A Slumber Party Massacre

Chapter 1

October 15th, 2007
    It was the big day for the Cottonwood High School varsity football team, it was the night of the big game against their rivals, the Lions. They won the game with 7 - 2, the school couldn't be more happy for their team representing their school. There was going to be a celebration in town at Ash's rich house tonight right after the game.
It's 10:00 pm, and a 1995 yellow Volkswagen Beetle pulls up in front of Ash's house. It was Elle and her boyfriend Fin. They were lucky to find a parking spot in front since the whole street was full of cars for the party.
the car turns off, and Fin and Elle sit for a while. Elle finishes doing her makeup, while Fin texts his friends he's outside. "Babe, does this lipstick look good on me? Or should I go with the other one?" Elle asked with red lipstick on her lips and pulled out her extra which was a pink lipstick. "I think you look good," Fin replied.
They get out of the car and walk up to the door, they pause once again, and Elle tells Fin that when they get inside she's going to look for her friends and leave him for a while. Fin didn't have a problem with that since he planned to do the same. He always seemed scared to be with his best friends and his girlfriend in the same house since his friends happen to be queer, and she doesn't seem like the type to support that. He assumed because she thinks they going to turn him gay.
They walk in, and the whole floor is covered in foam, and drunk high schoolers dancing and getting dirty with each other. A DJ was playing loud pop music. Elle sees her girls, Stella and Olive, they both wave at her and that's her cue to leave Fin. As she kisses him and leaves him, his friend Ash sees him and comes up to him with a big drunk welcome. "YAS MY PRINCE HAS ARRIVED!" He shouted. He hugged Fin tight and pulled him over to where the boys were. Key and Jacob. These are Fin's friends,
Ash is the horny type, who's gotten inside most of the varsity team's pants. Those boys can't resist his feminine body and the fact that he was wearing the shortest booty shorts at his party, and most of the team was dancing with him. Key is the sweetheart of the group, he too dresses feminine, except unlike Ash, he's not trying to show too much skin. He was the nicest person at school and was even the president of the 'Peace & Love' club at school. They host fundraisers to support kids with mental illnesses and disabilities, and they also help prevent bullying at school. Jacob on the other hand was the typical pot-head of the group. He was always smoking a fat joint anywhere he went. Getting high was practically a part of his daily routine. He played guitar, really well, and played it for the ladies. He was sitting outside by a tree with a group of Junior girls who fell in love with his music. Then there was Fin, He's been friends with these boys since they were in 8th grade. He remembers the day both Key and Ash came out to him, they both cried on his shoulders and he was glad to be a friend who supported his boys for who they were. He wasn't a big fan of Jacob trying his first joint when they were in 9th grade, but luckily it never seemed to hurt anyone plus they all knew that when they were feeling stressed or just felt like they needed it, he was always there to roll one up with his friends.
The boys were all glad to see Fin arrive at the party. Ash quickly left the group, two of the varsity players came up to him and soon enough they left upstairs to his bedroom. Ash left to have sex with two football players, Jacob was outside playing his guitar for a group of girls, which meant Key and Fin were left alone together. "Come, sit," Key said. Fin took a seat next to him on the red couch. "Should we get something to drink?" asked Fin.
They walked up to the bar where a bartender was cleaning shot glasses. His name is Kevin, he was a family friend of Ash's dad and was paid to serve alcohol to teens and keep it a secret.
"What could I get for you boys?" He said. "We'll get two of those blue-looking things with the gummy eyeball,"
"Coming up!"
The two of them toast their shots, they both give a laugh and a flirty smile coming from Key. He's been dealing with feelings for Fin. He never wanted to let him know since he's pretty sure Fin isn't gay, but he respects his girlfriend, which is why he doesn't try anything.
Olive was grabbing a party-size bag of chips from the pantry, quickly freezing when she spotted Fin and Key drinking and laughing together. She secretly takes out her phone and snaps a picture of the two. She runs off to the backyard where Elle and Stella are sitting and drinking some of those blue drinks with the gummy eyeballs. Olive sits and starts hyperventilating. "Olive, what's wrong?" Asked Stella. "Elle, we need to talk..." the girls all got serious and worried. She takes out her phone and shows them the picture she took of Key and Fin. Elle's mood quickly changed, she was upset to see her boyfriend drinking and laughing with a gay boy.

The party came to an end, it was 2:00 am, and Elle took off without Fin. He was curious if she was upset or if she had an emergency that she had to leave in a hurry. Jacob offered to give him a ride home, but Fin denied his offer since he knew Jacob was high as a kite. He decided to walk since he only lived a couple blocks away.
Ash was dead asleep by the time the guests all left, the two boys left him weak and tired. Jacob drove home in his hippy van. Key got a ride from one of the Peace & Love members.
Fin walked home in the dark streets, it was quiet and lonely. He didn't seem to mind it since he enjoyed lonely time to himself. He heard a creek come from behind one of the neighbor's bushes. He got creeped out and crossed the street just to get past the house.
He tried calling Elle to see if everything was okay, no answer after two call attempts. He left her a voicemail hoping she would get back to him once she got the chance. "Hey, babe, uh, just wanted to check on you, hope everything is okay? Uh, you left me at the party, and I'm walking home alone, I just hope you're not drunk driving, stay safe, love you!"
Fin arrived home, he walked up to his door and heard the sound of a car slowing down in front of his house. he turned around and saw a car that stopped in front of his house, he got creeped out because this car just stood in the middle of the road, you couldn't see inside, the windows were dark and the sound of a car on just in the middle of the street, knowing that whoever is in there is looking at you.
He got scared and quickly unlocked his front door and walked inside. Locked the door, ran upstairs to his bedroom, locked that door too, and peeked out the curtains. the car was gone.
He undressed himself, leaving on only his tighty whities, He got a notification on his phone, and he quickly checked his phone hoping it would be Elle. "Hey Fin, I heard you walked home after the party. Are you okay? Are you home yet? Please answer when you see this, I'm worried!" It was Key.
Fin lay in bed and replied to Key, "Hey, Yeah, I'm home safe and sound. I'm in bed right now ready to go to sleep," Key felt warm after reading the part about him being in bed since he knew that Fin usually sleeps in his underwear, Key was also in bed, he felt erect down there and proceeded to chat with Fin. "I'm glad you're home safe!"
"Thank you! Although there was something weird, there was a car that stopped in front of my house when I got home, they didn't get out or anything, they just stood there in the middle of the street, I quickly ran inside and locked all the doors, including my room, and I peaked out my window and luckily they were gone."
"oh my god! That's so scary! I'm sorry I couldn't walk home with you, we could have had a sleepover, like the old days!"  Key wanted to be there for his friend. He couldn't bear the thought of something happening to Fin out on the street, and no one would be around to witness.
They finished their conversation soon enough because Fin fell asleep. The key was wide awake thinking of him. He started looking through pictures of them with their friends together, he had a picture with everyone at Ash's pool that weekend in the summer when his parents were out and they had the place to themselves and decided to be 'boys'. The picture was the four of them by the pool in women's underwear, since Ash and Key were the two feminine ones, they started experimenting by wearing feminine underwear, and they thought it would be fun for the group to show their support to their two outed gay friends, by wearing panties to the pool. After all, Ash claimed it was just "Boys being boys".
Key looked at the picture with him and Fin together and, he couldn't help himself, he pulled his penis out and started touching himself. He moaned softly before he could climax, he heard his little sister coming out of her room to use the restroom. He freaked out and realized he was probably moaning too loud. He laid in bed naked and fell asleep to his nighttime playlist, he created a playlist to help him fall asleep faster.