The Vampire Diaries X Reader

We Do Share Her - Poly! Mikaelsons x Reader - Smut

Hayley and Klaus walked into the house, they were discussing the witches, and that's when they heard you and Kol a few rooms over in the parlour. You and Kol were known to be pretty promiscuous, often being very comfortable with PDA. Kol would smack your ass frequently with Hayley around, or kiss you or touch you in some way. Like during family meetings, he'd grab you and pull you to sit in his lap or drop your legs to rest on him.

But Hayley never thought you'd be doing this, straight up fucking in the open for anyone to see. You both could be heard moaning or panting, and you occasionally crying out Kol's name.

"That is pretty bold of them," Hayley said.

"I'm used to it; they do shit like this often," Klaus responded.

"And you guys are just cool with it? It's kinda disgusting. Like, don't all you guys use that room?"

"Yes, we do, but we all love her so much that it doesn't make much of a difference. Don't get me wrong, I don't want to be seeing Kol naked."

"What about her? Kol's girlfriend?"

"What about her?"

"You're just cool with her running around here naked and being openly fucked by your younger brother? Does it not bother any of your siblings?"

"Well, we are sharing her, so I guess it doesn't bother us that much."

"Sharing her? Like you guys are all sleeping with her?"

Klaus smiles.

"Yeah, right," Hayley said, not believing what Klaus just told her.

If Hayley were looking at Klaus closely, she would've seen how turned on Klaus was getting just from hearing you moaning.

You were, in fact, being tossed around from Mikaelson to Mikaelson. You were dating all of the siblings; it just made sense to you guys. It fit perfectly with their hectic schedule and their needs. You truly loved it and wouldn't change it for the world, even though you knew it might be kind of weird to outsiders.

After Hayley left, and you and Kol had finally given it a break, Klaus waited to pounce. He knew that since you had tempted him earlier, you were going to get it.

You were bent over Klaus' table in his painting room, Klaus fucking the shit out of you. You gripped the table as you rested your forehead on it.

Hayley came back to the home with Elijah; neither person knew what you and Klaus were up to. It didn't take long once the two entered the front foyer to hear what was happening. Elijah walked over to Klaus' painting room with the French doors open wide and stood in the entryway.

"Really? Like, we didn't deal with this earlier?" Elijah said.

Klaus growled in your ear and he lifted his body off your back and looked at Elijah before pushing deeper into you, causing you to cry out. Klaus smiled at Elijah as he kept going.

Hayley joined Elijah's side, then saw you and Klaus; her eyes went wide before looking away.

Elijah and Hayley moved away from Klaus' room and shortly after, Klaus joined Elijah and Hayley.

"You're actually sleeping with her. All of you?" Hayley said to Klaus

"I did tell you we share her."

"I didn't think you were being serious."

"Believe it."

"Is that not gross or weird?"

"No, it's pretty nice actually."

"Is that not weird for you, Elijah? Watching your brother fuck your girlfriend?"

"Not really. I like knowing she's being taken care of," Elijah said.

"I don't get it."

"It's not for you to get," Klaus said as he walked off.

A few days later, when Hayley had cooled off and tried to understand that you were with all the Mikaelsons. She walked into the house and called out for Elijah as they were to go out. Hayley was surprised that the house was pretty quiet.

She started to walk further into the house, still calling out for Elijah. She walked into the kitchen, and that's when she heard the whimpering of Rebekah. Hayley saw Rebekah lying on the island countertop with her one leg over your shoulder. Your head was buried between her legs, and your hand was under her shirt, kneading her boob.

Rebekah had one hand on your head in your hair and the other gripped the marble countertop. Hayley stood shocked, even Rebekah, she thought. Elijah came around the corner and placed a hand on Hayley's shoulder.

"We should go, leave them to it."

Hayley went rigid and looked up at Elijah, "sorry, I was just kinda shocked."

"Didn't think she was also sleeping with Rebekah?"

"No, I didn't expect that. I guess it makes sense if she's with all of you guys."

"Let's head out and leave them to it."

Hayley and Elijah left, but all Hayley could think about was how she was losing Elijah. She figured she could try harder to pull him away and hope that it would work. She didn't want you to have him; he was hers. She would have to put more effort into getting Elijah on her side and away from you and his siblings.

However, Hayley was centuries too late.

You started dating the Mikaelsons in the 1400s; it was a slow progression, but now you were inseparable. You had all been through so many things together and fought so hard to be together. None of you would change anything for the world, you worked too hard to lose this connection and it was something all of you held dear.

You were truly family.

Hayley came over to see Elijah, she walked into the house and heard someone fucking you. She figured it was Kol or Klaus, then she ran into Klaus in the parlour.

"Where's Elijah?"

"Upstairs," Klaus said.

"He's with her?"

"Yes, obviously."

"So, if you and her and the others are dating, what about us?"

"What about us?"

"We slept together. While in theory, you two were together. Does she even know about us? Does she even know that Hope is yours and that we had sex?"

Before Klaus could even respond, you spoke as you walked down the stairs with Elijah in tow.

"Short answer, yes," you said as you fixed your hair.

Neither of them realized that the sounds had stopped.

"To answer that question fully, I pissed Klaus off. I said some terrible things, and Klaus was pissed. I deserved it, and we talked about it, and we're cool, we've moved passed it. I mean, we have Hope, I'd never give that up. Of course, when I found out, I threw a hissy fit, but Klaus paid a premium. No sex for a month. Not many alphas can handle that," by the time you finished, you made it to the bottom of the stairs case and next to Klaus.

Hayley looked at you with some disbelief in her eyes. How you were okay with your life-long partner sleeping with another woman was beyond her.

"As well, Hayley, Elijah is not yours," Klaus said to Hayley as he saw right through her plans. The girl stood there dumbfounded as Klaus, Elijah, and you walked off.