A little while later, Peter, still in Henry's body, returned to the RV. As he arrived, Wendy was just waking up.
"Henry?" she asked confused, "How did I get here? What are you doing here?"
"I'm not Henry." Peter replied, using as soothing a voice as possible so as not to alarm her. "It's me, Peter."
Wendy immediately stood up and started backing away as soon as she registered what he had said.
"No, no." she said nervously, "No! Rumplestiltskin said he trapped Peter is Pandora's Box. And if it really is you, how did you get into Henry's body?"
Wendy continued to back away until she hit a wall.
"I switched bodies with The Truest Believer before Rumplestilskin attempted to put me in that box."
Peter said. He then added, lying, " Believe me Wendy, I don't want to harm anyone."
"It can't be you." Said Wendy, in denial.
Peter didn't know how to make her believe him so he walked up to her and kissed her. He knew if anything were to make her remember him, it would be the way he put his hand on the back of her head and grabbed her hair as her soft lips touched his. He knew she would remember how he subconsciously pushed her thick hair behind her ear and how after a while, his hand would slowly go down from her head to her back and around her waist. Wendy let her emotions get the better of her and allowed him to continue kissing her as his hand around her waist picked her up and propped her up on the bed and climbed over her. But before he could do anymore, she pushed him off. This was too much for her especially since in her eyes, she was doing this with Henry.
"I can't do this, Peter." Wendy said. "Not like this" she gestured to his body. He immediately understood.
"Then I will find a way to get my body back." He said as he started for the door. "Don't leave, I will return."
As he opened the door, Wendy asked, "What about my brothers?"
"They are safe." Peter lied again.