Mattheo Riddle x The Emerald Witch

Tease

I woke up the next morning to the sun rising. Oversleeping was just fine since it was the weekend. Slowly, I began getting out of my comfortable bed and walked into the bathroom where Theo was brushing his teeth. Honestly I'm still kinda pissed at him for last night. I mean who has the nerve to tell me who I can hang out with. He went from relaxed to acting like he was all big and bad in a matter of moments. That was the side of him that he usually shows to everyone, but I was hoping I wouldn't have to see it. Although I was mad I had to admit he looked awfully attractive. His hair was messy and he was still in his pajamas, green plaid pants with a white T-shirt. I'm not the type of person that usually likes petty payback or anything, but after Theo's behavior last night I felt like it was called for.
"Hey Mattheo I need to shower can you go?"
I figured making him leave the bathroom when he obviously had things to do would be a good start.
Theo "no"
Well I must admit, I wasn't expecting that. Although I was mostly doing this to piss him off, I did actually need to shower.
"Umm... that's not really an option"
Theo "I'm not looking y/n"
It was pretty obvious he was hiding a smirk.
"Okay fine"
It's not like a had much of a choice, plus the glass on the shower wasn't see through or anything. Needless to say I was gonna find a way to have fun with this. I innocently removed my shirt right in front of him showing off my black bra. It's not like I did anything major to him I'm just messing with him a bit. I walked over to where he could no longer see me for the rest and proceeded to take my shower. When I was done I used my powers to bring a towel over to me and I wrapped it around my body. Theo was no longer in the bathroom so I just walked into my room. Honestly that was quite fun. The look on his face was priceless, however I think he might have enjoyed that a little too much. Oh well. Using my magic I pulled a cute outfit out of my closet and got dressed before walking back into the bathroom to hang my towel up. Mattheo was back in the bathroom grabbing his rings off the counter.
"Those are pretty"
Shit why did I say that? I'm supposed to be mad at him, but why don't I still feel upset? Usually when someone does something to me I hold a grudge, but with him for some reason I wanted to forgive him right away. He walked over to me and held out a ring.
Theo "you can have it, it doesn't fit me anymore"
"Oh I can't take that Theo it looks expensive"
Theo "I have more y/n, besides it would look better on you"
I smiled and gently took the ring from his hand. He walked back to his side and put his other rings on. I turned to walk back into my room.
Theo "wait"
I turned to look at him.
Theo "About last night.... I shouldn't have snapped like that."
"It's alright Theo, we were both tired"
Theo "wait your not mad?"
"I probably should be but I'm not. I do have a question though"
Theo "yes?"
"Last night when I said you were acting like the bad person everyone says you are, you said 'maybe I am' what did you mean by that?"
Theo "it's a long story"
"I've got time"
Theo "why do you care anyways?"
"Because... well I'm not sure I just do"
Theo "i think it might be best if you stay away from me from now on"
"Wait wha-"
Before I could finish my sentence Mattheo had walked out of the bathroom and into his room, shutting the door. His thought process was impossible to follow, but telling me to stay away for him was strange even for him. This boy was a complicated mess.