My first request, you got a problem with polyamory then kick rocks, you don't have to read THIS story, just request something that's more your territory! I won't judge you.
________________________________
You stood at your window looking outside, the mansion was quiet as people started settling down from their missions. You squinted your eyes, trying to spot any movement outside before closing the blinds.
You got into bed and closed your eyes. Just before you fully dozed off, light started seeping into your room from your door. You looked over at it to see two familiar faces in the doorway. You sat up as the light flicked on. "What are you guy's doing back so late?"
"We got hungry." Hoodie tossed some fast food onto your bed and handed you your favorite drink. Mask quietly sat down with a sigh, resting his legs and getting his pill bottle out of his pocket. We had to trick a dog into going outside before we could get into our victims house."
He popped two pills into his hand and you took a sip of your drink before handing it off to Masky, letting him drink it to make his pills go down better.
"How sweet of you to not kill the dog, if only other people were that sparing." You mumbled, the two nodded and looked at you. Alright, it's Saturday. The night you pick who you wanna stay with, which one will it be?" Hoodie asked. You pondered for a minute.
(I got three choices written out, so pick your poison!)
Masky:
"I choose Tim." You said, Hoodie nodded and said goodnight before leaving. Masky took off his his coat and shirt. "It's always so got in here." He grumbled. You smiled.
"That's because I'm in here." You said confidently, taking a pause from eating just to make him aware of your confidence. He paused to look at you before plopping into bed. "Whatever helps you sleep at night."
Your mouth dropped as you looked at him. "I change my mind now, I want Brian back now."
"Too late, you're stuck with me now." He wrapped his arms around you and buried his face into your neck. "You know I'm your favorite."
You huffed and turned away from him. "Whatever helps you sleep at night."
________________________________
Hoodie:
"I choose Brian." You said. Masky stretched and got up. "Yeah yeah- night night, sleep tight, don't let the killers bite." And with that he left your room. You smiled at Brian who lovingly hugged you as you ate.
"I'm so tired." He mumbled. You nodded slowly. "Bummer, just go to sleep then."
"I'll feel rude since I was already late getting back." He mumbled, slowly dozing off anyway. You smiled. "Whatever you say Brian, night."
"Night." He whispered, leaning against you.
________________________________
Uh-oh! Double trouble:
"I'll feel bad for whoever I don't pick, so both."
The two looked at you, glancing at eachother before shrugged. Tim hopped in the bed and Brian sat beside you. The three of you talked as the two men started to doze off, leaving you awake to eat your food.
Once finished, you looked down at the two and smiled. "I think this was an excellent choice." You laid down between them with a victorious chuckle before falling asleep as well.
YOU ARE READING
Creepypasta x YOU
Fanfiction(Please read this, you've already read this far in the caption so why not read ONE chapter) Getting bored of cringy or boring oneshots of your favorite serial killer lover since middle school that change your independent cunning partner into some ra...
