School For Misfits (Evan Peters x reader)

Chapter Four | Bruises |

_______________________________
[Now Playing: I See Red - Everybody Loves An Outlaw
_______________________________
James brought me to his room and locked the door. He pushed me against the door and roughly pushed his lips against mine. He moved his lips to my neck and sucked on my sweet spot. He removed my shirt and unhooked my bra. He unbuttoned his shirt and removed his pants. He took off my pants and signaled me to jump. He held me by my thighs and brought me to his bed. He grinded against my pussy and groaned into my ear.
"Mmm, sweetheart, I want you so bad," he said before sucking onto my earlobe. I took off my panties and his boxers. I got on my knees and started pumping his cock. I sucked onto his tip as he threw his back in pleasure.
"Yes! Keep sucking on that cock, Y/n," he moaned out, gripping onto my hair. I put the rest of his cock into my mouth and sucked hard. I could tell he was about to cum but I stopped just as he was about to. He shot a glare at me and as I was about to tell him that I wanted him to cum inside me, he quickly put on a condom and shoved his cock inside me. He thrusted so fast and animalistic that the bed was banging against the wall.
"Did you think you could just do that without getting a punishment, darling?" he asked, smirking afterwards.
"N-no, I stopped because I wanted you to cum in me," I said. My words seemed to turn him on even more and he started to thrust his hips even faster. He moved his hands to my waist and held them still as he fucked himself into my pussy even harder.
"Cum with me, darling," he said. We came together and he released his grip on my waist.
"I didn't hurt you too much did I?" he asked, with a worried look on his face.
"Of course not," I said. I realized that I should probably go check on Kyle since I haven't seen him in a while. I quickly put on my clothes and gave James a kiss on the lips.
"I'm gonna go back to my room to check up on the rest of them, come join us when you're ready okay?" I said. James nodded his head as I left his room.
_______________________________
[Now Playing: Before The Day Is Over - Joji
_______________________________
"How's he doing?" I asked, as I entered my bedroom. Evan looked back at me and shook his head hesitantly. I heard yelling coming from the other side of the room.
"Hey, buddy. It's all good, this is a safe space. We're all literally the same person," confided Peter.
"NO!" yelled out Kyle. I quickly walked over to Kyle to try and calm him down.
"Kyle, calm down," I said softly. He looked up at me and held my hand. His face had a couple of bruises. There was a bruise around his right eye and another on the corner of his lip. He moved closer to me and hugged me tightly. "What happened?" I asked, looking over at Evan.
"I don't know. He started becoming increasingly aggressive towards us after we asked him if he was okay. He actually punched Kai in the face and that caused Kai to get angry so they got into a fight. Kyle probably has a couple of bruises on his face but that's due to Kai punching the shit out of him," explained Evan.
"That little fucker, if he wanted a fight from me, I wasn't gonna back down from that," chided Kai. I looked back at Kyle to see that he was quietly sobbing into my neck. James entered the room shortly, still buttoning up his shirt from earlier.
"What happened here?" he asked, walking closer to us.
"It's a long story, but I'll give you the main story. Kyle was becoming agro, he got overwhelmed by us trying to calm us down, he punched Kai, Kai and he got into a fight, I separated them both, and then he moved to the corner just to start yelling and throwing stuff at us until Y/n came," summarized Peter.
"Quite the event that happened while we were gone," said James.
"Anyways, how did it go with the new family?" asked Jimmy, trying to lighten the mood.
"The wife is a whore, she tried to give me hints that she wanted to have sex with me. She's a disgusting woman for wanting that. Especially since she has about six kids with her husband. Seems that she wanted some more but not from the same man. Too bad for her, I'll only have kids with one person and that isn't her," shared James.
"Welp, that's definitely something as well. How are the children?" asked Tate.
"The son is definitely interested in Y/n, which is what you say is a "no go" but I was able to pull Y/n away from that boy. The girl twin was also interested in me which means she might be interested in all of us. But that doesn't matter because the boy must be killed," announced James.
"James! Just because he talked to me doesn't mean that he was interested in me romantically," I explained.
"Well, he looked at you not with friendship interest. He had some lust in his eyes. Trust me, darling, I know what that looks like," he said.
"What's that supposed to mean?" asked Tate.
"I've seen how you guys look at her. It happens pretty often, more than you think," explained James. The boys looked away in embarrassment as James cleared his throat.
"Uhm, I'm gonna go get Kyle fixed up, and then I'll tend to your wounds, Kai," I said.
"Okay, don't take your time with that fucker," sneered Kai, giving Kyle a dirty look.
"Be nice, Kai. Remember, you guys are basically the same person," I said.
"Whatever," he said, rolling his eyes. I took Kyle by his hand and led him downstairs to the medical room. He sat on a chair while I went to find the medical supplies for him. I came back with ice packs and some ointment to put on his bruises. I gestured for Kyle to put the ice pack on his eye and he complied. While he was doing that, I put some cooling ointment on his knuckles since it was red and a bit bloodied up from punching Kai. I slowly rubbed the ointment on his knuckles and he winced in pain.
"Sorry, Kyle but this will teach you to not randomly punch people when you get aggravated," I said. He pouted his lips and removed the ice from his eye. I finished putting the ointment on his knuckles and I moved on to putting it on his eye. I carefully put some on his eye and his hand went to my thigh to grip it when it was painful for him. I moved onto his lips but I stopped when he was looking at me with intent. He moved his face closer to mine until our foreheads touched. He closed the gap between us and moved his lips against mine. His eyebrows furrowed as he deepened the kiss. He placed his bloodied hands on my cheek to pull me in closer to him.
"Alright, lovebirds, I think it's my turn to spend some time with Y/n," butted in Kai. Kyle pulled away from me and glared at Kai. Evan was standing behind Kai with an awkward smile plastered on his face.
"I'll take Kai back to his room so he can properly rest. Sorry, Y/n," said Evan. Evan took Kyle back to his room and Kai replaced Kyle in his seat. I put ointment on Kai's knuckles first. I could tell Kai's stare was on me as I was working. I looked up to tell him a sarcastic joke but I didn't realize how close he was. He looked down at me and smirked. He moved closer until our noses were touching.
"Y/n, I would suggest you continue instead of looking at me. I promise that you'll have me. All of me, after you put this ointment on my bruises," he said, hovering his lips over mine. I looked away from him and smiled to myself as I continued to put medication on his bruises. Once I was finished I closed the lid to the ointment and washed my hands. When I came back to the room, I was pushed against the wall. Kai put his head against mine and put one hand on my waist and the other on my neck.
"Shit, you have no idea, how long I've been waiting to do this to you all week. I've had so many wet dreams about you that I've been dreaming to make it a reality," he whispered to me. He suddenly pushed his lips against mine and we moved our lips against each other.
"Y/n!" We pulled away from each other, gasping for air.
"Fuck, I guess we'll have to continue this later," he said seductively as he squeezed my ass.