Black Phone imagines and head cannons

~You reject them yandere version~

A long waited request by Psychoboy1996

Let's be real, we all know that if you reject these boys it is not going to end well at all...

Finney:
• You have no idea how long it took this boy to muster up the courage to ask you out on a date
• He has literally been prepping for months!
• He had thought it through perfectly, he'd had 10 conversations with you and he was head over heels in love so he would leave a sickeningly sweet note from 'your admirer' to meet up and there he was with your favourite flowers...
• Well he didn't realise the love was one sided...
• So when you kindly let him down and declined the date Finney was devastated to say the least...
• He was still adamant that you loved him, and he definitely still loves you
• And it was as if something inside him snapped... but he was still just the awkwardly cute astronomy lover to you, but no more than a friend
• Until the next morning you found a heart in your locker along with a note and your favourite flowers...
• He just wants to shower you with all his love he has to give...

Robin:
• He planned to confess his love to you however when he found you... it seemed someone had beat him to it...
• And he felt as if you had stomped on his heart when he heard you accept this fuckers confession
• Robin didn't even know who they were but he did know that they didn't deserve you: only he did
• So he decided to take it upon himself and... show you what you truly deserved in his eyes
• So don't be surprised when they don't appear the next day at school... or for the next month
• So Robin consoles you when you believe that they just didn't like you...
• And the next thing you know you find yourself in a windowless room decorated with your belongings you thought you had misplaced...

Bruce:
• Well as we know Bruce already classes you as 'his girl/boy' even if you are completely unaware...
•Well you would be unaware if he didn't announce his undying love for you at any given moment
• And you turned down every confession each time...
• But even knowing Bruce's unrequited feelings you accepted another classmates Valentines...
• And Bruce (being the stalker he is) saw the entire exchange
• And he just snapped (even further if that's even possible at this point...)
• So later when you were walking home and saw Bruce smashing the confessor's skull in with his baseball bat not far from your home you were horrified at the sight...
• And Bruce was horrified that you were there at that moment in this ungodly act... until that feeling morphed into his usual love struck self...
• "Y/N?! No you're not meant to see this! I know it's close to your house but they were... they were to close to your house and I was only trying to protect you! And this doesn't have anything to do with his confession to you earlier or a-I LOVE YOU Y/N! MORE THAN ANYTHING! AND YOU DESERVE TO BE HAPPY WITH ME!

Vance:
• Well there's no way he would even let you reject him
• But just for the purpose of this story when he saw someone confessing you he saw RED
• He walked right up to the poor guy knife in his hand and... stabbed them over and over...
• Goes without saying that you're traumatised... but don't worry you won't be for long as before you know it you blacked out
• You wake up to your mouth gagged and a bloodied Vance rocking in the balls of his feet in front of you messing with the coated knife situated in his hand
• But as soon as he realises you have woken up he will drag you towards a mirror in this prison he has encased you in
• And you'll witness his handiwork, the words "Property of Vance Hopper" carved into your stomach and messy hearts carved all along your arms... as he states of being a declaration of his love
• But we all now how much he just loves to see you in pain...

Billy:
• Billy is 100% an emotional mess when it comes to you
• He just loves you with everything he has
• So when he finally musters up the courage to ask you out and you reject him... he's a sobbing mess...
• As in begging you to reconsider...
• And when you keep on declining he just snaps...
• And you wake up in a room unable to speak or move despite being conscious
• And guess who's there right by your side?
• "Sweetheart please call down! I know you're afraid but I'm here so everything will be okay! No one will ever hurt you! I promise I'll take good care of you forever and ever!"

Griffin:
• It's no secret how clingy Yandere Griffin is
• So when he saw someone else confessing to you and his heart shattered but when that person grabbed you hands...
• They've just dug there own grave...
• No one, absolutely no one is allowed to touch you
• Only he deserves your attention and affection
• So when you heard from Billy how your confessor had been attacked, their hands chopped off...
• Griffin would never ever intentionally physically hurt you
• And Griffin approached you in his usual love sick manner
• And let's just say he was with you even when you were sleeping...

Donna:
• She would leave you daily gifts and drawings for you everyday
•  So when she heard you had accepted another's confession she was extremely upset and disappointed in you. How could you accept someone so average and boring?
• So don't be surprised when your confessor suddenly looses interest in you when facts surface that are definitely not true
• And before you know it you're an outcast due to these rumours
• But thankfully you have Donna by your side the person you can always rely on...

I'm back! 'm sorry for the lack of updates but I'm here now so updates should be more frequent from now on! This one's a little longer as a got a little carried away with some. Nevertheless I hope you enjoyed this one!

- Miss Starlight