Terror and Envy

Uncontrolable

E.J's P.O.V~

"Calista!" I screamed, watching as her eyes closed. I thought she was dying from blood loss. I was going to kill that fucking pony bitch! Pinkamina turned around looking strangely happy to see us. "Oh goody! More playmates! Do you guys wanna play with us? You can make a tie for you if you want." the pink pony giggled. She ran at us with a knife in her mouth and jumped on BEN, but Slender grabbed her just in time. BEN stood back up and stabbed the foolish animal in her back. Screaming in pain she pleaded for us to stop. It made me even angrier when she began to wiggle and snap at Slender's tentacles trying to get free. L.J and Toby untied Calista from the table which gave me an idea on what to do with the pony. My gaze turned from the table to Slenderman, and he knew what I was thinking.
He nodded and walked over to the metal table, grabbing hold of Calista and replacing her with the snapping pony. He said nothing as he strapped her down and turned to face me. "I'm going to take the others back to the mansion. You and one other pasta may stay here to do what you wish with her. I will leave you this portal for when you done or need to leave for an emergency. Who do you wish to stay here with you?" He said in a serious tone. I looked around debating on who had the sickest mind, BEN doesn't normally kill so not him. Sally doesn't like to kill and is way to young to anyway. Masky and Hoddie only kill gruesomely when they are working together, so that only leaves Toby, Jeff, and L.J. I don't really like jeff and L.J gets extremely annoying when he kills. Therefore the only one left is Toby.
"I choose Toby." I replied. Everyone looked kinda surprised by my decision, but i didn't really care. He was the best choice, and the voices in his head will only make things worse for Pinkamina. Toby was very happy that I chose him though, and that was fine with me. At least he wasn't upset that he had to stay here with me for the next couple hours. slenderman nodded once more and grabbed everyone but me and Toby with his tentacles and teleported back to the mansion, leaving a blue portal for us. Toby looked at me and smiled. "So Jacky, how come you chose me to stay with you?" he asked. I took a glance at him and looked back at the pony growling at us. "I thought you could bring the most pain to her without being that annoying." I told him.

(WARNING! IF YOU DON'T LIKE GRAPHIC TORTURE, STOP READING HERE!)

"Oh, ok! So how do u want to start? he asked me innocently. I smiled wide and grabbed a knife. "Lets skin her alive, but make sure she stays awake! I want her to feel everything we do." I replied. Toby smiled and grabbed another knife off the table. We began to cut off her skin together ignoring her screams, but eventually Toby got bored and said he was hungry. I looked at him and smiled. "Bite her then." I told him. He didn't need to be told twice. Quickly he slid his mouth guard down and began to bite at her flesh. Though watching him eat made me hungry, so I stepped the the side if the half skinned pony and cut open her hip. I stuck my hand inside the slit I made and grabbed her kidney. I pulled the organ out and started eating it, making sure it was still attached to her so he could feel every part of my razor like teeth sliding against it.
I finished my kidney and stood back up noticing that Toby was still eating. I didn't bother him, but I did start to get annoyed by her crying. I walked to the head of the table and began to cut one of her eyes out. I found it a little amusing how she closed her eyes like it would make a difference, but I forced the knife in anyway. She screamed extremely loud. I felt as if i might go deft, Toby even stopped and covered his ears. I got tired of this fast an grabbed a scalpel from the metal tray an slammed it in her thought. She could still breath though cause I stuck it in sideways, Making sure to just damage he vocal cords.
Toby continued to chew on her skin again while I grabbed a hacksaw from the tray. I wanted to grab dinner for Seedeater before we left. I walked down to the bottom of the table and began to saw off her leg. I know Seedeater normally eats human, but mabey pony will be a nice change for him. I got the leg and set it on the floor for the moment, a I notice Toby had finished with her skin and was giving her a shot of adrenalin to keep her awake. I could tell he wasn't satisfied with just her skin, ad to be honest i was still hungry too. I grabbed the knife from her eye and started to cut open her torso.
Toby laid the needle down and pulled the muscle apart after I cut it. I started cutting through her organs searching for her other kidney, while Toby grabbed her liver and pulled it out. I finally found the organ and joined him in the cannibalism. We both left the organs attached so she could feel us eating away at her, but she started to close her eye like she was about to die. We both finished our dinner and were satisfied with our performance. With our clothes soaked in blood, I grabbed the leg as we walked through the portal leaving the pony to suffer till dead.