"It was always you." (Michael afton x Fem Reader)

chapter nine• "i think your in love with her"

Michael afton x Fem reader
chapter 9

Y/N's POV:
December 20th, 1983
10:47pm

We're in december now, almost Christmas, me and Michael are closer then ever, Zack and Marilou started dating about two weeks ago, god Lila and Jeremy are still together and now our group is me, Michael, Gabby, Lila, Marilou, Jeremy, Zack and Mark so a group of eight isn't bad and plus when all of us hang out it's fun as fuck, running from people, hanging out until four in the morning and plus we dont care what we do so literally I feel comfortable to smoke around them sometimes and plus, Mark, Michael and Lila do it, me and Lila not as much as Mark and Michael, only thing is is that I don't know is how Michael's family is doing, apparently William cut ties with Henry and now Henry has his own pizzeria called "Freddy Fazbear's Pizza" Well Michael says it doesn't open until summer of '84

But one thing I've been wanting to tell Michael is how I feel honestly, I've talk to Lila about it and she told me to just tell him, he's definitely different from the other people I've dated before but at the same time, I don't wanna mess up what we already have-

I snapped out of my thoughts when I heard a tap on my window, I got off of my bed and went over to see what is was, it was Michael, grinning and holding and cigarette in his hand, I quietly laughed as I got my lighter and a cigarette out of my dresser and opened my window and go out with him

"How was your lovey sunday?" He said sarcastically "It was bored as hell-" I chuckled as I sat down beside him "I heard there's a huge party new year's eve, wanna go with me?-" Mike asked as he put his cigarette between his lips "-God, maybe we could get the whole group to go" He muttered as he lit the cigarette "Sure, I'd be down to go" I replied as I leaned over and grab the lighter from him

Some time went by and it's now like one in the morning, I'm practically half asleep laying on his chest as I felt him play with my hair, causing me to be even more sleepy

"Y/N-" He whispered "Mm-." I groaned "It's midnight, we're gonna freeze if we stay out here-" He said as he sat up "I gotta get you inside darling" He added with a dramatic tone as he picked me up, I was too tired to walk "Where are.. we going-" I muttered quickly "I'm bringing you to your room so I can go back to my room so we can both go to sleep" He said softly as he carried me inside to my room and gently put me in my bed as I quickly fell asleep

"I love you Y/N."

Michael muttered so you wouldn't hear him and then quietly went back to his house

Michael's POV:
December 21st, 1983
2:36pm

"Fuck! I don't know man!-" I said dramatically to Mark as I threw myself on my bed "What do you mean you don't know how you feel about her!?-" He asked "Do you like her or not?!" He added "No no, I don't just like her!" I tried to explain "Okay, okay..-" Mark started to say "-What are some of your favourite things about her?" He asked. 

Oh god, I could go on forever about her honestly, there's just so many things I just honestly love about her.-

"Mike! stop day dreaming and start talking!" Mark said loudly "Okay! okay! well, her personality is my favourite thing about her but god, her eyes- I could get lost in them for hours honestly-" I said as I started to picture what her eyes look like "-Oh and her hair! I just really think it suits her and her style! fuck, I love her style and don't forget-" I said but then Mark cut me off "Holy fuck Mike." He sighed "What? do I sound like a creep? Oh god, what if she doesn't feel the same! I've never felt like this before for someone!" I panic "Mike you never felt like this for someone before because..-" He began to say but then stopped