Supernatural Boyfriend Scenarios/Preferences

First Kiss

Dean

You had been keeping Dean at arms length literally and figuratively. You weren't ready to let the man into your bed or feel anything for him. Dean showed up at your bar every night for the past few days. He managed to keep the creeps away, but tonight he was late, and the creeps were using that to their advantage.

"Listen, I have a boyfriend so back off." You told another creep once again. You were lying, but they'd seen you and Dean flirt, so it was believable enough.

"That guy in the Impala is your boyfriend, huh? I don't believe you. You two never kiss."

"Just go away, alright." You were cleaning a table, so you had no way to just block the man's advances. You shouldn't have been, but you were surprised when the creep grabbed your butt. You gasped and spun around, but you didn't get the chance to slap him. Dean had walked in, saw it and punched the man.

"You okay babe?" Dean asked as he pulled you to him.

"Yeah, thank you."

"Anything for you." He smiled at you and you couldn't resist this tie. You leaned up and pressed your lips to his. He instantly responded and began kissing back. You knew the creeps now would leave you alone, but all that was on your mind at the moment was Dean's lips on yours.

Sam

Sam returned the books, like he said he would, but he needed help with another subject. It was one you were good with and had research on. Sam took you to his motel room where the two of you discussed the supernatural/mythical being. You were concerned about Sam though, it seemed like he was looking for a werewolf, not a real being.

"Thank you, so much (Y/N), this is really helpful." Sam told you once he figured out what he needed.

"No problem, this was fun." You smiled at him. You didn't hang out with many people so spending so much time with Sam was really amazing. "Well I should get going. It's getting late."

"Yeah, let me walk you home."

"I'm a big girl Sam, I'll be fine." You chuckled as you stood up. You went to move forward, but your foot got caught on something causing you to fall onto Sam. He lost his balance and fell to the ground. To both of your surprises, your heads smacked together, making the two of you kiss. Instantly you two pull apart.

"I'm sorry (Y/N)."

"It was my fault..." You and Sam looked into each other's eyes, and kissed once again.

Castiel

You hadn't seen Castiel since the day you met him. You couldn't help but wonder about him. For a grown man he seemed a little clueless. Though right now, Castiel was far from your mind. Two men were robbing the store. Once had their weapon pointed at you while the other was taking the money and anything else they wanted.