Tell Me That You Love Me

The confrontation

Finn:You shouldn't be here.

Robby:Excuse me?

Finn:You heard me.

Robby:Do I know you?

Finn:No. But I know you. I know you to well. Sometimes I even wish that I didn't, because you make me sick, from what you did! You left you daughter and your wife! And then you come back like you didn't do anything! Like nothing ever happened! How can you do that?! They were your daughter and your wife! Did you not care?! Because your daughter is at my house right now, wishing that you never left and that you stayed! She's crying her heart, because of you! You left! Not anyone else, YOU! You left your family! Why?! That's all I need to know! Why?!

Robby:*shocked*I-I-I-I-I.....I don't know.

Finn:*furious*You don't know?! So there was no excuse! You just left! Am I right?!

Robby:Yes.*looks down*I just wasn't ready to have a child.

Finn:So you left? Shelby needed you! But most importantly Rachel needed you!

Robby:She's called Rachel? I have a daughter?

Finn:No, no, no, no, no, no. You HAD a daughter. But that was before you left her. Do you know she had to watch everyone grow up with a dad , while she only had a mother figure, but I guess that's why we're best friends, because at first we both only had a mom, but then I got a dad and Rachel wished and hoped that someone like Burt would come into Shelby's life, but Shelby just couldn't do it, cause she woke up every day hoping that you would knock on the door and realise what you did, and that you were sorry for it.

Robby:I am. I'm so sorry. Everyday I regret what I did. Everyday I wish I could turn back time so I would have never done that. I'm so sorry. I'm so so sorry.

Finn:You're apologizing to the wrong person.*starts to walk away, but turns around to face him again*Oh, and Shelby is still waiting for you to come home, she never moved on she couldn't, but right now Rachel just needs some time without you before she sees you again.

Robby:Wait, that girl was Rachel?

Finn:Yeah.

Robby:She looks just lke Shleby.

Finn:I know.*gets in his car and drives to his*

---Finn's House---

Finn:*walks into the house*I'm home.

Carole:*walks downstairs*Hi, sweetie.

Finn:How is she?

Carole:Well, she's asleep right now, but she hasn't stopped crying. Finn, she needs her best friend when she wakes up.

Finn:I know.*starts walk up stairs*

Carole:Finn.

Finn:*stops and turns around*Yeah?

Carole:What did you say or do to him?

Finn:I didn't do anything.

Carole:What did you say?

Finn:Everything that should have been said along time ago.*carries on walking upstairs*

Carole:*sighs*

---In Finn's Room---

Rachel:*asleep on Finn's bed*

Finn:*walks in, looks at her, smiles, strokes her hair*

Rachel:*stirs and wakes up*

Finn:Sorry, I didn't meant to wake you.

Rachel:No it's fine. So did you get my clothes?

Finn:Yeah. You know he was still there.

Rachel:What did you say?

Finn:The truth.

Rachel:Like?

Finn:I asked why he left. That you didn't know what it was like to have a father figure. That you only had a mother figure. How Shelby felt.

Rachel:What did he say?

Finn:How sorry he was. How he regrets what he did ever-

Rachel:No, I mean what did he say when you asked him why he left?

Finn:That he wasn't ready for you. Well, a child in general.

Rachel:So he just walked out on us, because of me? It was all my fault.

Finn:No it wasn't Rach, it was his, he could of helped Shelby and he would have had an amazing daughter. He missed out Rach. He doesn't know what a special girl he lost out on.

Rachel:Thank you, Finn.*kisses his cheek, hugs him*

Finn:*hugs back**pulls away*Right, you need some more sleep, so I'll just leave.*stands up*

Rachel:Wait, can you sleep with me?

Finn:*wide eyes*What?

Rachel:No I mean, just hold me, cuddle me, comfort me while I go back to sleep.

Finn:Sure.*lays down next to her, puts his arms around her waist and pulls her towards him*

Rachel:*snuggles into his chest*Goodnight Finn.

Finn:Goodnight, Rach. Sleep well.

Finchel:*fall asleep*