Sarah Sanderson X Male Reader

1.1K 16 8
                                    

Winifred, Mary and Sarah all get onto the bus hitching a ride.
The bus driver flirted a little with both Mary and Winifred, while Sarah curiously walked around the bus.
Then she saw You in the backseat.

Sarah felt her 300 year old heart flutter and skip behind her chest, as she felt love at first sight

Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.

Sarah felt her 300 year old heart flutter and skip behind her chest, as she felt love at first sight. It got her red and nervous, all she could do was stare, bite her lip, realizing she was drooling.
She was desperate for love, she had not had the chance to settle down or feel any kind of long relationship in the last 300 years, and the only person she ever did come close to getting with was Winifred's ex Billy Bucherson, who unbeknownst to her was having affair between the two sisters, he was in love with her and not Winifred, so Winifred cursed him. But who could love a wicked witch such as herself? No less a Sanderson Witch. She not so subtlety tried to flirt with you, as she crept beside you, watching you distracted by your iPod and headphones.
But then the bus hit a speed bump and she fell over landing in your lap, startling you. She held onto your back, while she accidentally landing beneath your crotch, where she then stared and blushed at your impressive package.
She then heard you say something, but she looked up at you, still holding your iPod and earbuds
She stared at the strange device plugged into your ear, she tilted her head and started poking the earbud curiously.
"Wha-hey!"
You grabbed her hand, making her blush more
"Well..hi there!"
She giggled.
"Are you..okay? You fell."
Sarah blinked, using the opportunity she then pretended to be injured
"Oh..yes! Oh my knee it hurts so much! Could you pick me up please?"
She gave You cute puppy dog eyes.
You reluctantly picked her up by the hips, and she sat down right next to you.
"Oh!...what strong arms you have mortal..."
You were both flustered and amazed by the woman sitting there. You could tell she was trying to be a witch by the dress and broom admiring it, but what she just said made very little sense.
"I'm sorry, mortal?"
You questioned
"You are a mortal, you know. I am an immortal witch"
She pointed to herself
It then clicked, she was acting as her character. Lots of kids in Halloween costumes like to get in character and act like the person they are cosplaying as.
"Ah. I see, your a witch. Your dress is very beautiful, did you buy this or design it yourself?"
Sarah blushed
"Oh...I made it myself...magic."
Sarah then subtly gave you a strip tease revealing her legs just below her knees.
"By the way, what is that...thing you have?"
Sarah poked the earbuds again
"Umm...it's an iPod. And these are my earbuds?"
You pointed
"...what's an earbuds?"
She asked
"...okay, well have you ever wanted to take all your favorite music with you wherever you go?"
You asked
"My...favorite music??"
She twirled her finger in her hair.
You handed her an earbud, to which she examined it curiously, before comedically trying to place it properly into her ear.
"Wow..."
Sarah was blown away by the modern technology that her lifetime was not even close to inventing or comprehending.
"Wow...so you like creepy girls, mortal?"
She asked listening to the song "your so creepy".
"Pretty good? I assume your not overly fond of these."
"Oh..well, I don't really need that...'iPod'...I can sing to myself."
She began to pull her hair
"I can show you if you like."
"Uh..okay."
You shrugged, as Sarah clears her throat and she begins to sing in her siren voice, where unbeknownst to you was a form of hypnosis. All of a sudden you were in a trance, and you began feeling differently about Sarah.
This went beyond love at first sight, You were suddenly madly in love.
"Wow...hey, did I say that dress was beautiful on You?"
You blushed

Marvel and Disney Women X Male Reader Where stories live. Discover now