Fear street (Simon Kalivoda X READER) REWRITING

Rudolph the red nosed reindeer

Recap: Simon and I ran like hell after that. We linked hands because we were fucking terrified.

We all arrive back to Deena's house.

"It doesn't make sense. Bullets didn't stop her." Sam pointed out

"Amazing observation." Kate said in a annoyed voice,

"Who the hell was that?!" Deena asked Simon and I.

"How the hell should I know, she- she was hot, I don't know, the bitch seemed normal." Simon admitted.

I ran to the bathroom right after hearing Simon say that. I ran the water and sat on the toilet, my knees to my face, crying. I knew then, he was right, but I had gotten so fucking jealous.

Simon runs into the bathroom two minutes later. I think he was discussing with the others about the murders.

"Hey, are you okay?" Simon asked me.

"No, I'm not, how could I be okay when you called another girl hot?!" I
Asked him with literal tears in my eyes trying to hold them back, but I couldn't. I blinked and they all came running out of my eyes.

"I'm sorry, I was going to say that she's not hotter than you, Y/N. But I thought that it would be weird. After you ran into the bathroom, everyone was teasing me 'you messed up, badly.' Simon quoted

"But she's nowhere near hotter than you, Y/N. I love you so much, you know that? I feel like I couldn't live without you." Simon had said. He brings his forehead to mine. He kisses me.

I smile at him with a red nose, blushing like crazy. I get up to rinse my face. I look in the mirror.

"God, I look like Rudolf the red nosed reindeer." I added.

Simon bursts out laughing. I rinse my face trying to get rid of my red nose, but it wouldn't go away. So I decided to forget about it. We went downstairs and when everyone saw me they laughed. Joking about how red my face was.

"Yeah, you really messed up badly, Simon, you made her cry." Kate adds.

"Okay, back to what y'all were talking about?" I ask.

"None of this is random. It's Sarah Fier. She's turning Shadysiders into killers." Josh says while slamming down a paper.

"You really believe that?!" Kate asked.

Simon and I go to sit down by Josh and Kate.

"I mean no one actually thinks that this witch shit is real." Kate finishes.

"Yeah, it's something that babysitters make up to scar little kids." Simon replied. I chuckled at Simon's reply.

"No, no, just listen to me, 1666, Sarah Fier was hanger for witchcraft, fact... but ever since she was executed, she's been possessing people to take revenge on the town." Josh explained while slamming another paper on the table.