Sam's Step Sister

Chapter 14

For the first time in a long time Jennifer came to class. Styled in her usual baggy hoodie and leggings, always comfort over everything else. Although she was in such a casual outfit, it didn't stop the guys from staring. Even I could admit she had a very voluptuous arse. We have been joined at the hip all day, we haven't seen Quinn or Brittany yet, she keeps reminding me to point her out and I would if I could. I can now, It's lunch and I can see them both about to walk into the lunch hall I tap Jen lightly and motion with my eyes and a slight head movement in their direction. 

"Oh damn she is pretty" She says as her eyes widen. 

"Shhh, she might hear you" I hit her on the arm and she gives me an incredulous look. 

"As if, they're across the hall Santana, stop being paranoid" I let her look but I almost died when Brittany looked straight over at us and saw both me and Jen staring. instead of looking away in embarrassment I carried on staring, letting her know I wasn't going to be a coward. I don't know what I expected her to do, but it wasn't what she did, she gave me a soft, sad smile before looking away. 

"She doesn't seem like a cheat to me" Jen shrugged and carried on eating. I watched her eat, or rather scarf down the food like she hasn't eaten in weeks. I chuckled watching her, wishing I could eat food like that and not think about it too much, and still have the body she does "What?" She asks, mouth full of food when she notices. 

"Oh nothing" I say and look away, trying to find Brittany again but she's gone. so is Quinn "I was thinking you join Glee too. You can be my back up when I perform this week. It'll be fun, even if you can't sing" 

"Yeah, even if I can't sing" She says, uncharacteristically ominous. 

... 

"Okay glee club, who has-"

"I do mister Shue" I stand and raise my hand, he motions for me to take the space "And I brought a friend" I say after and Jen stands up from the back. I take a glance at Brittany, she's just sitting, waiting, ignoring Quinn who is whispering in her ear. 

I start by walking to the musicians and telling them the song I picked, I give them a minute before me and Jen smile at each other and I start singing. 

Don't speak, no, don't try
It's been a secret for the longest time
Don't run (oh), no, don't hide
Been running from it for the longest time

We didn't discuss who would be singing what but when Jen started the next line, it's safe to say I was shocked. 

So many mornings, I woke up confused
In my dreams, I do anything I want to you
My emotions are naked, they're taking me out of my mindRight now, I'm shameless
Screamin' my lungs out for ya
Not afraid to face it
I need you more than I want to
Need you more than I want to
Show me you're shameless
Write it on my neck, why don't ya?
And I won't erase it
I need you more than I want to
Need you more than I want to

we sang the chorus together and I started the next verse.

So we're there, now it's real
Now that you have me, do you want me still?
My kisses are history, they go back a long time, uh
And I'm tired of loving somebody that's not mine, no

We were walking around together, facing off, going close and then far apart, I couldn't help but notice the pure emotion in her voice. 

So many mornings, I woke up confused
In my dreams, I do anything I want to you
My emotions are naked, they're taking me out of my mindRight now, I'm shameless
Screamin' my lungs out for ya
Not afraid to face it
I need you more than I want to
Need you more than I want to
Show me you're shameless
Write it on my neck, why don't ya?
And I won't erase it
I need you more than I want to
Need you more than I want to

the next lines were mine 

There's just inches in between us
I want you to give in, I want you to give in, oh
There is tension in between us
I just wanna give in
And I don't care if I'm forgiven

The next time the chorus hit we both sang together, each others voices complementing each other. Her voice was so thick and raspy. incredible. 

Right now, I'm shameless
Screamin' my lungs out for ya
Not afraid to face it
I need you more than I want to
Need you more than I want to
Show me you're shameless
Write it on my neck, why don't ya?
And I won't erase it
I need you more than I want to
I need you more than I want to

After we finished our song, the room rounded in applause. We were both out of breath afterwards and staring at each other intently. Although the moment was intense between us, all I could think about is if Brittany was jealous. And by my quick side eye, it looked as if she was. I smiled and hugged Jen, whispering that we had succeeded. She smiled softly at me too and looked to Brittany with disgust. I frowned a little but got distracted with all the praise from the other members from Glee. Everyone seemed to love Jen too, even Rachel was happy to find another star. 

sorry for the short chapter -  I hope you enjoyed reading it nonetheless. Be sure to check out my instagrams - elliebsanders_ and elliebrook_s thanks! more to come.