Supernatural Boyfriend Scenarios/Preferences

When He Tells You Who/What He Is

Dean

You and Dean had been casually hanging out for a while. He admitted that he wanted more, but you refused. He disappeared for a long amount of time and came back beaten up. You needed to know what he does when he's away if you were going to move forward with him. You told Dean that and he got irritated and left. It was now midnight and you were getting ready for bed when you heard a knock at your door. When you opened it, Dean was there.

"If you want to know what I do when I'm gone, then I'll tell you." Dean told you calmly.

"Come in Dean." You led Dean to your couch and sat down.

"I'm a hunter. I hunt monsters with my brother. I save people. That's what I do when I'm gone." Dean said simply.

"Monsters? Like bad people?"

"No, like vampires, werewolves, shapeshifters. That type of monster."

"Why should I believe you?"

"You don't have to, but you wanted to know." With that Dean stood up. "Think about it. I'll see you later, or not if you don't want to see me again." Dean kissed your cheek then left you alone in your living room.

Sam

Ever since Sam needed help with research on a werewolf, he's asked you for help with a few other beings. He kept telling you that it was for a school paper, but you knew he was lying. Once he got the information he needed, he would leave for a few days just to return hurt in some way. You told same that you knew he was lying to you and to either tell the truth or stop asking you for help. You were in his motel room with him, waiting for his response.

"Okay (Y/N), I'll tell you." Sam started, "My brother and I hunt monsters. The kinds you've helped me research. We save people." Sam explained hoping you'd believe him.

"So this is real?" You asked pointing to a wendigo.

"Yeah, all of it is real."

"You're insane...but I believe you. So I guess I'm insane too." You smiled at him. You could see he was relieved that you believed him.

"Thank you."

"When can I meet your brother?" you could see Sam's eyes widen.

"Never?" You two chuckled, but you were going to meet him. You have your own way to get what you want.

Castiel

You and the clueless man began spending a lot of time together. You'd go to a park and feed the ducks or go to a playground and swing on the swings. One of the days you were at the park, you decided to jump off of the swing. You landed wrong and it caused you to break your ankle.

"(Y/N), it'll be okay." Castiel told you as he appeared at your side.