Supernatural Boyfriend Scenarios/Preferences

How You Two Became a Couple

Dean

After you thought about what Dean does, you went to find him. The two of you talked and you told him you were ready to move forward with him. So you moved forward, to his bed.

Sam

Once you two were done researching a monster like you usually did, you weren't too busy to think. You were now not sure where you and Sam stood. So you decided to ask him.

"Sam, what are we? Work partners, friends?" You questioned as Sam packed up.

"I thought we were dating already." Sam told you honestly.

"Oh, well alright then." You smiled at Sam. "I'm glad."

"Good." Sam kissed the top of your head before going off to kill a monster.

Castiel

Castiel was a very confusing man. You were never sure what was going on in his mind. You also weren't sure why he was around you. You had no clue what the two of you were, so you needed to ask.

"Cas, are we together?" You questioned as he stared at your kitten on the floor.

"We are together (Y/N). You are right there and I am here." The clueless angel responded.

"No, I mean are we a couple, like dating?"

"Do you want to be?"

"Do you?"

"Yes (Y/N), I do."

"Then alright. We're together."

Crowley

Already Crowley's queen because of the deal.

Balthazar

You and Balthazar have been on quite a few dates and have done some things together but you weren't sure what the label on you two were. You didn't know if you were just friends with benefits or more. You two were laying in bed, you were almost asleep when you decided to ask.

"Am I your whore?" you bluntly asked. Balthazar sat up and looked at you startled.

"My dear, you'd never be a simple whore. That's far too low, don't call yourself that."

"Then am I your girlfriend?"

"I thought it was obvious darling. Of course you are."

"Good." You smiled brightly at him and leaned over to kiss your boyfriend.

Gabriel

You knew of Gabriel's ways, the women, tricks killing people, but the only thing that upset you, was the girls. Sure they were fake, but they were still other women. What made it worse was that you weren't even sure if you were allowed to feel jealous since you had no clue if Gabriel even cared for you in that way. Being your guardian angel, he could sense that something was off with you.

"(Y/N), what's wrong? You seem upset." Gabriel said when he appeared in your room.

"What am I to you? Am I just some job, some lower being to protect?" You questioned, rolling away from him. You heard Gabriel sigh and felt him climb into bed with you. he wrapped his arms around you and pulled you close.

"Everything (Y/N), you are everything to me." Gabriel whispered.

"What?"

"I thought that you could tell that, but I guess not." Gabriel chuckled.

"So does that mean...?"

"We're a thing? Of course cupcake."

Lucifer

Lucifer was, well he's Lucifer. He's the devil. You had no idea why he'd keep a simple human like you around. You wanted to know, but you were scared to confront him. Thankful for you, Lucifer noticed you were a bit confused, so he decided to confront you. he questioned why you weren't as happy as you had been before, and you told him why. Instead of getting mad at you like you thought he would, he chuckled at you.

"You silly little human, you aren't just some lesser being to me. You are my queen, what humans say, my girlfriend."

"Does that mean I can order your demons around?" You for some reason really wanted to do that without being murdered for it.

"Yes, they'll respect and follow you as they would me, or they will die." You smiled at Lucifer and kissed his cheeks. His answer was much better than you expected it to be, and you were thankful for that.

Kevin

You and Kevin demon-proofed the motel, and continued to hang out like nothing happened. There was only one problem, the two of you were acting like a couple but you didn't know if you were or not. You knew that Kevin had a girlfriend, but you weren't sure what happened with her. As the two of you hung out on your day off, you asked him about it. He told you that she was dead but that he was over her.

"I was kind of hoping that we could try to be a thing." Kevin admitted to you.

"I hope I don't end up like your last girlfriend." You responded, half chuckling.

"Yeah, me too."

Chuck

"So Chuck, you see the future, right?" You asked suddenly, though you knew the answer. There had been something you were curious about for a while.

"Yeah, what are you getting at?" Chuck responded, setting his glass of alcohol down.

"What do you see us becoming?"

"Do you really want to know? I don't want to scare you off or anything."

"Tell me Chuck." You smiled at him, hopeful.

"We become a couple. That's what 've seen so far, but it doesn't have to happen if-" You cut Chuck off by kissing him.

"It's exactly what I want." You kissed Chuck again; happy about what he saw and hoped this meant you were a couple now.

Benny

After you woke up, you told Benny you didn't want to leave. You wanted to stay with him, and you were getting what you wanted since he couldn't just let you go now. After a week with your new best friend, he told you that he needed to talk to you.

"I haven't felt like this towards a woman in a very long time." Benny explained to you. "I hope I'm not being to forward, but I'd like to court...I mean date you." You smiled at Benny and hugged him.

"I'd like that very much." You told him right before he kissed you.