𝐀𝐦𝐧𝐞𝐬𝐢𝐚 (Ticci Toby x FEM reader)

ɪᴠᴇʀ

In the midst of Eyeless Jack and Toby's bickering, Y/N's water broke. Her face flashed with panic, and she stood up, but she ended up sitting back down because of the pain. This caught Toby's attention.

"Y/N, what's wrong?" Toby asked, pausing the conversation he was having.

Y/N looked up at Toby with a hand on her stomach. Spikes of pain started to shoot through her entire body.

"I think my water broke," Y/N said.

Toby's expression morphed into sudden worry, and Eyeless Jack quickly went over to her.

"We need to get her to the bathroom."  Jack said with a calm urgency in his tone. Toby nodded and helped Jack carry Y/N to the bathroom. Something didn't seem right—the baby was coming early? That didn't make any sense!

During the hours of labor that Y/N endured, Toby was scrambling around the house, trying to get everything Jack needed. They didn't have time to prepare because of the early delivery. Toby came back to Jack with things like water bottles, rags, and towels. Seeing Y/N yell and cry in so much pain made him cringe for her, so he ended up pacing around behind Jack as he kept telling her to control her breathing and push.

Finally, the baby popped out, and Jack caught it in his hands. Everybody was nearly exhausted and sweating from the stress. The baby was definitely supernatural. It was obvious since the baby had no umbilical cord.

Y/N was catching her breath with tears of relief as her body trembled in shock.

"It's a boy," Eyeless Jack said, gently wiping away the black goop that covered the baby with a towel. He gently handed the baby to Y/N.

Y/N held the baby on her chest. It surprisingly wasn't crying at all. Toby stepped around Eyeless Jack to crouch next to Y/N.

The baby had wispy, white hair on the top of his little head. The baby was pale, but that was just Slenderman's genetics. For such a horrible father, he sure did have a cute baby. The baby was sleeping on her as if he wasn't just the most painful experience of Y/N's life.

"It's so tiny..." Toby said, his fingers gently caressing the baby's head.

Eyeless Jack took the towels that were covered in black goop, and he discarded them while they had their little moment. Though Jack wanted to hold the baby, he knew he had to be patient and wait for his turn.

Toby watched as Jack left the room momentarily.

"Do you want help up to the bed?" He asked, looking at her and the baby.

"Yes, please," she said tiredly. "Hold the baby."

Toby quickly offered his arms to pick up the tiny one. He supported the baby's neck with his hand to the best of his ability and held it against him. Eyeless Jack came back into the room and saw Y/N struggling to stand on her own. He opened his arms near Toby.

"Let me hold," Eyeless Jack said. "You need to help her up."

Toby sighed and gently handed the baby to Jack. Eyeless Jack gently held the baby and brought it into the nursery, which Toby had to point out to him.

Toby helped Y/N over to bed because she looked like she was about to pass out in his arms.

"Are you feeling okay?" Toby asked worriedly as she laid down.

"I need a nap, but if the baby wakes up, tell me," she said sleepily as she rested her head on the pillow.

Toby put a hand on her cheek and kissed her gently. He parted the kiss and looked at her in the eyes. He was anxious and excited about the baby, and they haven't even decided a name yet!

"I will, I promise," Toby said, leaving one last kiss on her forehead before turning on the fan and leaving the room.

He quickly went to the nursery, where he saw Jack holding the baby. The baby was now in a diaper, and it didn't have any more black sludge on it. Toby's hands twitched at the thought of holding the baby, but he was still awkward now that Jack was acting like the baby's nanny.

Eyeless Jack glanced down at the baby before looking back up at Toby.

"The baby has the symbol," Eyeless Jack said, turning so that Toby could see the mark.

The baby has a tiny ⦻ marking on his shoulder, and Toby stepped closer to get a better look. Toby sighed, gently caressing the baby's arm.

"Yeah, I know..." Toby said sadly, looking at the baby's tiny face. He felt bad for the little guy. He personally knew what it was like to have a shitty parent. Toby just hoped that the baby wouldn't turn out like Slenderman.

After a few hours, Y/N woke up from her nap. Somehow, she wasn't sore in the slightest. She felt rather energized and awake. Y/N sat up in bed and rubbed her eyes.

Y/N hopped out of bed and opened the bedroom door. It was rather quiet, even though there were two guys and a baby in the cabin.

"Toby? Jack?" Y/N called out, opening the door to the nursery.

Both boys were looking over the crib, where the baby was sleeping peacefully. They were acting like two guards protecting an ancient treasure. Y/N let out a thankful sigh that they were still there.

"Oh, you're awake!" Toby smiled.

Eyeless Jack hopped up and slapped a hand over Toby's mouth to silence him. Toby was instantly filled with regret. The baby stirred in the crib, and they all huddled around to see. They looked at each other, then back to the baby.

The baby whined and opened his big eyes. In contrast with the rest of his features, the baby's eye color was as black as a raven's feathers. They all stared at the adorable sight as the baby stared back at them blankly. After the baby seemed to notice all the stares, his face scrunched up, and he started to cry.

"Awww..." Y/N whispered as she reached into the crib to gingerly pick up the baby. The baby's little hands gripped the fabric of her shirt as he sobbed, likely in her arms.

"Is he hungry?" Eyeless Jack asked.

"No, he's scared of your fat face," Toby said to Jack.

"Shush, he's probably hungry." Y/N gently nudged Toby with her shoulder as she went over to the cabinet full of formula.

The baby blubbered against Y/N, looking at the two big, scary guys that were looking back at him. Toby crossed his arms but gave up trying to uphold a tough demeanor.

"I'll go get some milk," Toby said, walking out of the room before peeking his head back in, "but I'll be back. I'm not going anywhere," he quickly said, going to the fridge and pulling out the carton of milk. He rushed back to the nursery and set it on the table for Y/N.

Eyeless Jack stared back at the baby, who seemed to never blink. The sobs turned into muffled whimpers as the baby started to mindlessly suckle on his fingers.

"What are you going to name the baby?" Eyeless Jack asked.

Y/N thought about the question for a little bit as she mixed the formula in the bottle. She looked back at the baby, who had ivory-white hair and milky skin. It was difficult to think of something original, but over the past few days, there was one name that stuck with her.

"Iver"