Ticci Toby x Reader LEMON

ITC #1 (CrystalTheCanibal Pt. 2)

"Welcome to my playroom." Toby said.

You, astonished, looked around at all of the toys and gadgets. You didn't know what most of the toys were called, but you saw a few whips, collars, and handcuffs. "How did you even get all of this stuff?" BEN asked. Toby sat down on a dark red bed with silk blankets. "Most of it I bought, some of the more... extravagant I stole." He said. You couldn't move your body, only your eyes and barely your head. "And why are we in here?" BEN asked. Toby suddenly looked at you. "She wants to act like a whore, you are going to be a whore." He said sharply. You could feel your face heat up. A moment that felt like an hour passed before Toby stood and walked in front of you.

He stared at you for a moment, his eyes gazing over your flushed body. Your face burst into flames. You could hear BEN snicker loudly from afar. He was just trying to piss you off, and it was working at the moment. W-what?!" You exclaimed in BEN's direction. Toby grabbed your chin and snapped your head towards him. His eyes seemed to become darker as you stared into them. "You are going to be seen as a whore because you have been acting like one. I'm surprised you haven't straight up fucked every Pasta in this mansion, Y/N." He said, his eyes cold but aflame.

You gulped. "Y-yes sir..." You said quietly, your cheeks as red as blood. Toby smirked. "I want to do a little dress-up." He said. You stared at your feet; you've always wanted to dress up for him, but you didn't have the guts to tell him. Toby walked to a chest and opened it, taking out a tail and a pair of cat ears. He placed them in your hands. "Put these on, kitten." He said. You nodded and placed the cat ears on your head. You looked at the tail and noticed there was no strap on it. "How do I put this on?" You asked softly. You could hear BEN snicker at you. "It's a butt plug, Y/N." Toby said. You stared at the tail. "What do you do with it?" You asked. BEN laughed and Toby rolled his eyes.

"You put it in your butt like a plug to an outlet." Toby said bluntly. You gasped. "B-but I've never had anything in there before!" You protested. Toby shrugged. "This'll be your first then. Strip of your clothes before I have to, and you wouldn't like me doing that." Toby said, crossing his arms. You gulped and laid the 'butt plug' down on the bed, quickly taking off your clothes as Toby watched. You could feel BEN's eyes on you, but it helped that he was quiet. Your eyes stared at Toby's clothed chest, then his belt buckle. Your eyes snapped down to his crotch; you could see the large bulge in his pants. Remembering what your had to do next, you reached for the butt plug. Suddenly, you say Toby's hand grab it first. "What was that?" He asked lowly in your ear. You looked up at him. "What was what?" You asked. Toby snatched the butt plug away from you.

"Did I ask you to look at me like that?" Toby hissed, the butt plug firmly grasped in his hand. "W-what? No, you didn't! Can't I look at you?" You asked. You could see a faint red begin to swell on Toby's cheeks. "No! You look at me when I tell you!" He said, his voice slightly cracking. Was he... embarrassed? You gulped. "I-I'm sorry, sir." You said quietly. Toby huffed, his cheeks getting redder. "Just don't do it again, okay?" He asked quietly. You held back a snicker and nodded feebly. "Bend over on the bed." Toby demanded. You gulped and obeyed, slightly spreading your legs, knowing what was coming. But instead of feeling a butt plug pressed against your other hole, you saw Toby sit on the edge. "BEN, you mind lending a hand?" He asked.

Your heart practically stopped when you heard this and BEN beginning to walk over to you. "Mind holding her hand behind her back?" Toby asked him, gently running his hand through your hair. "Will do." BEN said, gently grabbing your hands and pinning them behind your back. Fighting back would be useless, for you had a feeling that it would only get you punished or you would hurt yourself in a way. You felt Toby's hand cup your chin, turning your head towards him to look at you. "This might or might not hurt a little, I'm not sure about you." He said quietly. You gulped and croaked out a feeble "Yes, sir". Toby held your gaze as he pressed the tip of the butt plug on your other hole. You let out a tiny gasp. Toby began to very slowly push in the butt plug. Although in slight pain, shocks of pleasure surged through your body, leading up to your mouth, making you moan. You squirmed slightly, this feeling abnormal for you. Toby petted you with his other hand.

"It's about halfway in, kitten. You'll be okay." He said softly. You clenched your restrained hands as you felt Toby push it in more. Each inch in further, your moans got louder and more persistent. You suddenly felt the plug all the way in, as if you sucked it in. Flushed, you face-planted into the mattress, your hands relaxing, your body pulsing with pure pleasure. You felt your hands be released. The bed rose as Toby got up, patting your head. "Although you were a good girl now, you are in here because you've been a bad, bad girl to me." He said, almost as if he was teasing a 5 year old. "As usual, I'm going to punish you for what you've done and you are going to get your mind fucked out of you." He said. You gulped, half excited, half scared. You could feel Toby bend down to your ear, his warm breath fanning over your ear as he said those three dreaded words.

"Both of us." He whispered.