Can you keep a secret?

iNSaNiTy

Twilight awoke in a strange place, very strange indeed. It was dark, she couldn't move and all she could see were those red glowing eyes from before. The lights flicked on and she saw they were in the basement. Her friends were bound to the wall along with her, there were ponies standing in a line like soldiers, what was wrong with them? Ellei walked over to main six and laughed.
"You really are a snoopy one aren't you princess. Sorry everypony but your princess made us cut the party short. Now comes the really fun part!" She says walking up to Rainbow Dash.
"What are you gonna do to us?!"
"Simple, Scarlet comes down here with our friends and we choose what new pony you can be."
" ' n-n-new pony'?!" Fluttershy asked trembling. "But I like the pony I am now."
"Too bad, the new you will be way cooler." Ellei says facing away.
"What did you do to the others?! Their staring at us!" Rarity says creeped out.
"Their stuffed. Scarlet gets what she can from them then they get- oh never mind I'm such a loud mouth!"Ellei says face hoofing. Scarlet finally comes down with three other ponies, they had Flash passed out. They threw him on the table in front of the ponies. The third pony looked at the stuffed ponies and clopped his hoof down, they walked over to the table and held Flash down as he woke up.
"Hello dears. Welcome to our reawakening ceremony and the end of your pathetic lives!" Scarlet says grinning, the three ponies with her laughed.
"Wha-?! Where am I? Princess??"
"Flash!" Twilight says from behind Scarlets puppets. Flash couldn't move either, the puppet ponies were too strong.
"Hmm should we change them now? Or let them watch handsome die?" Scarlet asks aloud.
"Kill the colt,kill the colt,kill the colt!" Ellei and the three began to chant.
"Very well, Ellei." Scarlet ushers to the bottles on the shelf, they all had strange glows to them except one, which Ellei had grabbed. Flash struggled in fear to get away, the ponies were too strong, for being puppets. Scarlet approached the head of the table and began to cast a spell, she spoke in a different language that was unknown. Flash began to cry out in agony, a blue mist rose from out of him. Ellei held out the bottle and the mist entered the empty capsule. A presence like before caused a static in the main six' ears.
"What is that?!" Applejack asked
"I don't know, but it's not friendly." Pinkie says outing her ears down.
"The pony from before. . . When I was knocked out" Twilight looked up to see a tall faceless pony stand on the other side of the room. They all gasped. They had almost completely forgotten about Flash and herd no more cries from him. He lay there limp, the puppets went back to their soldier like state. Ellei put the now filled bottle back on the shelf.
"What did she do to him?!" Rarity asked in shock.
"She took his life force, also known as the soul." A deep voice said, it came from the faceless pony.
"Good to see you, wood stalker." Ellei says. He simply nodded to her.
Scarlet approached Pinkie Pie first.
"You like cupcakes Pinkamena?"
"I love cupcakes! Wait what did you call me?!"
"Pinkamena Diane Pie, the killer cupcake maker"
"Stop it! Shut your trap!"
"Why hide it? I know all secrets. That's why I use them against you!" Scarlet shot a beam at Pinkie Pie and her color became darker and her hair flattened. She slipped out of her shackles and fell to the floor. She looked up at the ponies and laughed.
"Who wants to help me make cupcakes?!" She asked with a big creepy grin.
"Pinkie!?" They all gasped in horror.
"I'm sure Flash would like to help. But let's wait until your friends join us." Ellei says to the renewed Pinkamena.
Rarity was next.
"Is it really the end of the world Rarity? Maybe you need new patterns for your dresses?"
"My dresses are already fabulous! The end is nowhere near!"
"Isn't it though? Little ms. Rarity? Your cat is so mean, you dresses are near end of an era. Not to mention how rejecting the critics can be! How dreadful!"
"Ah! How dreadful can YOU get?!"
"That's it!" Scarlet turned Rarity into Insanity as well. LMR was born.
Then Butchershy.
"Now for you Princess." Scarlet moved on to Twilight.
"No!" Twilight shouted. She used all in her power and broke the last of the free.
"What?! These shackles are supposed to be magic proof!" Scarlet says backing up. Twilight broke free as well. . . This was gonna get ugly. . .