"In love with a killer." (SamGolbach x Reader)

Ch. 21

Y/n's Pov:

Secretly, I think I always knew it was him. I always knew it was Sam doing the murders and blaiming it on Colby. He even went as far as to fake having a split personality and then come home to me covered in blood. What really happened that night I wander. I bet Sam made Colby cover for him and then he destroyed the evidence so they'd release Sam because he threatened Colby. I should've never dated Sam. And a few moments ago, I learned the truth.

-10 hours ago-

Silver's Pov:

"Alright Colby, I can call you that right, Colby?," "Yeah that's fine.," "Alright, start from the begining.," "Well I was dating this girl he liked and-," "No, I want the WHOLE story. Start from 2 years ago when we first arrested him, what happened that night?," "Sam had been acting crazy. He'd been claiming to be posessed from one of our haunted locations we went to even after we got whatever demon that was in him out. He made up a whole persona, Mas, Sam spelled backwards. The people he killed... They were close friends.. Some I didn't know, like that one guy they found at the bottom of a clif for example. I'd never seen him before. But I did know Katrina. I was really close with her before she passed. Sam told me about all of it... The murders, the urges, everything. The night he was arrested, he told Y/n, his girlfriend now and then, he told her what he'd done. She was terrified and had nightmares for years since then. He made me destroy evidence and threatened my life if I told anyone and for 2 years I was so scared. And he made me keep it from Y/n. For a while, Y/n and I dated as well, until I got stupid and cheated on her with Jane. She caught us and ran to Sam about it. Jane went missing a few days later. I got scared I was next so, I called Kris and Caleb to come get me. While I was staying at their house, Sam followed me there somehow. Caleb found him wandering around and knocked him out and yes, we did tie him up and I did carve my name into his chest out of anger. I only wanted to show him how hs victims felt. I promise you, if you believe me, please, you have to realize you've got the wrong guy behind bars." Colby explained and I listened and watched his movements. He was telling the truth. "Thank you for your information, we almost have everything we need to put that psycho behind bars. Just wait a little longer and you'll be out of here." I said as I left the room. I texted Grace the info I found out and told her my next plan of action. I had my agents track where Y/n was. I need to talk to her alone.

-5 houres after the talk-

I tracked Y/n down to a coffee shop downtown. I walked into the coffee shop and ordered a vanilla iced coffee and spotted Y/n. I walked over to her once I got my drink. "Miss L/n right? May I sit?," "Of course Agent Silver, wha brings you here?," "Oh, I was just here getting my usual when I spotted you. I need to talk to you Y/n.," "Alright, what's up?," "Not here, somewhere a little more private, please?" Y/n nodded and we walked out to my car. "Alright Y/n, I'm gonna need your full cooperation, what do you recall from the night Sam was arrested 2 years ago?," "Well, he came to me covered in blood, saying his other personality made him kill again. I was so scared and then he told me he did the murders which scared me more. He told me that there was no other personality and that it was all made up to keep me from finding out. Then he was arrested but he was released because the evidence was destroyed. He told me later on it was Colby who made him do everything and that he didn't want to out his best friend like that and then I didn't talk to him for 2 years. That's all I know.," "Well, what if I told you we have evidence Sam did it, would you believe us?," "But Colby's DNA was found at the scene, what evidence do you have against Sam?," "The stories don't match up. I had a chat with Colby and I know a liar and a killer when I see one, and Colby didn't even show a hint of lying. He also didn't have that almost unnoticible sadistic glint in his eyes that most killers have. Miss L/n, Colby is innocent and we need your help to prove it. Y/n, would you be okay with wearing a wire? We'll talk you through what to say, I know this is scary but your cooperation would be greatly appriciated.," "I won't do it. My Sam would never hurt anyone like that. I'm sorry but I can't help you." She said and got out of my car. Damnit, now I'll have to find someone else to help, someone not as close as Y/n.

Y/n's Pov:

I drove home in a rush. Sam wouldn't be there for a while so I had time to think. I have to know the truth. Even so, I'd never sell him out. I was in too deep. I'm his ride-or-die. I love him and I'd never let anyone hurt him, even if he was a killer. But at the same time, I know he needed to be behind bars and I knew I had to do what was right.

-an hour before present-

I had done enough thinking and I've cone up with questions. Just as I finished, Sam walked through the door, perfect timing. "Sam honey, welcome home my dear. How was your day?" "My day was interesting, to say the least, how was yours?," "My day was interesting as well. In fact, a certain Agent Silver came up to me while I was having coffee and asked me a bunch of questions. I covered your ass and you better love me for it until the day you die.," "Y/n what are you talking about?," "I know you did it and I know why. You were doing it to protect me. Well today I protected you. She asked me to wear a wire but I refused.," "Y/n I-," "No, you nothing. I can't keep something like this from them. You are a criminal and you deserve to be where Colby is but, I can't bring myself to turn you in. But I should. I love you Sam but I can't let you hut other people." I watched his facial expression go cold and then he gave me a smile I'd never seen before. "Wow, look at you, detective Y/n! You cracked the case but, I wish you hadn't. You know, I did like you. It's a shame it's come to this." Then he came up behind me and it all went black.

Silver's Pov:

I planted a bug on Y/n and got the whole confesstion on tape. I sent it to the police station and we were on our way to the apartments. I just hope we aren't too late.

-present time-

Y/n's Pov:

I woke up to mine and Sam's bedroom. Sam was in the room with me sitting on the bed. I tried to sit up but I quickly realized I was tied down. "Oh, you're awake. Good. Y/n I hate to do this but you were gonna rat me out. I can't let that happen.," "You won't get away with this, someone will find me!," "Oh my dear, nobody's going to find you where you're going." He said while grabbing my chin and making me look up at him. "Where are you taking me? Tell me damnit Sam!," "So feisty, I sure have found a bold one this time. You know, you look really sexy like that." He said as he got closer to me. He bent down and started to kiss my neck causing me to scream. "What are you doing?!," "What? I can't kiss my girlfriend's neck? That doesn't sound like someone who loves me.," "I love you but, you're sick in the head Sam! You need help!," "No, what I need is you." He said as he started kissing down my body. I started squirming and he didn't like that. He took out a blade and started making cuts in my arms, not deep, but they still stung. I winced as I felt the blade against my skin. "Now, be a good girl and I won't have to hurt you, I don't want to hurt you but you're making me.," "Wait! If you let me go I promise you I'll stay by your side. I won't run and I won't tell anyone what you did!," "Do you mean it?," "With all my heart." I said seductively and he untied me. Just as he finished, I broke free and ran out of the door before he could catch me. I ran as fast as possible until I bumped into someone. I looked up to see Agent Silver and a bunch of S.W.A.T team members behind her swarmed the apartment. Agent Silver held me and I cried in her arms as they brought Sam who gave me a sadistic smile. "Baby, tell them this is all a missunderstanding.," "He did it Agent Silver. He did it all, you were right." I said through choked breaths. "I know sweetie, I know." She said as she hugged me tightly. "Take him away boys, and tell Colby Brock he's free to go, Kris and Caleb are there to get him." And after that I was brought in for questioning. And that night, I told them everything I knew about Samuel Golbach.

A/n: Yooo let's go!! Another chapter and it's WAY longer. As this story comes to a close I'd like you all to enjoy this chapter and I'll see you all in the next chapter.