What sexualities/pronouns I think creepypastas are:
Jeff: Bisexual no preference
Nina: Jeffthekillersexual
Ben: bi/questioning
Toby: bi no preference/preference constantly switching
Slenderman: aroace
Jane: Lesbian (canon)
EJ: Straight
Masky: straight
laughing jack: panromantic asexual
hoodie: biromantic asexual
Sally: unknown
Smile da dog: dogs
Pronouns:
Jeff: any pronouns/doesn't care (but always uses he/him for himself.)
Nina: She/her
Ben: He/him (doesn't mind she/they)
Toby: He/they
Slenderman: Any
Jane: She/her
EJ: they/them (doesn't mind she/her)
Masky: He/him
Laughing Jack: he/him
Hoodie: he/him
Sally: she/her
Smile da dog: doesn't care
A/N: Tell me if there are any other headcanons/people I should add
