Supernatural One Shots

Claire Taking Revenge Out on Castiel (Alternate Ending)

Claire Novak didn't know all the details, but she knew enough. Her dad left. The last time she saw him, the man inside his body said "I am not your father." Years later, things had changed. Her mom had left. She wasn't a little girl anymore. She knew what had happened to her dad, and she was going to make things right.

She'd been preparing for this for years.

She found an angel and caught it by surprise. The angel thought she was asking for help and guidance. The angel was kind; she hated to kill it. Still, she needed the blade to hurt, possibly kill, Castiel. Castiel wasn't like the other angel; he deserved to die.

It's time. Claire had found a secluded place where no one would be able to find them. The circle of holy oil was prepared on the ground. The lighter was in her hand. She made sure the lighter had enough juice in it, and it would light. Her backpack sat behind her, open, with the angel blade in it. Castiel wouldn't be able to see it, but she'd be able to get it fast if she needed to.

There was no hesitation. Claire knelt on the ground, with her head down. She wanted Castiel to think she was hurt so he'd be more likely to stay.

"Castiel. It's Claire Novak. I know you're an angle and you can hear me. I'm the daughter of Jimmy Novak; you took his body. I need help. My mom's gone and I'm hurt. Please come."

She grinned, her face still by her hair. There was the whoosh of wings and she saw Castiel's shoes in front of her. Perfect. He was inside the circle.

"Claire. I'm here. Are you alright?" He sounded concerned, but that must be fake.

"Yeah. I'm okay. But you won't be." She flicked the lighter on and threw it on the circle.

Castiel backed away from her, but he couldn't escape. "I don't understand." His eyes followed the flames of the circle before he looked up at her. "Claire."

Hot, angry tears rolled down her cheek. "You killed my dad! You took him from me, you fucking bastard!" She wiped her face and tried to collect her self.

"I –" Castiel began.

"No! You don't get to talk. Who gave you the right?!"

Claire turned around and took the blade out the bag. She tested the weight of it in her hand, and put the tip to her finger. "You picked the wrong family to fuck with, Castiel."

"He chose this, Claire. Your dad asked for this."

"No." She shook her head violently. "I don't believe that."

•••

Half an hour later, she managed to chain him to the ground and gag him. The circle of fire was big enough for her to step inside as well.

"Now comes the fun part." She put the tip of blade to the base of his throat. Castiel was actually trying to resist, making noises and squirming.

"Oh, my god. You're afraid. This makes it so much better." She laughed hard. She flicked the blade down his chest. Castiel's shout was muffled by the gag. He breathed hard when he realized she'd only knocked the buttons off his shirt.

"Think I'm going to carve the sigil into your chest before I bleed you dry." She chuckled and waved the blade nonchalantly. "I'm somewhat of an artist, you know. I've been practicing." She knelt down and put her mouth next to his ear, whispering, "I want this to be perfect."

Claire took her time, relishing in Castiel's screams and the bright light that escaped him with each cut.

She made him sit up. She moved behind him and wrapped her legs tightly around him. Claire reached for a bowl and set it on the ground. She jerked Castiel's arm up and held his wrist tightly in her hand. She moved the bowl under his arm and grabbed the blade.