Tyler Or Kevin? (Tyler Brown X Reader)

School

So after Kevin's house, I went home. I texted both for awhile, and went out with Kylie for awhile.

~Tyler's Pov~

After Sapphire left Kevin's house, he came to my house. He looked kinda upset.

"What's wrong?" I ask.

"Well, if I tell you, promise you won't be mad, okay?" He says with a worried face. "Ok, I won't." I say. Hopefully it's not too bad.

"Ok, I asked Sapphire out.." He says.

My mind goes blank.

"What did she say?" I ask trying not to freak out.

"She didn't say yes, but she didn't say no either. She said she has to think about it. But she also said, 'Tyler well..well nevermind.' What was she talking about?" He asks.

"Well, I might of asked her out too..but she said the same thing to me as she did to you. She said she liked both of us and she needs to think about it." I explain. "Oh. But look, whoever she says yes to, let's not me bad at the other person, okay?" He says. I agree.

~TimeSkip to next day~

~Your Pov~

I wake up and see that the guys have made a group chat.

T- Hey guys

K- hey Tyler and sapph

T- Sapph u awake yet?

K - she's probably still sleeping

T- yeah

S- hey. I'm up

K- oh heyy

T- hi Sapph

S- hey. Are we still walking together?

T- yeah. We'll be there in like 25 minutes ok?

K- yeah

S- ok. See u guys then. Bai💕

K- bye💘

T- bye💖

After texting I get my clothes and get dressed. I then eat my cereal and grab my backpack. I open the door and see Tyler and Kevin walking up to my door. I say hi to them and we talk on the way to school. When we get there, I go to my classes and then it's lunch. That's when Tyler and Kevin introduce me to their friends. But, Jacob is there.

I hope he doesn't know that I said I didn't like him on You Now..

~Jacobs Pov~

When Tyler and Kevin introduce Sapphire to everyone at the table, I immediately fall in love.

She's perfect..

I can't help but stare at her the whole time. But I stop when Tyler catches me and and gives me a dirty look. Probably because they're dating? No, they can't be. Tyler would of said it. I decide to ask. While Sapph is talking, I whisper to Tyler. "Is she dating anyone?" I ask. "No, but she will be soon." He says getting annoyed. "Who?" I ask. "You'll see." He says and turns around and listens to Sapph again. I have to ask who she likes. She has to like someone here.

~Mark's Pov~

While Sapph is talking, I see Jacob and Tyler staring at her. I don't blame them.

She's so pretty. And so funny. And sooo nice.

Pretty much everyone at the table likes her already. Especially Tyler. I see Jacob staring at her and Tyler gives him a dirty look and pretty much giving him a look that is telling him to back off. When it comes to girls that Tyler likes, he's always giving people looks if he catches them staring at her. But I think I know who she likes. It's probably Tyler. Everyone likes Tyler. And legit EVERYONE. It's because he has the stereotypical cute teenage boy face. Dimples, freckles, the hair, he has style, and everything else. Like yeah, we're friends, but sometimes it's really annoying. He gets all the girls. It's because he has the power to just lure girls his way. Once there was this girl he liked but she didn't like him. But, Tyler eventually got her to like him. He uses it on everyone who doesn't like him. He just has the ability to lure any girl he likes to his arms. But, he has only had like 2 girlfriends before. But, he has liked quite a few girls before. But eventually he stopped liking them and only went out with 2 of them. Loren and Ariel. Yep, Loren and Ariel. The 2 most popular girls in school and known for their awesome Musical.ly's. But, he only went out with Ariel for a week. He said they never kissed though, which is surprising. He went out with Loren for about a month, and only kissed once. Which is also very surprising. But they broke up because they didn't really feel anything between them anymore, but they are still friends. It's probably gonna happen with him and Sapph though.

~Tyler's Pov~

While she's talking, I notice that everyone is staring at her. But not because she's talking, it's because they like her. It's really getting on my nerves. Hopefully she'll say yes to me and they can stop staring at her 24/7. Ugh.
Just then, Jacob cuts her off and asks if she likes anyone.

This fucker.

She's speechless. I know who she likes. But she looks like she doesn't wanna answer.

Does she like any one else?! Oh god I hope not.

"Do you?" Mark asks. I give him a look.

Why is he asking her now?

She still looks confused.

"Uhh..well, yeah. Two people actually. I'm not really naming them though so it's not so weird.." She says uncomfortably. I get angry. Why would they ask her that? They don't even know her! I look at Kevin and see him get a little angry.

"Why are you asking?" Kevin asks angrily.

"I don't know. Maybe because I'm curious? What's your problem?" Jacob asks. "Because you guys just met her and you're already asking if she likes anyone, like you want to know so you can make a move." He gets angrier. So does Jacob. Sapph is shocked. And so is everyone else. Kevin rarely ever starts arguments. "Ok, so what if-" Jacob tries to talk but I cut him off. "Leave Kevin alone, asshole." I say angrily. Sapph then gets in. "Stop! Jesus christ! You're all acting like idiots! Who cares if I like anyone?! I said I like two people, and they're Kevin and Tyler, okay?! Can you stop being idiots now?" She says angrily and everyone goes silent. A few seconds later, lunch ends. Everyone one leaves, and Sapph is still mad. Thankfully we have the same class together right after lunch so I can talk to her on the way.

"You alright?" I ask hoping she's not mad at me.

"Not really." She says angrily.

"Are you mad at me?"

"No. Pretty much just Jacob and Mark." She says.

"Oh. Ok. Yeah, that was pretty fucked up to ask." I agree.

"Kevin was right, I bet Jacob did ask me that so he can make a move on me. Fucked up." She says. I agree, it is pretty fucked up. "Yeah." I say and we walk to class.

Sorry if this chapter if short and boring, but the next one will be exciting 😆