𝐀𝐧𝐠𝐞𝐥 𝐄𝐲𝐞𝐬 - M!xM! Reader

☁️Sub Rory × Dom M! Reader

Show: My Babysitters a Vampire

Relationship: You and Rory have been friends since the 3rd grade. But ever since he turned into a vampire you grew apart. (Also let's ignore the part where he and Erica almost kissed). (And you have Telekinesis btw).

Situation: Rory asks you out for a horror movie marathon and invites Benny and Ethan. You get bummed out when they just start hanging out like normal.

(Y/N's Pov)

"Hey Y/N!" Rory greeted as he opened the door. "Hi, Rory." I said. I walked in, looking around at the decor. "Oh hey Y/N." I heard someone say. I looked over to the living room to see both Ethan and Benny. I deflated, I thought that it was just going to be me and Rory tonight. "Hi, Benny. Ethan." I said, sitting down beside them. Rory ran back to get the popcorn and drinks while we sat there awkwardly.

Rory came back and turned on the TV. "Alright! Let's get this Horror movie marathon on!" He sat down beside me and handed me the popcorn. I sighed and took it. I knew that this night was getting no where between me and Rory.

After the 4th movie I was over it. I got up and shoved the popcorn into his lap. I ran up the stairs and to his bathroom. I fell back against the door and sniffled. I don't know why I was crying, it's not like it'll make him come to me. A knock on the door startled me. I wiped away my tears and looked up at the knob. "Who is it?" I asked, my voice still sounding a little hoarse. "It's Rory. Are you okay Y/N?" He asked. I looked down at the floor to think before I answered.

"N- no..." I mumbled. Rory tried to open the door, but realized it was locked. "Do you wanna talk about it?" He asked nicely. I got up and unlocked the door. "Yeah, I do." I said and grabbed his hand, dragging him to his bedroom. I locked the door behind me and turned to face him. He was sitting down on the bed, giving me such an innocent look. I felt bad for what I was going to tell him. "I um... I need to confess something." I said. I sat down next to him and looked down at the floor. He leaned closer, letting me know he was listening.

"I've been thinking this for a long time now... and I uh- I...." I started, trying my best to get straight to the point. Rory placed a hand on my shoulder. I looked over to him and saw a sad smile forming on his face. I smiled back and began picking at my nails. "I'm just going to get straight to the point- I like you, Rory. But I was afraid to tell you since I thought you were too cool for me..." I said, starting to sniffle. Rory patted my back and frowned. "I'm so sorry to hear tha- Wait. WHAT?!?" He yelled, making me feel like I was getting rejected.

He took his other hand an placed it on my other shoulder, making me face him. "You, like me?" He asked. I just nodded, knowing how this was going to end. "I didn't actually think you were able to have feelings for someone like me." He said, running a hand through his hair. I looked him straight in the eyes, shocked that he felt the same. "Wait. You feel the same!?" I asked. He nodded and looked off into space, astounded with what just happened. I blushed with the idea that popped into my head. "R- rory.... I was thinking-" "Yes! We should definitely kiss right now!" He gushed, grabbing my hands and looking into my eyes. I blushed and looked down. He pulled my chin up and leaned forward to my lips.

I leaned in too, lightly pecking him. We moved back for a second or two, until we both shared the same thought. We crashed our lips together and fell back onto the bed. This wholesome moment turned into a make out session real fast. He held my waist, making me gasp. That allowed him access to my mouth, exploring with his tongue. I tried a little too, but failed miserably.

A little bit later we heard footsteps coming up the stairs, but ignored it. There were sounds of knocking and voices we couldn't hear at the moment due to us sucking faces. Soon the door barged open, making us jump. Benny had used his magic to get the door open since we locked it. "Oh, I thought you guys were getting beat up by alien monkey's or something. My bad." He said, raising his hands up in defence. Ethan was just standing there amazed. He was probably wondering how Rory made out with someone before him.

"Ugh! Get out!" I yelled, embarrassed at the thought of them seeing me sucking face with our friend. Benny laughed loudly before I shut the door with my mind. I looked back to Rory and smirked. "Where were we?" I asked, making him giggle and put his arms around my neck. We started back up what we hadn't finished yet.

(Ethan's Pov)

After Y/N shut the door on us I looked up at Benny in shock. "How the heck did Rory of all people get to suck face before me!?" I yelled. Benny just laughed and put his hand on my shoulder. "I guess it's your turn to learn from Rory, the ninja." He chuckled. I was about to reply, but heard a moan come from Rory's room. Me and Benny looked at each other at the same time. "He got that before me too!?" I yelled. We both ran down the stairs and went home after all that started.

----------------------