Melody saw pictures of Alice on Logan’s phone. She recognised her as the girl she saw with Logan the day she tracked him down in Texas. She asked “Were you seeing each other that time I saw her?” Logan awkwardly responded, “We weren’t but we met again a week later and pretty much hit it off straight away”
Melody asked, “Today is Valentine’s Day so will you be doing anything tonight?” Logan responded, “I’ll be taking her out tonight.” Melody began to wish she had fought harder for Logan. Later on, Logan introduced Melody to Alice. Melody really wanted to hate Alice but she came across as really sweet. “I wonder if the press know they’re seeing one another,” thought Melody
This reminded Melody of her and Logan’s break up. She them remembered how Logan tried so hard to apologise and how tormented he was when she was with Chad. Melody sadly thought, “Now I know how it feels.” She really couldn’t stand to see Logan so happy with Alice so she told him she didn’t really feel like socialising with others so she was going to head back home
As she was walking back home, she briefly stopped walking, hoping Logan had caught up with her and say it was her he wanted to be with but when she saw he wasn’t coming, she headed home feeling despondent
On Valentine’s night, Melody stayed at home while Logan took Alice out for dinner. Melody thought about how happy her and Logan were when they were together and she cried thinking of all the happy times they had together
At the restaurant, Logan tried to convince himself he was having a great time with Alice but he knew deep down, he still wanted Melody. He never stopped loving Melody but he was still hurting that she had gotten engaged to another man
