Creepy Pasta Boyfriend Scenarios

When you meet again

(Btw I'm gonna use some swear word from now on in my book now)
Ticci Toby

You ended up back in the same alley as before hoping to run into the guy again. You continue walking but this time it seemed like everything was getting so dark before you were in complete darkness. You then realize that when you look around and notice that your not in the alleyway and you're now in a thick forest. You try and look for city lights but when you come up with nothing realize how deep in the forest you are.

"Fuckkkk, how did I end up in this stupid forest I was just in the alley?" I lean up against a tree suddenly feeling nauseous.

You hear static soon enter through your ears as you try hard to block off the noise by covering your ears. The noise soon goes away as you look up and notice it's the guy from yesterday. You uncover your ears and stare up at him surprised to see him here.

"What are you doing here?" I ask curiously.

"Umm I came to apologize for yesterday..." He says rubbing his arm awkwardly.

"Uh, in a forest?" You say raising your eyebrow questioning him.

He nods slowly as you stand up your legs feeling like jelly. You try and balance yourself before your legs are finally normal. You look up at him and the you extend your hand waiting for him to shake it. The guy accepts as he shakes your hand and then retracts his hand.

"My names Y/N." You say smiling.

"Toby or Ticci Toby, as they call me." He says back to you.

You give him a smile as he smiles back at you.

"Friends?" You ask.

"Friends." He answers smiling.
Jeff the Killer

You've had insomnia for the past few weeks, ever since that... Incident. You cannot shake off the feeling of being watched no matter what. Even when with a friend you still get the feeling. You've told no one since they'll probably just think you're crazy and suggest you go to a therapist or something. So you just keep everything bottled up for now. At night you stay up late worried he'll come back for you again.

Tonight will be different because he hasn't came for the past couple weeks. You sigh as you cuddle into the blankets more looking for heat. You get a sudden chill down your spine but you chose to ignore it. You close your eyes and fall asleep instantly. You'll probably get a good nights sleep tonight.

Later on in the night you wake up and need to go to the bathroom. You get out of bed and instantly regret it feeling wide awake with the warmth leaving your body so quickly.

You slowly make your way for the bathroom. You then feel arms wrap around your body and you being at least half awake lean into the body for warmth. You end up falling asleep in the persons arms.

The next morning you wake up and lean into the body and get comfortable. You're eyes widen quickly in realization when you remember you fell asleep alone. You turn around quickly and inspect the person and realize it was the same guy from a few weeks ago. You scream as you try and get out of his grasp as his arms tighten around you.

After about 5-10 minutes you realize there's no way out and finally give up. You hear him sigh as he pulls you closer.

"I wanted to say sorry from what happened the last time we met..." He says like he's never said sorry before.

Your face turns into a confused one as you stare up into his eyes. He stares back down into yours as he finally let's go. You stay completely still as you lay next to him. You observe him and notice he's wearing a white hoodie and jeans. You look at his face and it's still cut open and his eyes are still the same. You lift your hand up to his face and feel around the ridge of his cuts. You retract your hands slowly as you stare back up at him.