Teen Wolf Imagines

Second Choice | Scott

Lets just agree that Tyler Posey is an amazing human being, mkay?

*YOUR POV*

"Allison.."

Scott has been doing this since we started dating, it was after Allison died, he mumbled her name every time we fell asleep together, but it just seemed to keep me up, I understood that Allison was a big part in his life, but we've been dating for a month now, and it just wouldn't stop.

When Allison and Scott did date, Allison told me that if she ever did die due to the Nogitsune or Dread Doctors, she wanted me to be the one to date Scott, so that's exactly what I did, I love him, god I love him so much, but I'm not sure if he feels the same way, he wants someone else, not me.

"Scott," I whispered, shaking him, but he just ignored me as if I wasn't even there, I almost wanted to burst into tears.

Scott would sometimes call me Allison, and it hurts, he doesn't love me, he loves someone else, so I just got up out of bed, deciding to move to Scott's couch instead, considering that he'll be too busy thinking about Allison.

I put my hair in a messy bun before walking off to Scott's living room.

I used to get a little nervous when I was with Scott, because he is an Alpha after all, and I'm just this normal person who moved here to live a normal life, but like that's ever gonna happen.

I found an extra blanket lying around here, so I just rested on the couch, pulling the blanket up to my chin, tears threatening to spill out because I wasn't the one Scott wanted, I never was, the only person he wanted was Allison, and it hurts, not being the person that your boyfriend loves.

"Alli- Y/N?" I heard Scott's voice from his room, there he goes again, mistaking me for Allison, I swear I could just start crying right now, and that's when a tear slipped from my eye, I closed my eyes just to calm myself for a moment, before opening them back up to see Scott right in front of m.

"Thank god you're okay, please don't do that ever- hey, you're crying, what's wrong?" Scott asked me, wiping my tear with his thumb, I sat up, more tears running down my face.

"Alliso- Y/N, please don't cry," Every time he spoke, my heart broke a little more, I got up from my spot, beginning to walk to the front door.

I put my shoes and jacket on while Scott was asking what was wrong, and he was so confused, he had no idea this hurt me more than it hurt him.

"Scott, I-I'm sorry," I cried.

"For what? There's nothing to be sorry for," Scott reassured, but I shook my head.

"I-I'm sorry for not being the girl you want, that I'm not what you're looking for, and for being the girl you don't love, I'm sorry for not being Allison," I confessed, and before I new it, Scott was crying as well.

"N-no Y/N, I do love-" I cut him off, not wanting to cry harder.

"Please Scott, don't make this harder for me, I know you still love her, you've been mistaking me for her and mumbling her name at night since we started dating, this hurts me more than it hurts you, I love you Scott but I'm not sure if you love me, I'm really sorry."

And that's when I walked out the door, and the thing that hurt me the most, is he let me go.

>> A/N <<

I think I cried a little for this, but part two possibly?