late to help her. We can use this to prove that Ian killed Alison." Spencer said, grabbing the flash drive. 

"How are we gonna do that?" Emily asked.