Once Bitten, Twice Shy

Unchain the Night

  Lucas and Dustin were sound asleep on the pull out couch in Beth's basement. Mike was humming some Ozzy, lying on a pile of dirty clothes on the floor. Steve tiptoed down the stairs. "Eddie!", he whispered. Eddie jumped up the stairs into Steve's face with a terrible smile. "You got them revved up?", he asked, his voice drowning in lust.

"Yeah man, but how did you get these kids to knock out so fast?" Eddie sighed. "Don't tell the girls, but I may or may not have slipped a little something into their Yoohoos when they weren't looking." Steve glared at Eddie, jaw tense. "Come on, man. We can't drug a bunch of kids for some pussy." Eddie shrugged. "Well we didn't."

Eddie ran up the stairs. Steve remained for a moment, dumbfounded by what he'd just learned. "Oh fuck, Nancy!", he heard Beth moan. "Screw it, sorry kids," Steve mumbled to himself. Nancy's face was buried between Beth's legs, lapping at her pussy. Eddie had one hand in his pants and the other squeezing Beth's tit. "Your girlfriend is eager to please," Eddie said, staring at Nancy's tongue sliding around Beth's clit.

  Steve pulled his shirt over his head and threw it onto the couch. Eddie peeked at Steve's trim athletic build. It was kind of hot. Beth wrapped her hand around Eddie's arm and pulled him down to kiss her, his throat catching her moans as Nancy drew her to orgasm.

Beth pulled off Eddie's pants, his underwear clung to the wet tip of his dick. "Somebody's excited," Nancy smiled, noticing all the precum. She left a trail of kisses down Steve's stomach, stopping to lovingly bite at his hip bones. "That's right, Nance. Mark me, I'm all yours."

  Eddie slid his underwear down. Before he could stand back up all the way, Beth was gagging on his cock, slobber dripping down to Eddie's balls. Steve watched her work him, eyebrows raised and erection growing. "Hey Nancy check this out." Steve grabbed Nancy by her neck and held her in front of him. Nancy pressed back into him so that his erection was rubbing against her bottom.

  Nancy was really coming out of her shell. Steve was proud of her for finally liberating the slut inside of her. "I'm taking notes", she said, reaching back to pull Steve free of his pants. "Fuck me while you watch her take care of Eddie," she breathed. Steve greedily pulled Nancy's white cotton panties down and off. He teased her opening with the tip of his dick. "Mmm, you're such a bad girl, Nance. You're so excited already."

  Nancy gasped as Steve pushed himself all the way into her, spreading her faster than she had anticipated. He paused, gripping her delicate waist, before sliding back. Her walls tensed around him. He let out a deep growl, moving her away from and back to him, eyes fixated upon Beth's lips gripping on Eddie.

  "Fuck babe, you think she can do you that well?", Steve wondered aloud. The idea of Nancy straddling Beth's soft, plump tongue pumped even more blood, swelling him inside of Nancy. "Steve you're so hard right now." It almost sounded like a complaint. "Is it too much?", he asked, pulling out of her and gripping himself.

  She whined at how empty she felt. "Just be gentle," she pleaded. Steve nodded. He twirled her around to face him. Saliva pooled in his cheeks as he carried her over to the leather recliner that sat in front of the TV. A trail of soft pecks lead him from her collar bone to her breasts, down past her navel, and into the soft tufts of trimmed brown curls on her mound. "Steve," she croaked, "I kind of wanted her to taste me with you."

  With a pop, Eddie pulled himself from Beth's eager mouth. "Your attention is requested at the recliner, my dear," he snickered. He held Beth's hand and walked her over to where Nancy was spread wide open and dripping with want. "Oh Nancy, your pussy is so pretty," Beth crooned. Eddie nodded in agreement. "With that hot little mouth of yours it'll be even more pretty."

  Beth rubbed her soft hands up and down Nancy's thighs, a little nervous to start. "Please," Nancy begged, thrusting her pelvis towards Beth. Eddie wrapped Beth's long, wavy brown hair around his hand and gently guided her. The instant Beth's tongue met Nancy's engorged clit, Nancy quivered and her legs went stiff. "She's so ready for you, sweetheart," Eddie reassured, pushing Beth's face further into Nancy.

  Beth began to move on her own, one hand keeping Nancy's lips open, the other resting on Nancy's chest. Everyone stared as Beth slid her tongue over Nancy's opening, humming and moaning and slurping. "Steve," Nancy gasped, "maybe you should join her." And he did.

  It was like they were making out. Their tongues slid around each other, spit and Nancy's juices mixing as they took turns licking and sucking. Eddie hovered over them. Nancy was pretty, but Beth was so fucking sexy. She was so good with her mouth. He wanted this to be over with so he could kiss her while he slid in and out of her.

  "I don't hear anyone cumming," Eddie teased. "I'm about to," Steve laughed. The shaking breath against her sensitive bud caused Nancy to jolt upwards, crashing into Beth's tongue. Beth mumbled against her, realizing the vibrations were sending Nancy over the edge. Steve slid two fingers into Nancy as Beth held her steady, sloppily trashing her tongue about.

  Nancy let out a quiet squeaking cry, her entire body tensing up in Beth's hands. Steve's jaw dropped as he felt Nancy tighten around his fingers. "I've never felt you cum so hard, Nance," he whispered as he kissed her trembling thighs.

  Tears fell down Nancy's cheek as she relaxed into her afterglow. "That was even better than I dreamt," she managed to get out before losing herself completely and falling limp. Eddie rubbed Beth's head with pride. "Good work," he told her, pulling her up and over to the couch. "Can I watch you watch me fuck you now?" Beth excitedly nodded, lying back and folding knees to her chest. Eddie tilted her hips back so she could see as he slowly filled her up.

"May we join you?", Steve flirted. "Of course," Eddie responded. Nancy sat herself next to Beth and stuck her legs up onto Steve's shoulders. He slid his thumb into her mouth, then used her spit to massage her throbbing clit. She closed her eyes and prepared herself. Steve smiled with his mouth open as he slid into Nancy just as she was peaking.

  Beth kept her eyes on Eddie's cock, slippery and solid, pounding into and out of her. She patted her clit, feeling herself getting close to bursting. As she sprayed Eddie's happy trail, Steve laughed. "Did she just piss on you? No judgment. It was hot, whatever it was." Eddie giggled. "Steve Harrington has never made a girl squirt?", he mocked.

  "Holy shit," he said, pausing his strokes to look Eddie in the eye. "That's real?" Eddie laughed and bent down to kiss Beth. "You want me to show you?", he asked, eyes dancing between Nancy and Steve. Nancy looked a little uneasy, but definitely interested. "Does it hurt?", she asked Beth. "No but if you feel like you have to pee don't try to stop yourself. It's not painful, just sometimes the first time is really overwhelming and embarrassing. It's sexy, don't be in your head about it."

Nancy opened herself to Eddie, her chest rapidly rising and falling with each nervous breath. "He'll take good care of you", Beth promised. His rings were cold against her skin as Eddie caressed around her warmth. "May I", he asked, staring into Nancy's anxious eyes. "Yes," she confirmed.

Eddie hooked two fingers into the spongy crook inside of Nancy. He licked at her clit with a wet, flat tongue, drool running down and helping lubricate his digits. "Oh, Eddie, oh, fu—," Nancy's eyes were squeezed shut. It was impossible for her to do anything but moan.

Steve was a little jealous, but also very interested in seeing how the hell Eddie would pull this off. The noises that came from Nancy's body were nothing Steve had ever heard before. The screams, the rapid squishing, and then—it happened. Nancy was crying, her legs keeping Eddie's face in place as she squirmed through the orgasm.

  "Are you alright?", Eddie asked when she finally let go of him. Nancy stared at the ceiling. Eddie snapped his fingers in front of her face, "Nancy? Hello?" She continued to stare, unmoving. Eddie and Steve looked at each other in a panic. Beth placed her hand on Nancy's cheek and said, "Nod if you're okay." Nancy nodded, still unable to speak.