TBP preferences because I said so

94- Y.R.A part 3

I didn't know so many of ya'll were into the Poly stuff...But here we are
Thanks to vances_doll for giving me a plot example.
Alright, you gotta share both of these yandere simps.

3rd person POV:

"Who's it gonna be?" Finney asked.

Y/n got too overwhelmed and freaked out.

"Neither! Neither of you! I'll just leave you two to figure shit out..." Y/n said, leaving the two boys alone.

Finney and Robin both stood up. They both looked at each other before Finney spoke.

"Listen, Robin. We both want Y/n, and Y/n likes both of us. Don't ask how I know. But..."

While the two guys were discussing how to get Y/N, Y/n was already on their way back home. On their way back, however, they saw another boy. The boy whose name was... Bruce Yamada? Yes, Bruce Yamada. As soon as y/n laid their eyes on him, they felt something...They felt happy. They knew what they'd have to do. Simply start the whole process over again. But there's an issue, Bruce has a lot of fangirls, so y/n would need to just kill the girls who talked to him.

After a month or so, Y/n had murdered over ten girls due to their newfound crush on the popular baseball player. Y/n had even become a good friend to the boy, and was certain he liked them back. Y/n fessed up one day and told Bruce about their crush on him, he liked them back! Y/n was over the moon, but two boys weren't so supportive of this. None other than Finney Blake and Robin Arellano. The two boys spent a month thinking of a plan, the perfect plan. The two agreed to share the love interest.

After school one day, Y/n was just walking home, when they suddenly got yanked into a bush the occasionally walked by. They felt a damp cloth go over their nose and mouth. They didn't even bother to waste energy on trying to escape, as they already knew the familiar smell of Anesthesia.

Once awake, y/n felt a rope that tied their arms and legs together, completely restricting movement. Y/n easily escaped the ropes, as one of their victims had escaped their ropes before and y/n mentally noted down the procedure. Once they got up and rubbed their wrists, they noticed they were in Robin's house. They were in the guest bathroom's bathtub to be exact. They went to the door to open it, but Robin opened the door first.

"Let me go, Robin." They said.
"Oh sorry. Can't do that amor." He replied.
"And why not?" Y/n asked.
"Because! Me and Finney already killed Bruce and stuff, so we're kinda all you have now. You are completely reliant on us now." Robin said.
"Us?" Y/n asked, confused.
"Oh, me and Finn came to...An agreement." Robin said. Y/n still liked the two boys, they aren't afraid to admit it. They'd never loose feelings over the two boys who actually made them feel something. Y/n gently put two hands on Robin's shoulders and sighed before moving him to the side to go to Robin's room. Robin followed behind as y/n sat down on Robin's bed and grabbed one of their favorite comic books Robin possessed.
"Huh. You're pretty easy to keep." Robin said, standing in front of y/n.
"Yeah, sure." Y/n said, reading the pages before lying down on their back.

Not too long after, Finney came into the room.
"Oh, They're already awake?" He asked.
"Yeah, they just came in here and sat down and read a comic." Robin said.
"Stop talking about me like I'm some sort of animal. You both know my name, start using it." Y/n told them both sternly. They both fell silent before both laying down next to Y/n, reading the comic too.