Yandere!Under verse x Reader

The First Villager and Memories

A/n: this is about a month later

~~~

A month passed and the brothers had no idea what they were doing trying to raise a toddler, but they slowly got the hang of it thanks to a cat named Neil. The brothers also got a schedule going between them, Dream would take care of them in the mornings and early afternoons, and Nightmare got her late afternoons and evenings, and both got them at night because sleepy time. At the current moment, Dream is running around the village, doing errands for people, so that leaves Y/n with Nightmare, listening to him read a book, their tail flicking.

Nightmare:...and then the bunny fell into a hole after being too smug at being faster than the tortoise.

Y/n: tot...oise?

Nightmare, nodding: tortoise. It's a type of reptilian creature that has a shell. It can hide in it.

Y/n: :0

Nightmare chuckles and pats Y/n's head, ruffling their fur. Y/n squeaks happily, leaning into the touch as their wings flap, the down feathers on their wings fluffing up, with some feathers coming off of her wings. Nightmare pulls his hand away and y/n pouts, wanting attention from her big brother. Nightmare raises an eyebrow, chuckling.

Nightmare: what? You want more hugs?

Y/n nods, squeaking as their fur fluffs up. Nightmare shakes his head and pulls Y/n into a hug, going back to reading out loud as y/n listens with rapt attention.

Nightmare: the bunny was in the hole for what felt like hours, and then the tortoise appeared. The bunny got angry at it, seeing as it was the reason why it was in the hole.

Y/n:..bun...ny

Nightmare, nodding: bunny. They are small and fluffy

Y/n, shaking their head: bunny

Nightmare, raising an eyebrow: what about a bunny?

Y/n, pointing: bunny!

Nightmare looks up and curses once he sees a villager approaching and they look angry. Nightmare quickly picks up Y/n and hops into the tree, setting Y/n down gently.

Nightmare: alright Y/n...you need to stay here while I take care of this?...i-if you hear some yelling, don't worry about it or come out until me or Dream come and get you, yeah?

Y/n, wide eyes:...brother...be otay?

Nightmare, nodding: I'll be okay, promise!

Nightmare holds out his pinky. Y/n stares at it, before shaking his pink with her own, and they shake on it. Nightmare pulls his hand away and pats Y/n's head.

Nightmare: be back soon...sister

Y/n nods and watches as Nightmare hops out of the tree, holding their tail in anxiety. Y/n isn't sure how or why, but they know that the villager is bad news and somehow they could see into the villagers mind...Y/n didn't like that. Y/n wanted to help their brother...so Y/n, being the clueless goat toddler they are, peers down the tree, and then recoils back because the tree is tall and they are smol, so it looks even bigger to them. Y/n sees the angry villager approach and back off abit so she doesn't see her. Y/n soon hears yelling and their wings lower in sadness and anxiety.

Villager1: YOU USELESS-

Y/n isn't sure what happened. They heard the villager yelling at her brother, and suddenly, they could see the villagers memories and of how awful they treated her brother, both of her brothers. Y/n is just as suddenly forced from the villagers memories and is back in reality. Y/n can't handle all of them emotions and what they saw, so they tear up and start to cry, but as quietly as they can so the villager doesn't hear and hurt Nightmare worse. They don't want their brother to get hurt worse because of them. That would make her feel horrible. After what felt like forever, the villager left and Nightmare climbed up the tree, injured, but nothing he couldn't handle. Nightmare grunted softly, his ribs aching as he made it to the spot where he left Y/n at, only to see her crying. His eyelights softened and he pulled them into a hug, causing her to squirm.