You are welcome to use these criteria as a guide for your feedback. But you don't have to! This is just a help ;)
Logic
Does the story make sense?
Does it fit into the story?
Do the existing characters behave according to their character?
Writing style
Is the story easy to read?
Are there no/few spelling mistakes or grammatical errors?
Are the actions/events/places etc. well and sufficiently described?
Cover
Does it arouse curiosity?
Does it attract readers?
Is it beautiful to look at?
Does it fit the story?
Idea
Is the idea original?
Has it been realised well?
Title/flap text
Does it fit the story?
Does it promise suspense?
Does it attract readers?
Protagonist
Does the main character act comprehensibly or according to his character?
Is the character original?
Is it easy to empathise with him/her/them?
Do you sympathise with him/her/them?
Suspense
Do you really want to read on and find out what happens?
Are there any unpredictable twists?
YOU ARE READING
The Bookclub of Fandoms
RandomA warm welcome! You are a passionate fangirl/fanboy and would like to exchange ideas with authors of other fanfictions, gain new readers, get comments and feedback on your stories or simply get to know new books? Then you've come to the right place...
