Ugly Scars Make You Beautiful (Ticci Toby Love Story)

10

Sally began to panic more and crawled out the other side and began running. She ran as fast as her little legs could go; she looked back seeing him look at her then began running after her. Sally gasped and looked ahead; hearing him screech and growl made her scared more, he was gaining on her. She didn't know what happened to Cassie; she didn't see her. Sally saw the manor ahead of her and picked up the pace, but she tripped over a root grunting in pain; she turned to face him as The Rake walked towards her as she began to back away "Daddy!" She screamed in fear. Slender came outside to see what was going on; He leaped at her as she screamed, Slender couldn't get her in time. She closed her eyes and shield herself, but only felt a sharp pain in her arm, nothing else happened. Sally heard him grunt and growl like he was struggling; she looked up and seen him being dragged away from her by Cassie. Slender picked her up as they both saw Cassie pull him back more and began beating on him. They stood there and watched as Toby and some of the other Pasta's came out. Cassie didn't stop hitting him; her knuckled split opened and began to bleed as she hit him. She hit him as hard she could until he was knocked out; she began panting and shaking as she wiped some of the blood off her lips. Toby quickly went over to her "A-Are you al-alright?" He asked with worry looking at the deep wounds, but she just nodded. "Cassie." Sally said as Slender put her down. Cassie limped over to her "Sally I'm so sorry." She said, kneeling down before her and looked at the cut on her face and her arm "Are you alright?" She asked. Sally cried and hugged her as Cassie hugged her back "What about you? I thought h-" Cassie only shushed her as Sally hugged her tightly "I'm fine." Cassie said softly. Toby was right beside her when Cassie let her go.

"Thank you child." Cassie only nodded as Slender took Sally inside to take care of her cuts. Toby was right beside Cassie "Y-You're so re-reckless." He said to her. She almost fell down, but luckily he caught her in time "Let's g-get you t-to Dr. Sm-Smiley." He said and picked her up and carried her inside. 

 ~Toby~

Once I got Cassie downstairs to the basement, I sat her down onto the table. I stayed there while Dr. Smiley began treating her wounds on her arms, legs, and the one across her chest without asking any questions on what happened. I grabbed Cassie's hands to look at her now bruised and bleeding knuckles "You r-really beat th-the shit o-out of him." I said to her and cleaned them off. Cassie smiled "Yeah..." She replied "He almost had me." She admitted in annoyance; I just chuckled. Cassie winced in pain "Sorry." Dr. Smiley said plainly. He continued stitching her wounds "Luckily you were there." I said to her. She chuckled a little "You know that I would have."

When Dr. Smiley got done I helped her down from the table "She needs to rest. Don't do anything rational or the wounds will open up." Cassie thanked him before we left basement to take her to her room. I helped her along the way "Thanks." I opened the door to her room "No p-problem." I replied.

~~~

A week went by after that incident with the Rake; Cassie was healed enough to move around better and she had the chance to settle in. She had trouble here and there getting along with Jeff and some of the Pasta's there though other then that she got along with everyone. She helped around the manor when anyone needed it or mostly hung around Toby when he wasn't on a killing spree.

Late one night, toby went upstairs to Cassie's room. He stopped "Hey Cassie!" He barged into her room. He stopped "Toby get out!" Cassie covered herself quickly though her back was facing him; He didn't listen, he was shocked at what he saw. He walked over to her, not listening to her demands. He was standing behind her; Cassie knew what he was staring at making her down in shame, yet embarrassment. Cassie tensed up when she felt him gently touch her back. He glided his fingers over the ugly scarring "He did this to you." Toby began to twitch more and stuttered less. Cassie relaxed at his touch and nodded as he continued gliding his fingers over the scarring all over her back. He couldn't say sorry; that wouldn't fix anything, nor remove the scares. His blood began to boil yet he felt sick to his stomach when he felt every deep scarring "Cassie I-" "Toby, I really don't want to talk about this." Cassie's voice quivered as she quickly put on a tank top before putting on her jacket "When did that happened?" He looked at her "What did you need earlier?" He sighed because she changed the subject. He didn't remember; he forgot the moment when he saw the deep ugly scarring all over her back "I forgot. I'll just go." He sighed before leaving her room and shutting the door behind him. Her eyes began to tear up, but she held them back.

Toby leaned against her door; he couldn't shake the image out of his head. Whatever happened to her was because of him; he was blaming himself and it made him even more sick. He walked down that hall from her room "If only..." After an hour or so, Cassie hasn't came out of her room, so he just told everyone to leave her alone.

~Toby~

Days passed by, Cassie wouldn't make eye contact with me and she would tense up a little when someone touches her back or touch her at all. I knew why she was like that; it was because of what I saw "Toby your girlfriend is acting weird." I rolled my eyes when Masky said that. I gave up on telling everyone she wasn't my girlfriend "she'll be fine." I headed upstairs to check on her again. I knocked on the door lightly "Cassie." The door opened, revealing her "Hey Toby." She looked down "I wanted to say sorry about walking in on you like that before." She sighed "You weren't suppose to see that." I could see that she was embarrassed more than anything. She looked up at me and smiled "I'll be fine." I wasn't stupid "I kn-know you w-well enough to know th-that is fake." She frowned and looked away from me again"I'm just embarrassed." I sighed "and you want to know about what happened." I made her look up at me "i won't force you to tell me." She nodded "And you shouldn't feel that way." I reassured. She sighed "how can I not? They're ugly scarring and memories that won't go away." I didn't reply back. I placed my hand on her shoulder "I will get him for this." Cassie just smile "I know."