Creepypasta Adventures

Chapter 6: Jeff won't say he's in love

(This takes place before Jeff and Ben start dating. Credits to Megara from Hercules (1997))

Jeff walked through the woods, groaning. No matter how hard he tried, he could not get a certain boy with blond hair out of his mind. He hated the fact that he was in love with someone who wasn't even of his kind. In fact, Jeff thought he hated that boy, but after some time, the way he viewed Ben changed dramatically. Jeff eventually stumbled across a small lake. He looked down at his feet to see a small rock resting right in front of his foot. Jeff sighed in frustration and kicked the rock into the lake. 

"If there's a prize for rotten judgement," Jeff sang rasply. "I guess I've already won that." He said with a sigh at the end. "No one will ever be worth the aggravation. That's just history, I've been there, I've done that!" (Jeff has an ex who cheated on him-before he killed her)

"Who ya think ya kiddin'?" A deep, raspy voice spoke. Jeff turned to see Eyeless Jack leaning against a tree.

"He's the earth an' heaven ta ya." Another voice spoke, this one much clearer and less deep than Eyeless Jack's. Jeff then spotted Laughing Jack leaning against a tree next to Eyeless.

"You try to keep it hidden," Masky and Hoodie said, sitting on the other side of the lake.

"Boy, we can all see right through you." A deep voice chuckled, and there he saw, Slenderman was towering over Jeff from behind him.

"Boy, ya can't conceal it. We know how ya feel and who ya think of day and night." Masky, Hoodie, Eyeless Jack, Laughing Jack and Slenderman sang in union.

"NO! NO! NO, NO, NO, NOOO!" Jeff screamed. "NO CHANCE, NO WAY, Y'ALL ARE CRAZY, I WON'T SAY IT!"

"You swoon," Hoodie sang.

"You sigh," Masky continued.

"Why ya denyin', woah, oh." The 5 men, excluding Jeff, sang.

"It's just, too cliche. I won't say I'm in love." Jeff growled as he tried to walk away. Then stopped and sighed. 

"I thought my heart had learned it's lesson. It feels so good when ya start out. And damn, my head is screamin' at me, 'get a grip, boy', unless you're just beggin' to cry your heart out!" Jeff sang.

"Ya keep on denyin' who ya are and how ya feelin'. Boy, no one is buyin'. We all saw ya hit the ceilin'. Face it like a man. When the hell will ya own up that ya just got, got, got it bad?"

"Uggggggghhhh! NO CHANCE. NO WAY. I WON'T SAY IT." Jeff screamed, glaring at Masky, Hoodie, Eyeless Jack, Laughing Jack and Slenderman, who are now standing side by side. Then Jeff noticed that the gloves Ben gave him fell out of his pocket and onto the ground next to him. Jeff smiled as he picked the gloves up and returned them to his pocket.

"Give up, give in. Check the grin, you're in love~"

Jeff's eyes went wide and he growled in frustration. 

"We shall never speak of this again! I won't say I'm in love."

"Boy, ya flip out. Read our lips. You're in love!"

"You couldn't be more off base! I won't say it! Now get off my case, I ain't gonna say it!"

"Boy, don't be proud. It's ok, you're in love~"

Jeff couldn't help but notice his hands getting cold. He took Ben's gloves out of his pockets and put them on his hands. Jeff smiled and sighed as he stared at the green gloves with a video game controller on it. Jeff sat down on a log nearby. 

"Well, at least out loud.....I won't say I'm in love." Jeff said as he laid back and relaxed on the log.