The Mansion (A creepypasta story)

Chapter 6 - New Game

~ Still Katrina's POV~
Ben grinned and stood up.

"I have a game we can play", he said taking off his hat. "Everyone put in a little trinket."

"Oh no.... Seriously Ben?! Why seven minutes in heaven? Why not a normal game like hide and scare?", I glared at him. I reached into my secret trench coat pocket and pulled out a beautiful crimson sharpie. Ben held the hat thingy in front of my face and I slowly dropped my precious sharpie in it. He just smirked at me and moved on to Jeff and the other boys. Jeff put in a piece of candy shaped like an eyeball for no reason. Jack pulled off one of his black gloves and dropped it in the hat. Gage put in a pair of sunglasses. Ben skipped over Toby, put in his Majora's Mask cartridge, then shoved it in his face.

"Choose wisely, little one", Ben said grinning evilly. Toby started twitching a bit. He reached in and pulled out two things. It was red and black. My eyes widened when I realized that it was my sharpie and EJ's glove. Two people? Ben jumped up and grabbed my arm and shoved me, EJ, and Toby into the closet.

"B-", Ben shut the closest door before I could retort. I huffed in annoyance. "Yeah, hate you too, jerk." I looked over at the boys and saw that they were both staring at me. I glanced at Jack. His mask was off. Then, I looked at Toby and saw that he took off his mouth guard and push his goggles up, making his hair kinda messy which, I had to admit, looked pretty sexy. Studying their faces, I realized they're not all that bad looking. I might even go as far as to say they're pretty hot. I cursed under my breath for thinking such thoughts about my friends.

"Katrina...", Jack started. He took a step closer causing me to step back. He stepped towards me again and I scooted back again only this time, my back hit Toby's chest.

"J-Jack? T-t-toby? W-we don't have to do anything you guys are uncomfortable with... You two know that right?", I said hesitantly. I've never been this close to a guy before. Let alone two. What do I do?

"Who ever said we didn't want to do anything?", EJ and Toby asked in sync. I blushed darkly. Their voices were... Different somehow. It sounded... Darker? Hoarser? I don't know but it definitely changed. Jack stepped closer and put his hands on either side of my head, making a sort of cage, trapping me against Toby's chest.

"J-J-Jack?", I stuttered again. He chuckled. My face heated up even more. Curse my stuttering, but I can't help it. I started fidgeting. This was different then when I kissed them earlier. This was- My thoughts got cut off, for EJ had placed his lips over mine and Toby started kissing my neck. My eyes closed on their own accord. Our lips moved in sync. Jack's lips were perfect. Nice and soft and warm. We broke for air. I looked up at his face, studying it. That's when Toby's lip grazed over my sweet spot. I suppressed my moan and squeezed my eyes shut in pleasure. He sucked on it and I couldn't contain my moans anymore. A tiny quiet one slipped my mouth and I felt EJ run his hands up and down my sides. Toby had stopped torturing my sensitive skin and was just hugging me close to him. I took a deep breath.

"I... Um... J-Jack? Can I ask you something?", I asked quietly, looking anywhere else but at his face. Jack hummed and nodded in approval. Biting my lip I asked, "When I-I asked who y-y-you liked and you said it was classified, was that because you liked me?"

~Jack's POV~
I... shit... Should I tell her the truth? I sighed. There's not point in not doing so. I mean I already kissed her sooo.... I guess I've got no choice now do I?

"Yeah... I-I just didn't say it because... Well... I didn't want to ruin our friendship...", I said in a low voice. She looked up at me and blushing even more, which was somehow possible. Katrina hugged me tighter.

"You could have just told me you know.", she giggled. I smiled at that.

"One more minute you three!", I heard Ben shout. Oh yeah... We're still at Jeff's place...

Toby's POV
I heard Ben yell that there was one minute left. I slowly turned her around.

"K-Katrina", I whispered in the crook her neck making her shudder. EJ hugged her from behind. I pulled away a little and grabbed her chin lightly, tilting her head up to look in my eyes. Her hazel eyes were so beautiful. I slowly leaned in and kissed her with all the passion I could muster. My eyes shut as I enjoyed the feel of her sweet, soft lips. Suddenly, light flooded into the closet and I opened my eyes. There was Ben standing there with a smirk on his face that looked somewhat forced. I pulled away from Katrina. She whimpered softly. My eyes widened and my... problem... Got worse. My face heated up a little. Ben left the three of us there. I reached up to pull on my goggles when Katrina reached up and grabbed my arm.

"Don't. You look cute like this", she said in an adorable voice. I nodded. Looking over her shoulder I saw EJ looking at her fondly. His mask was pushed up on his head. Katrina turned to face the closet opening and pulled EJ and I in front of her.

Katrina's POV

They both looked down at me then at each other. EJ turned and whispered something in Toby's ear. Toby nodded then they both looked at me again.

"Katrina... Would you-", EJ started. His cheeks reddened and he glanced at the floor.

"Hey guys! Your time was up two minutes ago! Come on", Gage shouted. The two boys jumped a little. I sighed, hugged them both, and kissed them both lightly on the mouth. I walked out of the closet and down the hallway, leaving the boys dumbstruck. I took a seat next to Jeff on the floor.