𝑊ℎ𝑦 𝑑𝑜 𝑦𝑜𝑢 ℎ𝑎𝑡𝑒 𝑚𝑒 𝑠𝑜 𝑚𝑢𝑐ℎ？

𝑃𝑇．5

"Hold on. I'm going to need an explanation."

"He was shit talking you, so I punched him. Its not that hard to understand."

"No, you fucking idiot. Why did you stand up for me? Why do you care about me? Since WHEN did you care about me? How long have you 'loved' me? Why did you just suddenly kiss me?"

"Like I didn't already explain last night? I told you, I love you." "THAT DOESNT ANSWER ALL OF MY QUESTIONS." "Okay, then maybe this will." He looked at me and held eye contact as he stepped closer, but just as I thought he was about to kiss me he started to talk. "Ever since you first introduced yourself, I ran away because, I mean, just look at you. You're so pretty, and I just look like this." He did a hand gesture like showing himself, I was about to speak when he cut me off again. "I've always thought you were so pretty, and I was scared of you breaking my heart when we were older. That's why I always ran away, I did everything I could to make you hate me. But the truth is that I was only doing that so we would stay away from eachother, so when you never stopped trying to be my friend I knew I had to do something. I decided ignoring you wasn't enough, so I took it to bullying you. I felt horrible every time I would hit you, or say anything mean because I knew I didn't mean it. I only kissed you because I was hoping you felt the same way, I know now that you don't. That kinda sucks but I guess I can live with it. Sorry for being a dick, I just didn't know how to express my feelings."

His words hit me like a truck, I expected some stupid apology, not that. I was lost on what to say when someone spoke up for me. "THAT IS SO CUTE AWW" I quickly spun around and I was looking around the room for any signs of someone there, it was a familiar voice, I just couldn't pick up who it was. Suddenly a stall door unlocked and Gwen came out of it, "you guys kissed? And you didn't tell me?!" Robin and I stared at eachother, shocked. "I heard the whole conversation! I was about to come out when I heard punching and kicking, so I just stayed in my stall until it went away. But then I heard Y/n's voice and I really badly wanted to hear what you guys had to say to eachother, I thought you would fight but YOU GUYS KISSED?!" She screamed in my ear.

I looked back and fourth at her and Robin, I knew there was no getting out of this one.

"Ha! We got you!" Robin yelled and pointed at her, she looked confused but I went with it. "We knew you were in here idiot, so we had a fake conversation to see what you would say!" I added. She looked really disappointed, but I wasn't 100% sure she bought the lie.

*Gwenny's pov*

I wasn't exactly sure they were serious, I'm pretty sure they're pranking me. They must have actually kissed right? How did they even know It was me in the bathroom? It could have been anyone!

I saw Robin and Y/n keep making eye contact and they looked worried, so I acted like I bought it. That seemed to impress them enough. I immediately ran out of the bathroom to go and tell Finney what happened, but then I reconsidered their privacy. If they were actually serious and they did kiss, im sure they wouldn't want me going around telling people. I was thinking about it in class for the rest of the period until my math teacher advised me to go take a nap in the nurses office.

*Robins pov:*

I could tell Y/n wanted to tell Gwen, but I didn't want it to go spreading around the whole school so I made up a lie and she just went with it. I wasn't embarrassed of us, but I thought she would be—

"So you don't want anyone to know huh? You're embarrassed of me?" Shit. "What? No!- I just didn't want that spreading through the whole school—" "so you are embarrassed of me?" "I didn't say that!" "You thought it." "I didn't! You would probably be the one embarrassed of me!" "Oh so I'm the bad guy here?"

I was so sick of arguing with her. I just wanted us to be on good terms, so I could have another chance at winning her over. I was about to say something when I reconsidered, I didn't need to say anything to mess us up again.

"Are you gonna speak?" She snapped at me. "I'm sorry.." I hate being all shy around her, I'm known as the 'toughest kid in school', I cant ruin that. I don't want to keep up my reputation so I seem cool, I wanted to keep it up so she would think I'm cool. I really was obsessed.

*Back to Gwen's Pov:*

I was walking around a block, when I noticed a window that just stood out to me for some reason, I closed my eyes and imagined myself in it. When I re-opened my eyes I was in the room with that window. (She's dreaming🤪)

I was looking around the unfamiliar room when I heard arguing, I looked up and saw Robin and Y/n. 'Wasn't I just in the nurses office? How am I here' I thought to myself, which I then realised I was dreaming. So it must have been important.

"Fine! You wanna know why im such a dick to you?!" Robin snapped at Y/n, she looked scared but concerned at the same time. They didn't notice I was there, which was how I was positive I was dreaming. "Yeah! I do actually!" She snapped back. Robin took a step closer to her and pushed her hair back, not behind her ears, just back. He placed his hands on her cheeks and kissed her, I was stunned but even more confused when she kissed him back?!

I shot my eyes open and sat up, in the nurses office. "It was a dream! That did happen!" I shouted, the nurse looked at me confused but I just got up and ran out. I knew they had a class together then but I didn't know which one, so I barged into all of them.

*Your pov:*

I was tapping my pen on my desk when I met a familiar pair of eyes across the room, I wasn't sure if I was mad at him or just super confused, but I didn't have to answer that as I heard someone yelling my name. "Y/n! Would you mind paying attention? You don't want another detention do you?" My teacher screamed at me. We both turned our focus back to the class, but not for long as Gwen ran in. "Sorry Mr.Garrison! I need to borrow Y/n and Robin!" I stood up hurriedly, trying to get out of that class as soon as I could. The teacher didn't question it and continued yelling at everyone.

She brought us out and I saw Robin smiling at me, patting the chair next to him for me to sit on it. I ignored him and sat next to Gwen instead. "So.. I know you guys said it was a prank.." I already knew where it was going. "But- I had a dream.."

Okay, maybe I didn't know where it was going. But Robin did, and he looked petrified. "A dream? What does that have to do with anything?" I met his eyes again but instead of smiling at me he slightly shook his head, like I shouldn't have asked that.

"Oh, my dreams. I forgot to tell you about them!" I don't even think I wanted to know. "I have dreams about things, like things that have happened, or things that are going to happen. Sometimes things that are happening in the present." I thought she was crazy, but she seemed determined that her dreams were real.

"Wait, if you have dreams like that then.. what did you dream about?.." I could feel a cold sweat running down my forehead as I knew what she was going to say.

"You weren't just pranking me! You liars!" She started laughing hysterically after she said that, "I wont tell anyone though, you don't need to worry about that." I felt relieved, but Robin looked worried. He really was embarrassed of anyone knowing about us.

*Robin's pov:*

I was almost shaking, it felt like my soul was being pulled out of my body. I didn't care Gwen knew, I didn't care if she was about to go tell the whole school, I didn't care if I was going to be made fun of for obsessing over her. But I saw her sweating. Was she really that scared people would know? Is that how much she hated me? I regretted what I had done to her. If I wasn't such a prick maybe I would actually have a chance with her.

I stood up, my face was red from holding back tears. Again. What has she done to me? Why am I suddenly all soft for her? (I know what you're thinking you dirty little- 😡)  I walked over to the bathroom, I walked into the males instead of unisex so that they couldn't follow me in. Well, they couldn't at least. The bell went and just as I thought nobody was coming in.

"Hey Robin, what's happening?"