Choosing Between The Two (A markiplier/Jacksepticeye x reader)

What Is Going On With The Two?

-------------•a/n•-------------
I'm decided not to use _____, and I'm going to continue using (y/n). It makes a lot more sense. I want to thank the one viewer I have gotten so far. Yay. Seriously though. I thank you one random person that decided to read this!
-------------•(y/n)'s POV•-------------
"Does he normally act like this?" I whispered to Mark in the car ride home. He just shook his head while looking at the floor of the car. I don't know why but he decided to sit beside me in the back. I could tell he was upset about the whole thing. Mark and I just continued to whisper about the details the entire way to a McDonald's. That was the first time Jack spoke to use on the car.
"What would you guys like?" He said turning around to face Mark and I.
"Uh...I'll take a Bic Mac with medium fry." Mark said immediately. It's like he read my mind.
"I would like that too. And a water to drink if you don't mind." I said looking straight at Jack.
"Dr. Pepper for me!" Mark said (I don't really know if he likes that drink). Jack faced the window as a cheerful lady spoke up through the intercom. It was hard to tell if her happiness was forced or not.
"Hello, and welcome to McDonalds. how may I serve you?"
"I'll have three Big Macs with medium fries with a water, sprite, and Dr. Pepper please." He said surprisingly fast.
"Alright. Is that all?" She asked.
"Yes that is!" He replied obviously trying to brush off some of the awkwardness between us. She told us the total and before Sean could pull out his wallet, I had already handed my cash to the lady in the window. "You know (y/n), you didn't have to pay for us." Sean said as we parked to check to see if we got all of our food.
"Yeah I did."
"Why did you feel like you had to?" Mark asked facing me with a mouthful of fries. I giggled along with Jack.
"I dunno. I felt like I just should've. Got a problem with that guuuurlfriend?" I asked Mark sassily while snapping my fingers.
"I don't know if Jack does but I know I do. I wanted to pay." he looked legitimately angry. "Okay...." Suddenly Jack asked for my phone.
I just gave him a confused look. "What do you want it for?"
"Just let me see it!!!!" He said getting irritated but still had a small smile on his face.
"Okaaayyyy" I said while giving him my phone. He did a few things on it, and then I got it back about 15 minutes later. I took my phone and since it's an iPhone, I tapped the home button twice. I noticed that the last thing opened was the contacts and I clicked it. I opened it to find "Jackaboy ❤️❤️" newly added into my phone.
"Jackass." I mumbled to yourself a huge smile spreading across my face. He's such an idiot. A hot one I might add.
"What did you say (y/n)? I didn't quiet catch that." He said blushing while smiling happily turning to me.
"I said JACKASS now let's go. I wanna go see my new apartment."
They both laughed and Jack drove out of the parking lot. I looked out of the window the rest of the way home thinking about who I should pick. Sean or Mark? We pulled up to the building about fifteen minutes later. Mark and I grabbed our bags and Sean helped carry a bag. We all walked upstairs and right in front of my door, I felt a pair of strong arms wrap around me. I looked behind me to see Mark hugging me and Sean with a red face. What was up with him? And why is Mark hugging me? He pulled away just as I was realizing I was blushing. Without saying a word, he walked into Jacks apartment. We I looked at Jack to see him with an upset and surprised expression. I felt bad so I hugged him. Right as I was letting go, I felt something warm upon my cheek. I looked up to see Jack was blushing.
"I-I-" was all I could get out because I was so nervous. I liked them both so much. But who did I like more? It was so hard to decide. "Uh-wanna-uh-come inside to eat with me? The movers already have my furniture inside.
"Sure. Let me ask Mark." He walked inside his apartment and a few minutes came out with a still blushing Mark. "Let's go inside."
We walked inside and sat our food onto the table and ate while telling cheesy jokes and things like that. When we were done Jack randomly spoke.
"Hey (y/n) wanna come over and watch a movie or something?"
"Sure! I would love too!" I said happy I could spend more time with them.
"Great! Let's head over then!"
"Hold on. Let me grab some pajamas. Do you mind if I change over there?"
"No, not at all!"
"Great!" I ran over to one of my suitcases and started to rapidly go through it, actually throwing stuff over my shoulder. I found Lacey relatively close to thong underwear, a sports bra, pajama pants, and a tank top.
"Let's go!" I turned around to see a blushing Mark and Jack.
"What's wro-" Is all I could say before realizing I had thrown lingerie right in front of them. I felt really hot at my face and I immediately ran to grab it. I threw it in my bag and walked out the door not looking back. We walked inside and the two immediately started laughing.
"Shut it assholes. Where would you like me to change?"
"You can change in my bedroom if you would like. It's the first room on your left."
"Thanks Jack." I followed his directions and closed the door. I fell when I was trying I put my pants on, and they both rushed in to check on me. Of course, it was me in just my bra and underwear. They both turned and I could see a smile smirk playing on both of their lips. Pervs. My face was bright red.
"Are you okay (y/n)?" Mark asked.
"Yeah. I would appreciate it if you got out." They both practically ran out of the room. I smiled. When I walked out, both of their faces were still red and they avoided eye contact with me. To make it more awkward, I slowly say down in between them, knowing that there was little space so my butt was on both of their laps.
"Sorry. I thought my butt would fit." I stood up purposefully pushing my butt towards them. I saw a small bump in both of their pants rise. I giggled softly. Mark scooted over a little because Sean couldn't considering he was against the arm of the chair. Halfway through the movie, I feel Mark scoot a little closer and he repositioned himself. When he was doing this his hand gently brushed against my thigh. Was it an accident? UGH THEY CAN BE SO HARD TO UNDERSTAND! Then I felt someone entangle their fingers with mine. I looked down at the couch to see Jack holding my hand. UGH! I NEED TO THINK ABOUT THIS! I released his hand and he looked a little hurt. "Where's the bathroom?"
"Across the hall from my room." He looked a little relieved but still had a look of confusion on his face.
"Thanks." I blushed as so walked hurriedly to the bathroom. I sat in the toilet with my head in my hands. What should I do?

--------------Authors Note--------------
I SHALL HOLD A CONTEST! TWO. Everyone here has heard of a character contest right? Well that's one of the contests I am doing. Add your information including name, gender, physical description, and background. You can add anything else you want. SECOND CONTEST. I have decided to make (y/n) another decently famous YouTuber! This contest is which YouTube name I shall use! Make sure to label the first contest entry (1) and the second contest entry (2). You can comment them or DM me! Thanks for reading!!!!
~~~~~•Kyleigh McLoughlin❤️~~~~~