New to Rosewood (a pretty little liars fanfic)

Chapter 36

I walked into the interrogation room that I was in not too long ago with Mike. I sat down in the oh so familiar chair, but his time Tanner was sitting across from me. Not Holbrook.

"Macy you came in here with a lot of answers that the Rosewood PD has been looking for, for years. How did you know all that? How can I know that I know that you were telling me the truth?" Tanner got straight to it.

"Being friends with Alison you hear thing. She likes to gloat. Also why would I lie? Where would it get me? Nowhere. Telling you those things did nothing for me."

"But it did thing for other people that you care about. What you told us would help clear your cousins name. People wouldn't be afraid of Toby anymore."

"They never should have been in the first place. It was all Alison's fault."

"You kept the secret. You could have done something about it. Just like you could have told us that Alison was actually alive and not dead. Instead of wasting our time looking for a killing that didn't exist."

"I didn't know what to do. I was fourteen and I was shipped off to Michigan the next morning. Alison visited me the next week and told me not to tell anyone where she was. When you found Bethany's body and claimed it was Alison's she to me to keep quiet. I was just doing what my friend asked." I said trying to convince myself more than Tanner.

"You could have told us the about everything else before. Also why couldn't you tell me who killed Shana Fring."

"I could have, but later is better than never. And for Shana it was an accident, self defense. Shana was going to kill Ali and Aria pushed her and she fell. She didn't mean to kill her she just fell."

"The evidence at the scene does support that scenario. How do you know? You weren't in town yet."

"Friends share secrets, that's what keeps us close. We tell each other things. They told me things and that's how I knew what I told Holbrook. I promise I was telling what I was told. If it's not true, the lying is not on my part."

"One question, why would Toby take the fall for Ali?"

"Didn't Holbrook tell you? I told him everything I know."

"Ya, but I would like to know why that would make Toby take the fall. Wouldn't you want people to know if that was going on?"

"Alison thought it was the other way around. Jenna threatened to tell my aunt and uncle the story the other way around. Who do you think everyone would have believed. Taking the fall for blinding Jenna was easier than the mess of all that getting out."